Obligations to the Public

When safety and loyalty collide, safety wins, and the engineer says so in writing.

A project meeting for a new parking garage. Your check says a transfer girder is undersized. Your boss says it's fine, the owner says the drawings go out Friday, and the meeting moves on to the next item.

What do you do before Friday? Going along won't do. Neither will quitting, quietly fixing the sheet, or calling a reporter, though each of those feels right to someone. There's one correct response, and the exam asks for it in many disguises.

The one party with no seat at the table

Look at who was in that meeting, and who wasn't.

Owner Project manager Contractor Your boss You The public
Everyone with a stake is in the room, with one exception

Everyone at the table can look after themselves. The owner can hire another engineer, the contractor can file a claim, and your boss can weigh the firm's risk. The people who'll park under that girder next spring can do none of that. They can't read the calculations, and they'll never hear about the meeting. Someone has to speak for them, and that's what your license is for.

So the rules make it your first duty. The exam tests the NCEES Model Rules, whose Rules of Professional Conduct the Handbook reprints, rather than your personal morals or any one society's code. They bind every licensee, meaning every licensed engineer or surveyor. The first rule of the first group reads:

Licensees shall be cognizant that their first and foremost responsibility is to safeguard the health, safety, and welfare of the public when performing services for clients and employers.

The Handbook sorts its rules under three headings: obligations to the public (A), to employer and clients (B), and to other licensees (C). This Lesson names a rule by its letter and number, so that one is A.1. Stack the headings with the public on top, and you have what this topic calls the ladder.

Higher rung wins The public A. Obligations to the Public safety, overruled judgment, truthfulness Employer and clients B. Obligations to Employer and Clients competence, confidentiality, conflicts Other licensees C. Obligations to Other Licensees qualifications, commissions, errors, criticism
The ladder of duties
Each rung is one heading of the Handbook's rules, with a few of the subjects it covers.

Source: Adapted from the FE Reference Handbook, Rules of Professional Conduct

When two duties collide, the higher rung wins. The Handbook never says its three groups are ranked, and "first and foremost" is its only ranking language, but the exam's answers follow this order. The headings also double as an index: to find a rule, ask who it protects. On most days all three rungs point the same way. The ladder only matters on the days they don't.

Checkpoint

A design change would save the client $200,000, keep the firm's largest account happy, and spare a respected colleague an awkward correction. It would also weaken the fire protection on an occupied floor. Under the Model Rules, which of these is the licensee's first and foremost responsibility?

A.
Staying within the client's budget
B.
Loyalty to the employer
C.
The public's health, safety, and welfare
D.
Courtesy toward other licensees
E.
The firm's profit

When you get overruled

Back to the garage. Your judgment has been overruled on something that can hurt people, and rule A.3 covers exactly that:

Licensees shall notify their employer or client and such other authority as may be appropriate when their professional judgment is overruled when the health, safety, or welfare of the public is endangered.

It doesn't ask you to win the argument, or even to be certain, since your boss might turn out to be right. It asks that the risk reach people who can act on it. That takes two moves, in order, and this topic calls them the escalation sequence:

  1. Notify your employer or client, in writing. Say what can happen if the design stands, the possible consequences, and not merely that you disagree.
  2. If the danger isn't corrected, notify the appropriate authority. That usually means the building official, who can stop the work.

A.3 itself says only "notify," with no "in writing" and no stated order, but expect the exam's right answer to have both. The writing makes the notice stick: a warning in a hallway can be forgotten or denied, and a letter can't. Your employer or client goes first because they can fix it fastest.

Your judgment is overruled and the public is endangered 1. Notify your employer or client, in writing, of the possible consequences Corrected? Yes Done No 2. Notify the appropriate authority, such as the building official Dead ends Go along with it Resign quietly Fix it without telling anyone Go to the media first
The escalation sequence and its dead ends

Each dead end appeals to a different instinct. The Handbook doesn't mention resigning or the media, so reason them out by asking who ends up knowing what:

  • Going along. "The boss is senior" and "the client is paying" tell you who runs the project, not who gets hurt. Nothing about the danger has changed.
  • Resigning quietly. Your hands are clean, and the girder is the same size. The next engineer doesn't know what you know.
  • Fixing it without telling anyone. The people who overruled you still think the old design is fine, nobody looks for the same mistake elsewhere, and the next revision can undo your fix.
  • Going to the media first. A reporter can't stop a pour. The people who can haven't heard from you yet.
A habit for any ethics question

Eliminate any answer that puts profit, convenience, or loyalty ahead of public safety. Among what remains, pick the most transparent option that uses proper channels.

Worked Example The undersized girder
1 of 3

You're the licensed engineer checking the garage design for your firm. Your calculations show a transfer girder is undersized for its load. Your supervisor, a principal with 30 years in practice, tells you to drop it, since the drawings go out Friday. You believe the girder endangers the people who'll use the garage. What do the Model Rules require of you?

"We can't lose two weeks"

Pressure rarely sounds like a threat to the public. It sounds like a schedule. An owner wants to skip the concrete cylinder breaks because the next pour is booked. A project manager wants to drop a design check because the budget is gone. Someone wants to cut a safety feature to find $80,000 by Tuesday.

Time and money are real constraints, and helping a client save both is part of your job. But a required test, inspection, or check is how anyone knows the work is safe, and a safety feature is there for people who never see the budget. So look at what the request actually takes away. The Handbook has no rule about schedules, so you reason from the ladder.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

A job is three weeks behind. The owner's project manager asks you to sign off on the structural steel without the required weld inspections, because they would delay the deck pour. What response is consistent with the Model Rules?

A.
Sign off as asked, as long as the project manager puts the request and the reason in writing
B.
Decline, try to speed up the inspections, and notify the owner in writing of the possible consequences
C.
Sign off now to protect the pour, and schedule the inspections for as soon as it's finished
D.
Leave the project without comment, and let the next engineer settle the matter with the owner

The duty doesn't stop at your scope

Say you're at a site to look at a drainage easement. Walking back to your truck, you see the shoring in the trench next door bowing toward a public sidewalk. It isn't your project, your client, or your contractor. Whose problem is it?

You'll want to say the contractor's or OSHA's. They may well have duties of their own, and those rules are the subject of Construction Site Safety. But the question here is whether you have one, and A.1 has no clause that says "on your own assignment." You now know something the people on that sidewalk don't. The Handbook has no rule on site visits, so your duty rests on A.1 and A.3.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

You're at a shopping center to review a repaving plan for its owner. In the parking structure next door, which isn't part of your assignment, you notice wide diagonal cracks and spalled concrete at several column tops. What is your duty?

A.
None, since the structure is outside your scope of work and doesn't belong to your client
B.
Promptly tell your client and the structure's owner in writing, then the authority if nothing is done
C.
Leave it to OSHA and the other regulators, since workplace and site safety are their responsibility
D.
Note the cracks in your own file with photographs, in case the question ever comes up later

When the mistake is yours

All of this gets harder when the person it costs is you. In 1978, William LeMessurier, the structural engineer of the 59-story Citicorp Center in Manhattan, rechecked the newly finished tower's wind bracing. He found that its joints, bolted during construction instead of welded as first designed, might fail in a storm that wasn't especially rare. Nobody else knew. He told the owner anyway, the city's building officials were brought in, and welders reinforced the joints at night while the building stayed in use by day.

The Handbook has no rule that says "your own error" in so many words. It doesn't need one, because A.1 and A.3 make no exception for the licensee who caused the danger. A design you sealed is your responsibility (Licensure, Seals, and Responsible Charge covers what a seal certifies), and the cost to you or your firm doesn't move the public off the top rung.

Checkpoint

Two years after a pedestrian bridge opens, you find an error in your own sealed calculations: a bearing connection falls well short of its required capacity. Your partners worry about liability and the firm's insurance. What is the required response?

A.
Watch the bridge, and speak up only if distress appears, since it has performed well so far
B.
Promptly inform the client or employer, then the appropriate authority if the danger isn't corrected
C.
Correct the calculations in your file, so the record is right if anyone ever asks about it
D.
Issue a statement to the press right away, so that the public hears about it from you first

Secrets, and where they stop

The second rung holds a rule that seems to collide with all of this. Here is B.4:

Licensees shall not reveal facts, data, or information obtained in a professional capacity without the prior consent of the client, employer, or public body on which they serve except as authorized or required by law or rules.

Most days, this simply holds. A client's process data, test results, and expansion plans stay with you, even after the job ends. But the rule has two exits built in: prior consent, and "authorized or required by law or rules." Look at that last word, and think about which rule you've already met that requires you to notify someone.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

Under a confidentiality agreement, you evaluate an occupied office building for an owner planning to sell it. You find a defect that could bring down part of a floor. The owner says your report is confidential and wants the finding kept private until the sale closes. Which duty governs?

A.
Confidentiality to the client, because the agreement is in writing
B.
Loyalty to the client, who commissioned and paid for the evaluation
C.
Courtesy to the licensee who designed the building, who should hear first
D.
The duty to safeguard the public's health, safety, and welfare

The whole truth, and who's paying for it

A report can contain nothing but true sentences and still lie. Leave out the two borings that hit peat, and the other eight look wonderful. The bank or the judge reading it can't know what's missing, so rule A.4 closes the gap:

Licensees shall, to the best of their knowledge, include all relevant and pertinent information in an objective and truthful manner within all professional documents, statements, and testimony.

"All relevant and pertinent" is the part with teeth. What goes in depends on what matters to the conclusion, not on what would please the reader.

Speaking in public adds two requirements. Under A.5, a professional opinion given publicly must be "founded upon an adequate knowledge of the facts and a competent evaluation of the subject matter." Under A.6, when an interested party inspired or paid for your statement, you must name that party and reveal any interest you have in the matter. Being paid isn't the problem, since expert witnesses are paid all the time. The problem is a listener who takes a hired opinion for a neutral one.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

You're testing concrete for a client. Two of ten results came back low. The client asks you to leave those two out of your report, since the scope asks only for the average strength. What is the proper response?

A.
Include all the results, with your objective assessment of what they mean
B.
Leave them out, since the report answers what the scope requested
C.
Leave them out of the report, and mention them to the client by phone
D.
Withdraw the report, and refuse any further work for this client

Honest about who did what

Rule C.1 opens with two sentences worth reading slowly:

Licensees shall not falsify or permit misrepresentation of their, or their associates', academic or professional qualifications. They shall not misrepresent or exaggerate their degree of responsibility in prior assignments nor the complexity of said assignments.

"Falsify" is what you do, and "permit" is what you let happen. If marketing writes you up as project manager on a bridge where you checked three connections, saying nothing is a violation too. The rule covers your colleagues' roles as well. And as a reference for a license applicant, A.9 says you shall not "knowingly provide false or incomplete information regarding an applicant." A reference is your word for what you saw, and nothing more.

Checkpoint

Which of these violate the Model Rules?

A.
A proposal credits a colleague as project engineer on a dam where they only ran the survey, and you let it go out
B.
A proposal lists a past project and accurately describes your role as a junior checker
C.
You sign a licensure reference saying a colleague spent four years in design when you can confirm only two
D.
Your résumé says you managed a project you only assisted on, because it reads better
E.
You decline to act as a reference for someone whose work you never saw

Now flip the seats: what if you own the firm, and the person who overstated their qualifications is someone you hired? The Handbook doesn't say what to do, so reason it out. What exactly is wrong here, and which response deals with all of it?

Checkpoint

A firm owner learns that a recently hired engineer intern, otherwise a good employee, misrepresented their qualifications. What is the most appropriate response?

A.
Fire the intern immediately, as a lesson to the rest of the staff
B.
Ignore it, since the intern's work has been good and nobody has complained
C.
Pay for more schooling to close the gap, and otherwise leave the matter alone
D.
Discuss the shortfalls and the dishonesty with the intern, and develop a plan of action

The third rung

Suppose you're reviewing another engineer's design for a client, and you find a mistake. C.4 tells you what you owe them:

Licensees shall make a reasonable effort to inform another licensee whose work is believed to contain a material discrepancy, error, or omission that may impact the health, safety, or welfare of the public, unless such reporting is legally prohibited.

There's more than courtesy in this. That engineer may have made the same mistake on other jobs, or may know something that shows it isn't a mistake at all. If you just correct it and move on, neither comes to light. And if the danger remains, rung one still stands above this, with the escalation sequence.

C.3 sets the limit on how you talk about other licensees. You shall not injure their reputation "maliciously or falsely, directly or indirectly," nor "indiscriminately criticize other licensees' work." That doesn't gag you. You can say a design is wrong, to the people who need to know, for reasons you can show.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

A client hires you to finish a project started by another licensee. You find an error in that licensee's design that could affect public safety. What is the proper conduct?

A.
Make a reasonable effort to inform the other licensee, and see that the error gets corrected
B.
Correct it in your own drawings, and say nothing to the other licensee about it
C.
Tell the client the other licensee is careless, to secure the rest of their work
D.
Publish the error in a trade journal, as a warning to owners and other engineers

Recap

  • The public has no seat at the table, so its health, safety, and welfare come first. The ladder runs from the public to employer and clients to other licensees, and the higher rung wins.
  • The escalation sequence: notify your employer or client of the possible consequences, in writing, then the appropriate authority if the danger isn't corrected. Going along, resigning quietly, fixing it quietly, and going to the media first all fail.
  • The same sequence answers schedule and budget pressure, a hazard seen on any site visit, and an error in your own sealed design.
  • Confidential information needs prior consent, unless law or rules authorize or require disclosure, so confidentiality yields to public safety.
  • Be objective, truthful, and complete, and say who is paying. Never misstate qualifications, answer a dishonest hire with a discussion and a plan, inform another licensee of errors, and don't disparage competitors.