Thermal Strain and Indeterminate Bars

Block a bar from growing, and the blocked growth becomes stress.

Before this Lesson

A steel rail, 100 ft long, warms by 60°F in the sun, with no train anywhere near it. If it's free to move, it grows about half an inch, and that's the whole story: no force and no stress. Now fix its ends to something that won't budge. The half inch has nowhere to go, and the steel is squeezed to about 11 ksi by sunlight alone. A rail 1,000 ft long would feel exactly the same 11 ksi. By the end of this Lesson, that will seem obvious.

Free to grow

Warm a solid, and its atoms jostle harder and settle a little farther apart. Every inch of a bar grows by the same small fraction, and that fraction per degree is the material's coefficient of thermal expansion, α\alpha. So a temperature change gives a strain of αΔT\alpha\Delta T, with no force anywhere. A free bar can have strain without stress, because Hooke's law only ties stress to the strain that loads cause.

Multiply by the length, and you have the bar's free change in length. The Handbook's Thermal Deformations entry prints it with the final temperature TT and the initial temperature ToT_o, and this Lesson shortens T−ToT - T_o to ΔT\Delta T:

δt=αL(T−To)=αL ΔT\delta_t = \alpha L(T - T_o) = \alpha L\,\Delta T

Heating makes it positive, and cooling makes it negative.

at To e L at T δt δt = αL(T − To) no force, no stress
A rail anchored at one end, growing into its expansion gap

Table 1 prints α\alpha both per °F and per °C, so use the one that matches your ΔT\Delta T. They differ by a factor of 1.8, because a change of 1°C is a change of 1.8°F. The 32 in the Handbook's conversion applies only to readings.

Expansion coefficient and modulus of common materials
Materialα\alpha (10⁻⁶/°F)α\alpha (10⁻⁶/°C)EE (ksi)EE (MPa)
Steel6.511.729,000200,000
Aluminum13.123.610,00069,000
Cast iron6.712.114,500100,000
Copper9.316.617,000117,000

Source: FE Reference Handbook, Table 1 - Typical Material Properties (adapted)

For an alloy named in Table 2, use its row instead, which is per °F only. A36 steel is 6.60 there, and concrete, listed only in that table, is 6.0, both times 10−610^{-6}.

An expansion gap is just room for this growth. The smallest gap that works equals δt\delta_t from the installation temperature up to the hottest one expected. Run it backward, and the rise that closes a stated gap ee is:

ΔT=eαL\Delta T = \frac{e}{\alpha L}
Worked Example Room for a girder to grow
1 of 3

A steel bridge girder, 150 ft long, is anchored at one end and set at 50°F. It may reach 120°F in summer and −10°F in winter. Using Table 1, find the minimum expansion gap at its free end.

The hole grows too

Heat a steel ring. Does the hole get bigger or smaller? The usual first guess is smaller, since the metal expands into it. Here's how to settle it. Before heating, imagine the hole filled with a plug of the same steel, so that ring and plug are one solid disk. Heat the disk, and it grows everywhere in proportion, plug included. Now lift the plug out. The hole it leaves is the plug's new size, which is larger.

ring and plug, cold D heated together D + αDΔT plug removed D + αDΔT
A ring and an imaginary plug heated together, with the growth exaggerated

Heating acts like a photographic enlargement: every length grows by the same fraction, hole or no hole. So a hole of diameter DD grows by αD ΔT\alpha D\,\Delta T, and the ring's outside diameter and wall thickness don't enter. That's how a collar goes on a shaft slightly too big for it: heat it until its hole reaches the shaft's size, slide it on, and let it cool.

ΔT=Dshaft−DαD\Delta T = \frac{D_{\text{shaft}} - D}{\alpha D}
Checkpoint

A steel ring has a 150.00 mm inside diameter and a 200 mm outside diameter. It must slip over a shaft 150.25 mm in diameter. Using Table 1, what temperature change brings the inside diameter up to the shaft's?

A.
Cool it by 142°C
B.
Heat it by 256°C
C.
Heat it by 142°C
D.
Heat it by 107°C

Block the growth

Back to the Hook's rail with its ends held. A bar that can't move is hard to think about, so split what happens into two moves. First, let go of one end and let the bar grow freely by δt\delta_t. Second, push it back until it fits between the walls again. The push has to shorten it by exactly what it grew:

1. between the walls area A, modulus E L 2. let go and heat: free growth no stress δt = αLΔT 3. push it back: walls restored compression P P PL/AE = δt
A heated bar between two walls, split into free growth and a push back
PLAE=αL ΔT⇒σ=PA=Eα ΔT\frac{PL}{AE} = \alpha L\,\Delta T \quad\Rightarrow\quad \sigma = \frac{P}{A} = E\alpha\,\Delta T

Both LL and AA vanish, each for a reason. A longer bar wants to grow more, but it has more length to squeeze, so the strain it gives back is the same. A fatter bar takes more force to squeeze, but it has more area carrying that force, so the stress is the same. Only the material and the temperature change are left, which is why the Hook's rail gets (29,000)(6.5×10−6)(60)=11.3 ksi(29{,}000)(6.5 \times 10^{-6})(60) = 11.3\ \text{ksi} at any length. The area still sets the force on the walls, P=σAP = \sigma A.

The direction comes from asking what the walls must do. Heat the bar, and they squeeze it: compression. Cool it, and they hold it out against its shrinking: tension.

The Handbook has no line for this stress, though setting the strain to zero in its Hooke's Law entry, which includes a thermal term, gets you there. It assumes rigid walls and a stress within the elastic range.

Worked Example A bar that cools between walls
1 of 3

A steel bar, 2 in. in diameter and 8 ft long, is fixed between rigid walls at 70°F. The temperature drops to −10°F. Using Table 1, find the stress in the bar and the force on the walls.

A gap first

Now leave some room. A bar is fixed at one end, with a gap ee to a rigid wall at the other. As it warms, it grows freely, with no stress at all, until it touches. After that, only the growth it still wants is blocked. So check first: is δt\delta_t bigger than ee? If not, the stress is zero and you're done. If so, the wall pushes back just the excess:

PLAE=δt−e⇒σ=E(δt−e)L\frac{PL}{AE} = \delta_t - e \quad\Rightarrow\quad \sigma = \frac{E(\delta_t - e)}{L}
at the start e L the growth it wants blocked δt e δt − e
A bar with a gap: the growth the wall lets through and the growth it blocks

The length is back. The gap is a fixed distance, so it doesn't scale with the bar, and a longer bar uses it up sooner. Plotted against the temperature rise, the stress sits at zero until the gap closes, then climbs at the same slope as a bar with no gap.

e/(αL) gap closes temperature rise, ΔT compressive stress, σ no gap: σ = EαΔT with a gap same slope, Eα
Stress in a restrained bar against the temperature rise
Worked Example A rail that outgrows its gap
1 of 3

A steel rail, 50 ft long, is anchored at one end, with a 1/4 in. gap to a rigid stop at the other. Using Table 1, find the stress in the rail after a temperature rise of 80°F.

When statics runs out

Look again at the bar between two walls. It has two reactions and one force equation, so statics says they're equal and nothing about how big they are. You found them anyway, from a fact about shape: the bar's total change in length had to be zero. A problem like that is statically indeterminate, and the missing equation is always geometry. The rest of this Lesson uses the same three pieces:

  1. Equilibrium. Sum the forces, which leaves too many unknowns.
  2. Compatibility. Say how the deformations must fit together.
  3. Force-deformation. Turn each force into a deformation with δ=PL/AE\delta = PL/AE, then solve.

Together, these three pieces are the force method. The Handbook prints no axial version, but its Force Method entry shows the same idea for beams, and Beams with One Redundant picks it up there.

Most of these problems come down to one picture. Hang a rigid plate from a stiff spring and a soft one, with the load placed so the plate stays level. Both springs stretch by the same δ\delta, and each force is kδk\delta, so the stiff spring takes more, in exact proportion:

δ=P∑kiTi=kiδ=P ki∑ki\delta = \frac{P}{\sum k_i} \qquad\qquad T_i = k_i\delta = P\,\frac{k_i}{\sum k_i}
k1 = 2k k2 = k δ δ P T1 = 2kδ T2 = kδ
A rigid plate on a stiff spring and a soft one, both stretched by the same amount

Load doesn't split evenly, and it doesn't go to whichever member could best carry it. It goes where the stiffness is.

Two materials, one strain

A reinforced concrete post is those springs side by side in one block. A rigid cap presses both materials down, and they're bonded and the same length, so they have equal strain. That doesn't mean equal stress or equal load. With σ=Eε\sigma = E\varepsilon, the steel's stress comes out Es/EcE_s/E_c times the concrete's.

δ P L Ast (total) Ac = Ag − Ast same δ, same L, so εs = εc
A reinforced concrete post under a rigid cap, and its cross section

Equilibrium says the two stresses times their areas add up to PP. Put in the common strain, and it comes out directly:

P=ε(EsAst+EcAc)⇒ε=PEsAst+EcAcP = \varepsilon(E_s A_{st} + E_c A_c) \quad\Rightarrow\quad \varepsilon = \frac{P}{E_s A_{st} + E_c A_c}

Then σs=Esε\sigma_s = E_s\varepsilon and σc=Ecε\sigma_c = E_c\varepsilon, and each load is its stress times its area. The Handbook's column symbols are AgA_g for the gross area and AstA_{st} for the total steel, and the concrete keeps the rest, Ac=Ag−AstA_c = A_g - A_{st}. A steel tube filled with concrete works the same way.

A question usually states EcE_c, or points you to Table 2's 3,200 ksi for low-strength concrete and 4,200 ksi for high-strength. The Handbook's Short Columns formula is a different thing, a strength at failure, so it won't give this elastic split.

Worked Example Steel and concrete sharing a post
1 of 3

A short post, 12 in. by 12 in., has Ec=3,600 ksiE_c = 3{,}600\ \text{ksi} and four #8 bars, each 0.79 in² in the Handbook's ASTM Standard Reinforcement Bars table. It carries 300 kip on a rigid cap. Using Es=29,000 ksiE_s = 29{,}000\ \text{ksi}, find the stress and the load in each material.

Rods under a rigid plate

Hang a rigid plate from rods. If the rods and load are symmetric, or the question says the plate stays level, every rod stretches by the same δ\delta. That's the spring picture with k=AE/Lk = AE/L, so the sharing rule applies directly, and a shorter rod counts as a stiffer one.

Now give one rod some slack. Rod 2 passes through a hole in the plate and ends in a nut a small distance ee below it. The plate has to drop by ee before it lands on the nut, and until then rod 1 carries everything. Once it lands, rod 1 has stretched ee more than rod 2, and that's the compatibility equation:

δ1=δ2+e\delta_1 = \delta_2 + e
before loading rod 1 rod 2 e under load rod 1 rod 2 δ1 δ2 P δ1 = δ2 + e
A rigid plate on two rods, with a gap at rod 2's nut

Check first that the gap closes, which takes a load of k1ek_1 e. A smaller load stays entirely in rod 1. For a larger one, use T1=k1δ1T_1 = k_1\delta_1, T2=k2δ2T_2 = k_2\delta_2, and T1+T2=PT_1 + T_2 = P.

Worked Example A rod with slack
1 of 3

In the setup above, rod 1 is steel with an area of 1.0 in², and rod 2 is aluminum with an area of 1.5 in². Both are 6 ft long, e=0.02 in.e = 0.02\ \text{in.}, and the plate stays level under P=40 kipP = 40\ \text{kip}. Using Table 1, find the force in each rod.

A bar between two walls

Fix a bar at both ends and push on it at an interior point B. Both walls help, and statics gives only RA+RC=PR_A + R_C = P. The geometry is that the ends can't move, so the total change in length is zero. With the load pointing toward C, segment AB stretches and BC shortens by exactly the same amount:

before loading A B C a b L under load δB P RA RC stretches: tension shortens: compression
A bar fixed at both ends, with a load at B
RAaAE−RCbAE=0\frac{R_A a}{AE} - \frac{R_C b}{AE} = 0

For a uniform bar, AEAE cancels, and with equilibrium that gives:

RA=P bLRC=P aLR_A = P\,\frac{b}{L} \qquad\qquad R_C = P\,\frac{a}{L}

Notice which way around that is. The wall nearer the load takes more, just as a simple beam's nearer support does. The shorter segment is the stiffer spring, and both segments move the same distance at B, so it's the sharing rule again. When the segments differ in area or material, give each its own k=AE/Lk = AE/L and use R=P ki/∑kiR = P\,k_i/\sum k_i.

Worked Example A load 4 ft from one wall
1 of 3

A uniform steel bar with an area of 2 in² is fixed between walls 10 ft apart. A 30 kip load along the bar acts at B, 4 ft from wall A and pointing toward wall C. Using Table 1, find both reactions and how far B moves.

Recap

  • A free bar has strain without stress: δt=αL ΔT\delta_t = \alpha L\,\Delta T, with α\alpha per °F or per °C to match ΔT\Delta T. A hole grows with the material around it.
  • A fully restrained bar has σ=Eα ΔT\sigma = E\alpha\,\Delta T, whatever its length or area: compression when heated, tension when cooled. With a gap, check that it closes, then use only the excess: σ=E(δt−e)/L\sigma = E(\delta_t - e)/L.
  • When equilibrium runs out, geometry supplies the missing equation, and members forced to deform together share load in proportion to their stiffness.
  • A post's steel and concrete have equal strain, not equal stress. Rods under a level plate share by AE/LAE/L, with δ1=δ2+e\delta_1 = \delta_2 + e if one has slack.
  • A bar fixed at both ends has zero total change in length, so RA=Pb/LR_A = Pb/L, and the shorter segment carries more.