Moment of Inertia of Areas

Area far from the axis counts for much more than area near it.

Before this Lesson

Lay a plank 2 in thick and 10 in wide flat across a ditch and walk out to the middle. It dips under you like a diving board. Now stand the same plank on edge, brace it so it can't roll, and try again. It hardly moves. It's the same wood with the same area. All you changed is how far that area sits from the line the plank bends about.

Flat you axis 10 in 2 in On edge you axis 2 in 10 in
The same plank, flat and on edge

The number that tells those two planks apart is the cross section's moment of inertia. Like the centroid, it's pure geometry.

Distance counts twice

Cut through a sagging beam and look at the cut face. The top is squashed, the bottom is stretched, and a line between them, through the section's centroid, does neither. That line is the axis.

Compare two equal patches of material, one a distance yy from the axis and one 2y2y. The far patch stretches twice as much, so it pulls twice as hard, and its pull has twice the lever arm. That's four times the resistance to bending. Distance gets counted twice, so each bit of area counts by its distance squared.

axis y 2y F 2F squashed stretched near patch: F × y = Fy far patch: 2F × 2y = 4Fy
A patch twice as far out pulls twice as hard on twice the arm

Add up every bit, and you have what the Handbook's Statics chapter, under Moment of Inertia, calls the moment of inertia, or second moment of area:

Ix=∫y2 dAIy=∫x2 dAI_x = \int y^2\,dA \qquad I_y = \int x^2\,dA

The yy in IxI_x is the distance from the xx-axis. In Centroids of Areas, ynany_n a_n was the first moment, area times distance, and this has one more factor of distance. So bits on opposite sides of the axis add instead of canceling, and the units are length to the fourth power.

Despite the name, nothing here has mass or spins. The Handbook's Dynamics chapter uses the same letters for Mass Moment of Inertia, a different quantity.

Why depth is cubed

Take a rectangle of width bb and depth hh, with the axis through its centroid. Double the width, and you've set two copies side by side: twice the II. Double the depth, and there's twice the area with every bit twice as far out, which counts four times over: eight times the II. That's the Handbook's area table, for a horizontal axis through the centroid:

Ixc=bh312I_{xc} = \frac{bh^3}{12}
xc b h I 2b h 2I b 2h 8I
Doubling the width versus doubling the depth

The dimension that's cubed is the one perpendicular to the axis, however the page is turned. About a vertical axis, Iyc=b3h/12I_{yc} = b^3h/12 cubes the width. For the planks:

Iflat=(10)(2)312=6.67 in4Iedge=(2)(10)312=166.7 in4I_{\text{flat}} = \frac{(10)(2)^3}{12} = 6.67\ \text{in}^4 \qquad I_{\text{edge}} = \frac{(2)(10)^3}{12} = 166.7\ \text{in}^4

That's the same area with 25 times the II, and 25 is (10/2)2(10/2)^2. Under the same load, the plank on edge sags a twenty-fifth as far.

Converting units takes all four powers: 1 ft⁴ is 124=20,73612^4 = 20{,}736 in⁴, and 1 m⁴ is 10004=10121000^4 = 10^{12} mm⁴. The Handbook prints neither factor.

Read the row's axis first

The area table from Centroids of Areas has a column headed Area Moment of Inertia. Each row gives IxcI_{xc} about the centroid and IxI_x about the xx-axis in that row's own sketch, and that xx-axis moves from row to row. In the circular rows, aa is the radius. The Handbook's sketches mark only the centroid, so the centroidal axes are drawn in here.

Rectangle b h xc C x y Triangle b h xc C h/3 x y Circle xc C a x y Semicircle 2a xc C 4a/3π x y
Where each row's axes sit

Adapted from the FE Reference Handbook, Statics area table

Four rows, with the columns this Lesson needs
ShapeAAIxcI_{xc}IxI_xIts xx-axis
Rectanglebhbhbh3/12bh^3/12bh3/3bh^3/3the base
Trianglebh/2bh/2bh3/36bh^3/36bh3/12bh^3/12the base
Circleπa2\pi a^2πa4/4\pi a^4/45πa4/45\pi a^4/4tangent at the bottom
Semicircleπa2/2\pi a^2/2a4(9π2−64)72π\dfrac{a^4(9\pi^2 - 64)}{72\pi}πa4/8\pi a^4/8the flat side

Adapted from the FE Reference Handbook, Statics area table

Two rows that catch people

A triangle's bh3/12bh^3/12 looks like a rectangle's centroidal formula, but it's about the base. Its centroidal value is bh3/36bh^3/36.

A semicircle's πa4/8\pi a^4/8 is about the flat side, which is 4a/(3π)4a/(3\pi) from its centroid. Its centroidal value is the awkward one, about 0.1098a40.1098a^4.

Later chapters mostly want the centroidal value: the bending-stress formula writes it plain II, and Fluid Mechanics writes it IxCI_{xC}.

Moving the axis

For an axis the table doesn't list, such as one through a triangle's tip, follow one bit of area. If it's yy above the centroidal axis and the new axis is dd below that, the bit is y+dy + d above the new axis.

xc x d y y + d dA C
One bit of area, seen from two parallel axes

Add up every bit:

I=∫(y+d)2 dA=∫y2 dA+2d∫y dA+d2∫dAI = \int (y + d)^2\,dA = \int y^2\,dA + 2d\int y\,dA + d^2\int dA

The first integral is the centroidal value, IcI_c, and the last term is Ad2Ad^2. The middle integral is the first moment about the centroidal axis, which is zero: that's what a centroid is. What survives is the parallel-axis theorem:

I=Ic+Ad2I = I_c + Ad^2

The Handbook, under Moment of Inertia Parallel Axis Theorem, prints it as Ix=Ixc+dy2AI_x = I_{xc} + d_y^2A, with dyd_y the vertical distance between the axes, and likewise for IyI_y. Test it on a rectangle, whose base is h/2h/2 from its centroid: bh3/12+(bh)(h/2)2=bh3/3bh^3/12 + (bh)(h/2)^2 = bh^3/3, the table's IxI_x.

Two things follow:

  • Ad2Ad^2 can't be negative, so of all parallel axes, the one through the centroid has the smallest II.
  • The middle term vanished only because the starting axis ran through the centroid, so one end of every transfer has to be centroidal. Going from a base to another axis takes two steps, through the centroid.
Worked Example A triangle about its tip
1 of 4

A triangle has a 6 in base and a 9 in height. Find its moment of inertia about the axis through its tip, parallel to its base.

6 in 9 in axis
A triangle and an axis through its tip

A hollow section is a solid minus its hole

II is a sum over the area, so as with centroids, a hole subtracts, as long as both values are about the same axis. In a concentric section, the outer shape and the hole share a centroid, so no transfer is needed. The Handbook doesn't spell this out, and it has no hollow-rectangle row, so with capitals for the outer rectangle:

Ixc=BH312−bh312I_{xc} = \frac{BH^3}{12} - \frac{bh^3}{12}
B H b h xc − =
A box section as a rectangle minus its hole

Subtract the II values, not the dimensions, and count a wall on each side. The table does have a hollow-circle row, with aa the outer radius and, in this row, bb the inner radius:

Ixc=Iyc=π(a4−b4)4I_{xc} = I_{yc} = \frac{\pi(a^4 - b^4)}{4}

Hollowing costs little. Bore a 4 in hole through a 6 in round bar, and you remove 44% of the area but only 20% of the II, because that material sat near the axis, where it counted least.

Worked Example A box section
1 of 3

A box section measures 8 in wide and 12 in deep outside, with walls 1 in thick all around. Find its moment of inertia about its horizontal centroidal axis.

xc 8 in 12 in 1 in 1 in
A box section with 1 in walls

Judging without computing

Many questions ask only which section has more II, or how II changes. Three rules cover them:

  • A rectangle scales as width times depth cubed, so flat to on edge gains (long side/short side)2(\text{long side}/\text{short side})^2.
  • Scale every dimension of a shape by one factor, and II scales by its fourth power, which covers a circle's diameter.
  • With the area fixed, push it away from the axis, and II climbs. That's why steel beams keep so much of their area in two flanges.

Other questions ask which parallel-axis expression is set up correctly for one part of a section. The full calculation waits for Composite Sections, but the setup is just the theorem applied to that part. Take the T from Centroids of Areas.

12 in 2 in 8 in 7 in 2 in xc
A T-section and its centroidal axis

The flange's own centroid is 9 in above the bottom edge, and the T's is 7 in, so the flange's share of II about the T's axis is:

(12)(2)312⏟Ic+(24)(9−7)2⏟Ad2\underbrace{\frac{(12)(2)^3}{12}}_{I_c} + \underbrace{(24)(9 - 7)^2}_{Ad^2}

Each part uses its own centroidal value, with its own depth cubed, and dd runs from the part's centroid to the new axis, not from an edge.

Checkpoint
1 of 4

A rectangular beam 8 in deep is replaced by one of the same width and 12 in deep. By what factor does its moment of inertia about the horizontal centroidal axis grow?

Recap

  • Each bit of area counts by its distance squared: Ix=∫y2 dAI_x = \int y^2\,dA, in length to the fourth power, so 1 ft⁴ is 12412^4 in⁴.
  • A rectangle's Ixc=bh3/12I_{xc} = bh^3/12 cubes the dimension perpendicular to the axis.
  • The area table's IxI_x uses each row's own axis: the base for a rectangle or triangle, a tangent for a circle, and the flat side for a semicircle.
  • I=Ic+Ad2I = I_c + Ad^2, with one end of the transfer on a centroidal axis. The centroidal axis has the least II.
  • For a concentric hollow section, subtract the hole's I from the outer shape's.