Effective Stress

Water pressure pushes the grains apart, so only part of the soil's weight presses them together.

Before this Lesson

A vacuum-packed brick of ground coffee is as hard as a block of wood. Snip a corner, hear the hiss, and it turns into a soft bag of grounds you could pour. The air outside presses on the bag just as hard as before. What changed is the air between the grains: there was almost none, and now it pushes back from inside as hard as the air outside pushes in.

Ground below the water table is that bag, with water in place of air. The water's pressure decides how much of the soil's weight the grains press on each other with, and that decides how strong and stiff the ground is. This Lesson finds that number at any depth.

The weight of everything above

Pick a point in the ground and picture the column of ground standing on one square foot around it. Everything in that column rests on that square foot: the grains, the water in their voids, and any lake sitting on top. Its weight per unit area is the total vertical stress, σ\sigma.

You've done this walk before. It's the layered tank from Pressure and Depth, with soil layers in place of oil and water. Start at the ground surface and add each layer's unit weight times its thickness:

σ=∑γiHi\sigma = \sum \gamma_i H_i

Each layer gets the unit weight that matches where it sits, as in Unit Weights of Soil. Above the water table that's the moist unit weight γ\gamma. Below it the voids are full, so it's γsat\gamma_{sat}. A sand that the water table cuts through counts as two layers: the same sand, with γ\gamma above the water table and γsat\gamma_{sat} below. Standing water, such as a lake, is one more layer on top, with a unit weight of γW\gamma_W.

Stresses come out in psf (lb/ft²) or ksf, where 1 ksf is 1,000 psf, or in kPa (kN/m²). In this topic σ\sigma, uu, and σ′\sigma' are vertical unless a question says otherwise.

The water's share

Below the water table, the water in the voids connects from pore to pore all the way up to the water table. The grains make a maze of it, but in still water a container's shape never matters, only depth does. So the pore water's pressure follows P=γhP = \gamma h, with hh measured down from its free surface. That free surface is the water table: the level where the groundwater's pressure is zero, which is where water would stand in a hole dug down to it. The Handbook's Effective stress equations write the pore water pressure as

u=huγWu = h_u\gamma_W

and call huh_u the pressure head. In still groundwater it's simply the depth below the water table, so uu grows by 62.4 psf per foot, or 9.81 kPa per meter. Measure it from the water table, not from the ground surface. Above the water table, take u=0u = 0. If a lake covers the site, the lake's surface is the free surface, so huh_u counts from there.

What the grains feel

Now cut through the soil at the point with an imaginary horizontal slice, and ask what holds up everything above it. Two things do. The water pushes up on the slice with pressure uu, and since grains touch only at tiny points, it acts over practically the whole area. The grains below push up through those contacts. Whatever the water doesn't carry, the contacts must, and what they carry per unit area is the effective stress:

σ′=σ−u\sigma' = \sigma - u

The Handbook prints that equation under Effective stress, and its Vertical Stress Profiles diagram writes it as σ−u=σ′\sigma - u = \sigma'. In words, the water pressure pushes the grains apart, holding up part of the weight that would otherwise press them together.

That's the coffee brick. Sealed, the bag had air outside pressing in at 14.7 psi and almost nothing pushing back from inside, so the grains carried all of it: σ′\sigma' was about 14.7 psi. Snipped open, the air between the grains rose to 14.7 psi too, and σ′\sigma' fell to zero.

Why give σ′\sigma' its own name? Everything a soil does happens at those contacts. Grains slide past each other only when the friction between them gives way, and friction grows with how hard they're pressed together, so σ′\sigma' sets the strength. A layer compresses only when its grains are pushed into a tighter arrangement, so σ′\sigma' sets the settlement. That's why most of this topic opens the same way: find σ′\sigma' first.

One consequence surprises nearly everyone. Take two sites with the same clay, one with the water table at the ground surface and one under 10 ft of standing water. At any depth in the clay, the second site has 624 psf more total stress, from the lake's weight. But its free surface is 10 ft higher, so its pore pressure is 624 psf higher too, and σ′\sigma' is exactly the same. A lake presses on the soil only through water, and the water in the voids pushes back just as hard. That's why mud on the floor of the deep ocean, under miles of water, is as soft as mud at the edge of a pond.

Worked Example Three stresses in the middle of a clay
1 of 3

At the site below, sand lies on a 12 ft clay layer, and the water table is 6 ft down in the sand. The sand weighs 110 lb/ft³ above the water table and 125 lb/ft³ below it, and the clay's saturated unit weight is 118 lb/ft³. Find the total stress, pore pressure, and effective stress at point A, in the middle of the clay.

6 ft 8 ft 12 ft Ground surface Water table Sand, γ = 110 lb/ft³ Sand, γsat = 125 lb/ft³ Clay, γsat = 118 lb/ft³ 6 ft A
Sand over clay, with point A

Skipping the subtraction

Below the water table, each foot you go down adds γsat\gamma_{sat} to σ\sigma and γW\gamma_W to uu. So each foot adds their difference to σ′\sigma':

γsat−γW=γ′\gamma_{sat} - \gamma_W = \gamma'

That's the effective (submerged) unit weight from Unit Weights of Soil, which most questions call buoyant, and it's no accident that it turns up here. That Lesson found γ′\gamma' as the weight per cubic foot that Archimedes leaves the grains to press on each other with, which is exactly what σ′\sigma' counts. So you can build σ′\sigma' directly, with γ\gamma for each layer above the water table and γ′\gamma' below it, and never compute uu at all. For point A:

σ′=110(6)+(125−62.4)(8)+(118−62.4)(6)=1,494 psf\sigma' = 110(6) + (125 - 62.4)(8) + (118 - 62.4)(6) = 1{,}494\ \text{psf}

Same answer, no uu. The trap is mixing the two routes. γ′\gamma' has already taken the water out, so a σ′\sigma' built from γ′\gamma' is finished, and subtracting uu from it takes the water out twice.

When a question gives GsG_s and ee instead of a unit weight, the Handbook's Phase Relationships section supplies γsat=(Gs+e)γW/(1+e)\gamma_{sat} = (G_s + e)\gamma_W / (1 + e), and γ′\gamma' is one subtraction away.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

A 6 ft layer of sand with γ=105\gamma = 105 lb/ft³ lies on a 16 ft clay layer with γsat=120\gamma_{sat} = 120 lb/ft³. The water table is at the top of the clay. What is the effective stress at the middle of the clay?

A.
592 psf
B.
1,091 psf
C.
1,590 psf
D.
716 psf

The shape of a profile

Plot σ\sigma, uu, and σ′\sigma' against depth, and every line is made of straight pieces, because each is a running sum of unit weights times thicknesses. Within a piece the rate of growth is steady, and a line bends only where that rate changes:

  • σ\sigma grows at each layer's own unit weight, so it bends at every layer boundary and at the water table.
  • uu is zero down to the water table, then grows at γW\gamma_W in one straight line.
  • σ′\sigma' matches σ\sigma down to the water table, where uu is still zero. Below it, σ′\sigma' grows at γ′\gamma', roughly half its rate above.

Depth runs down the page, so a line that grows faster runs flatter. Here are the three profiles for the site you just worked:

6 ft 8 ft 12 ft Ground surface Water table Sand, γ = 110 Sand, γsat = 125 Clay, γsat = 118 Unit weights in lb/ft³ A Total stress, σ (psf) Pore pressure, u (psf) Effective stress, σ′ (psf) 660 1,660 2,368 0 499 874 660 1,161 1,494
σ, u, and σ′ with depth at the worked example’s site
All three plots share one stress scale, so you can see that at every depth uu and σ′\sigma' add up to σ\sigma. Below the water table, σ′\sigma' grows by 62.6 psf per foot in the sand and 55.6 in the clay, against 110 above it.

Layout adapted from the FE Reference Handbook, Vertical Stress Profiles

The Handbook's Vertical Stress Profiles draws the same three plots for a simpler site, with two layers and the water table at the boundary between them. With a lake on top, σ\sigma and uu both start at the lake's surface and climb together at γW\gamma_W through the water, so σ′\sigma' stays at zero down to the lake bed and only starts growing there.

Checkpoint

A thick deposit of one uniform sand has its water table partway down, at the dashed line. Which sketch shows how σ\sigma, uu, and σ′\sigma' vary with depth? All four use one stress scale.

A.
σ u σ′
B.
σ u σ′
C.
σ u σ′
D.
σ u σ′

Working backward

Some questions run the other way. They give the σ′\sigma' a point must have and ask how deep the water table is, or how thick a layer is. The profile is still a sum of unit weights times thicknesses, so write it with a letter for the unknown thickness and solve.

The water table version has one wrinkle: its unknown shows up twice. The deeper the water table sits, the more of the sand lies above it at γ\gamma and the less lies below it at γ′\gamma'. Each extra foot of depth trades a foot of γ′\gamma' for a foot of γ\gamma, and raises σ′\sigma' by γ−γ′\gamma - \gamma'.

Worked Example Where is the water table?
1 of 3

A 15 ft sand layer lies on a 10 ft clay layer. The sand weighs 112 lb/ft³ above the water table and 124 lb/ft³ below it, and the clay's γsat\gamma_{sat} is 116 lb/ft³. The water table is somewhere in the sand. How deep is it, if the effective stress at the middle of the clay is 1,600 psf?

Recap

  • Total stress is the weight of everything above a point per unit area, σ=∑γiHi\sigma = \sum \gamma_i H_i, with γ\gamma above the water table, γsat\gamma_{sat} below it, and γW\gamma_W for any standing water.
  • Pore pressure is u=huγWu = h_u\gamma_W, with huh_u measured down from the water table, or from a lake's surface. Above the water table, u=0u = 0.
  • σ′=σ−u\sigma' = \sigma - u is what the grains press each other with, and it sets a soil's strength and compression. Find σ′\sigma' first.
  • Below the water table, σ′\sigma' grows at γ′=γsat−γW\gamma' = \gamma_{sat} - \gamma_W, so you can build it directly. Don't subtract uu again. Standing water adds equally to σ\sigma and uu, leaving σ′\sigma' unchanged.
  • Profiles are straight pieces that bend at layer boundaries and the water table. uu starts at the water table, and σ′\sigma' grows more slowly below it. To work backward, write σ′\sigma' with the unknown thickness and solve.