Gates and Buoyancy

A gate opens when the water's moment about the hinge wins.

A steel gate closes an outlet low in a reservoir wall. It hangs from a hinge along its top edge, and its bottom edge rests against a stop on the dry side. The water pushes on it with about 59 kN, and that push has to go somewhere: part into the hinge, the rest into the stop. Undersize the stop, and the reservoir lets itself out.

You don't need to know what the hinge carries to size the stop. One equation, written about the right point, finds the stop's share and never sees the hinge at all.

A gate is a lever on its hinge

From Hydrostatic Force on Plane Surfaces, all the water pushing on a flat gate adds up to one force at the center of pressure. Once you've found it, you can forget the water. The gate is a rigid body with three things acting on it: that one force, the push from whatever holds it shut, and the reaction at the hinge.

C CP F R P d L ytop yCP
The forces on a gate hinged along its top edge
The water is replaced by its resultant FF at the center of pressure. The stop pushes back with PP, and the hinge with RR.

The hinge reaction is the awkward one, since you know neither its size nor its direction. But its line runs through the hinge, so its moment about the hinge is zero, the same move Reactions of Bent Bars, Brackets, and Booms makes at a pin. Sum moments about the hinge, and the reaction drops out, leaving one equation with one unknown. With counterclockwise positive, as in Moments and Couples, the water in the figure turns the gate counterclockwise and the stop turns it clockwise:

ΣMhinge=Fd−PL=0\Sigma M_{\text{hinge}} = Fd - PL = 0

It's a door: push near the hinges and it barely moves, push at the handle and it swings. The stop pushes at the far edge, on the longest lever, so it carries less than the water's full push.

The arm dd is where people slip. FF pushes squarely on the gate, so its arm about a hinge on the gate is the distance along the gate from the hinge to CPCP, not the distance from the water surface. For a hinge at the top edge, d=yCP−ytopd = y_{CP} - y_{\text{top}}, and at the bottom edge, d=ybottom−yCPd = y_{\text{bottom}} - y_{CP}. On a sloping gate, it's the same, with every distance measured down the slope.

The same equation answers two more questions. A shaft at the hinge, in place of a stop, must supply the water's moment, FdFd. And since that moment grows as the water rises, a gate opens at the depth where it reaches the most the hold can supply: set the two equal and solve for the depth. The Handbook's Forces on Submerged Surfaces and the Center of Pressure gives FF and yCPy_{CP} and stops there, so these moment equations are yours to write.

Worked Example Sizing the stop
1 of 3

The Hook's gate is 1.2 m wide and 2.0 m tall, set vertically, with its hinged top edge 1.5 m below the water surface. A stop at its bottom edge holds it shut. Find the force the stop must provide.

Circles and triangles

F=γhCAF = \gamma h_C A doesn't care about the gate's shape, and the center of pressure needs just two shape facts, the centroid and IxCI_{xC}, both from the Handbook's Statics table of centroids and moments of inertia, adapted below for the shapes gates come in.

The circle's row uses the radius, aa, and problems usually give a diameter, so halve it first. That row also lists J=πa4/2J = \pi a^4/2, the polar moment, twice too big for this job. And the triangle's rows are drawn one way only, base down and apex up, with Ix=bh3/12I_x = bh^3/12, about the base, beside the centroidal bh3/36bh^3/36. A gate can be set either way up, so carry the rule, not the picture: the centroid sits a third of the height from the base, wherever the base is. Turning the triangle over moves the centroid's depth but leaves IxCI_{xC} alone.

a C xC Circle b C xC L L/3 Base on top b C xC L 2L/3 Apex on top
Where the centroid sits in three gate shapes
Each dashed line is the centroidal axis for IxCI_{xC}, parallel to the water surface.
Gate shapes, with LL for a triangle's height (the table's hh, renamed to keep hh for depth). The last column is the offset of the center of pressure below the centroid.
ShapeAAC below topIxCI_{xC}IxC/(yCA)I_{xC}/(y_C A)
RectanglebLbLL/2L/2bL3/12bL^3/12L2/(12yC)L^2/(12y_C)
Circleπa2\pi a^2aaπa4/4\pi a^4/4a2/(4yC)a^2/(4y_C)
Triangle, base on topbL/2bL/2L/3L/3bL3/36bL^3/36L2/(18yC)L^2/(18y_C)
Triangle, apex on topbL/2bL/22L/32L/3bL3/36bL^3/36L2/(18yC)L^2/(18y_C)

Adapted from the FE Reference Handbook, Statics, Centroids and Moments of Inertia

Checkpoint
1 of 2

A circular gate 1.2 m in diameter is set in a vertical tank wall, its center 3.0 m below the water surface. What is the resultant water force on it, and how far below the surface does it act?

A.
33.3 kN, 3.06 m below the surface
B.
133 kN, 3.12 m below the surface
C.
33.3 kN, 3.03 m below the surface
D.
33.3 kN, 3.00 m below the surface

Water on both sides

Put water on both sides of a gate, and each side pushes as if the other weren't there. So find each side's resultant and line of action on its own, with that side's depths measured from that side's surface. They push in opposite directions, so the net force is their difference.

Where the net force acts is the step that goes wrong. It isn't at either side's center of pressure. It acts where its moment equals the two moments together, so take moments of both about one point and divide. About the floor, with zz for each force's height above it:

Fnet=F1−F2znet=F1z1−F2z2FnetF_{\text{net}} = F_1 - F_2 \qquad z_{\text{net}} = \frac{F_1 z_1 - F_2 z_2}{F_{\text{net}}}

The picture behind it is a subtraction, point by point. At each height on the gate, the net pressure is one side's γh\gamma h minus the other's. Below the lower surface, both sides grow at the same rate, γ\gamma per unit of depth, so their difference doesn't change. Above it, only the deeper side pushes.

F1 F2 H1/3 H1 H2/3 H2 Each side on its own Fnet z γ(H1 − H2) The net pressure
One gate, water on both sides
Below the lower surface, the net pressure is a uniform γ(H1−H2)\gamma(H_1 - H_2), and above it the deeper side's triangle is all that's left. The net force acts at zz, at neither side's own line.
Worked Example The net force on a channel gate
1 of 3

A vertical gate 2.0 m wide separates two channels and reaches from the floor to above both water surfaces. The water is 4.0 m deep on one side and 1.5 m deep on the other. Find the net water force on the gate and how high above the floor it acts.

Buoyancy is a pressure difference

Now let the water surround a whole body. Picture a 1 ft cube held with its top 2 ft below the surface. The water pushes down on its top face with 62.4(2)=124.862.4(2) = 124.8 lbf/ft², and up on its bottom face, a foot deeper, with 187.2 lbf/ft². The pushes on the four side faces match in pairs and cancel. What's left is 62.4 lbf, upward: the weight of a cubic foot of water, the cube's own volume of it.

γhtop γhbottom FB htop hbottom
The water's push on a block under water

So buoyancy isn't a new kind of force. It's the same γh\gamma h, pushing harder on the bottom than on the top.

The cube made the arithmetic easy, but the result holds for any shape, and there's a way to see it without adding up a single pressure. Imagine a parcel of the water itself, shaped exactly like the body, in the body's place. It doesn't rise or sink, so the water around it must push up on it with exactly its weight. Now swap the body in. The surrounding water can't tell the difference, so it pushes the same way. The upward push on any body is the weight of the fluid that would fill its place:

FB=γVdisplacedF_B = \gamma V_{\text{displaced}}

Here γ\gamma is the fluid's specific weight, not the body's, and VdisplacedV_{\text{displaced}} is the volume of the body below the surface: all of it for a submerged body, only the part under water for a floating one.

The Handbook's Archimedes Principle and Buoyancy entry says it in words: the buoyant force on a submerged or floating body equals the weight of the fluid it displaces, and a floating body displaces a weight of fluid equal to its own. That force acts through the centroid of the displaced volume, the center of buoyancy.

Checkpoint

Which of these statements are true?

A.
A floating body displaces a volume of fluid equal to its own volume.
B.
A steel ball and an aluminum ball of the same size, both held fully under water, feel the same buoyant force.
C.
A submerged block feels a larger buoyant force the deeper it sinks, because the pressure there is higher.
D.
A rock resting on the bottom of a tank feels a buoyant force equal to its own weight.
E.
A 300 lb log floating in a pond pushes aside 300 lb of water.

Floating: sink until the displaced water weighs as much

Lower a block into water and let go. It sinks, pushing aside more and more water, until the water it has pushed aside weighs as much as it does. Then it stops, in equilibrium, weight down and buoyancy up. For a body of specific gravity SGbSG_b floating in a liquid of SGlSG_l, with each γ=SG γw\gamma = SG\,\gamma_w:

SGb γwV=SGl γwVsubVsubV=SGbSGlSG_b\,\gamma_w V = SG_l\,\gamma_w V_{\text{sub}} \qquad \frac{V_{\text{sub}}}{V} = \frac{SG_b}{SG_l}

The fraction submerged is the body's SG over the liquid's, which is the body's SG alone only in fresh water. Seawater is about 3% heavier and floats the same block a little higher; the Handbook lists no value for it, so a problem will. With vertical sides, the fraction submerged is the fraction of the height under water, so the draft is D=(SGb/SGl)HD = (SG_b/SG_l)H. Given a weight instead, divide it by γl\gamma_l times the plan area. A log on its side floats with the same fraction of its volume under water, but its round section means the draft isn't that fraction of its diameter.

W FB D H One liquid Voil Vw W FB oil water Oil over water
Two ways to float
At an oil-water interface, the buoyant force counts both liquids: FB=γoilVoil+γwVwF_B = \gamma_{\text{oil}} V_{\text{oil}} + \gamma_w V_w.

Two more cases need nothing new. The load that sinks a body to a given depth is the buoyancy at that depth, less the body's own weight. And a body at an oil-water interface displaces some of each, so the Handbook's entry sums the weights of both. The same rule gives submerged soil its buoyant unit weight in Unit Weights of Soil.

Worked Example A timber block in seawater
1 of 3

A timber block 0.40 m by 0.40 m in plan and 0.30 m tall, SG 0.65, floats upright in seawater of SG 1.03. Find its draft.

Recap

  • With the water replaced by its resultant at the center of pressure, a gate is a lever: sum moments about the hinge, with the arm along the gate from the hinge, and the hinge reaction drops out. A gate opens where the water's moment reaches the most the hold can supply.
  • For circles and triangles, take the centroid and IxCI_{xC} from the Statics table: a circle's πa4/4\pi a^4/4 uses its radius, and a triangle's centroid sits a third of its height from its base, whichever way up.
  • With water on both sides, subtract the resultants and place the net force by combining their moments. Below both surfaces, the net pressure is uniform and acts at the centroid.
  • FB=γVdisplacedF_B = \gamma V_{\text{displaced}}. A floating body displaces its own weight, so Vsub/V=SGb/SGlV_{\text{sub}}/V = SG_b/SG_l, and at an interface both liquids count.