Euler Buckling

A long column doesn't crush; it bows sideways at a load set by stiffness alone.

Before this Lesson

Stand a strand of dry spaghetti on the table and press down on its top. It doesn't crush. Long before the pasta comes near its strength, the strand bows out sideways, the bow runs away from you, and it snaps. Now break off half and try again. The half strand takes about four times the push, though nothing about the pasta changed but its length.

Why a column bows instead of crushing

Take a perfectly straight column with pinned ends, load it straight down its axis, and nudge its middle sideways. Now the load has a lever arm. It still acts along the line between the pins, but the column sits off that line by a distance yy, so the load bends it with a moment M=PyM = Py, the way it's already bowed. The column pushes back with its bending stiffness: a moment of EIEI times its curvature, the same EIEI that sets how far a beam deflects.

line of action of P P L y P P M y M = Py
A pin-ended column nudged into a bow

Under a light load, the column's push wins, and it springs back straight. Under a heavy one, the load wins, and the bow grows on its own. In between is one load where they tie, the critical load PcrP_{cr}, where the straight shape stops being the only way the column can stand.

A pin-ended column bows into half a sine wave, and a sine wave's curvature is (π/L)2(\pi/L)^2 times its offset yy at every point. Set the two moments equal:

Py=EI(πL)2yPy = EI\left(\frac{\pi}{L}\right)^2 y

The yy cancels. At one load, the column balances bowed by any small amount just as well as straight, so the smallest nudge leaves it bowed. The Handbook's Mechanics of Materials chapter prints that load under Columns as Euler's formula, with an effective-length factor KK for the end supports:

Pcr=π2EI(KL)2P_{cr} = \frac{\pi^2EI}{(KL)^2}

For pinned ends, K=1K = 1. The Handbook writes the length there as ℓ\ell, and its steel section writes LL, as this Lesson does.

Notice what's missing: strength. A36 steel and a steel twice as strong give the same PcrP_{cr}, because structural steels all have E=29,000E = 29{,}000 ksi. The column fails by bending out of the way, so only stiffness counts: EE for the material, II for the shape, and the length, squared. Halve the length, and PcrP_{cr} goes up four times. That's the spaghetti.

All this holds for a long, slender column, one that buckles while its stress is still below the proportional limit. Where stocky columns that yield first take over is the business of Slenderness and the Governing Axis.

It bows the easy way

Press a plastic ruler on end, and it always bows across its thin side, never across its wide one. A column has an II about every axis through its centroid, and it buckles about whichever gives the smallest PcrP_{cr}. With the same end supports in every direction, that's the axis with the smallest II, the weak axis. For a rectangle, it's the one that cubes the short side.

strong axis weak axis Imin = hb3/12 b h bows this way
A rectangular column's weak axis

A round section is the same in every direction, so any diameter will do. A hollow section is the solid minus the hole, with the fourth powers taken before you subtract. Subtract the diameters first, and a pipe with 0.5 in walls comes out with almost no II at all.

Putting in the numbers

Euler's formula has no unit conversion built in, so keep one length unit throughout. With EE in ksi and II in in⁴, put the length in inches, and PcrP_{cr} comes out in kips. With EE in MPa, which is N/mm², and II in mm⁴, use millimeters, and it comes out in newtons. A length left in feet makes the answer 144 times too big.

When a question names a material but no specific alloy, take EE from the Handbook's Table 1 - Typical Material Properties, in the Mechanics of Materials chapter:

Modulus of elasticity of three column materials
MaterialE as printedE in ksiE in MPa
Steel29.0 Mpsi (200.0 GPa)29,000200,000
Aluminum10.0 Mpsi (69.0 GPa)10,00069,000
Wood (fir)1.6 Mpsi (11.0 GPa)1,60011,000

Adapted from the FE Reference Handbook, Table 1 - Typical Material Properties

Worked Example A pin-ended steel bar
1 of 3

A solid steel bar, 2 in by 4 in, is 8 ft long and pinned at both ends. Find its Euler critical load.

End restraint shortens the bow

A pin can't resist turning, so the moment there is zero and the curve has no curvature: each pin is an inflection point. Euler's formula really measures the distance between two inflection points, one half sine wave. Hold the ends differently, and the half wave changes length. That length is the effective length KLKL.

P Fixed–fixed K = 0.5 P Fixed–pinned K = 0.7 P Pinned–pinned K = 1.0 P Fixed–free K = 2.0 L KL = 0.5L KL = 0.7L KL = L KL = 2L
Four end conditions, with the inflection points and effective length of each
  • Fixed–fixed. Both ends stay vertical, so the curve reverses near each, with inflection points at the quarter points. The middle half is a pin-ended column L/2L/2 long: K=0.5K = 0.5, and four times the pin-ended load.
  • Fixed–pinned. One inflection point falls inside the column, about 0.7L0.7L from the pin: K=0.7K = 0.7, and about twice the load.
  • Fixed–free, a flagpole. Mirror it in the ground, and the flagpole and its reflection make one pin-ended column twice as tall: K=2.0K = 2.0, and a quarter of the load.

The firmer the ends, the shorter the half wave. KK is a ruler for end conditions.

The Handbook lists those four theoretical values under Euler's formula. Its Civil Engineering chapter, after the steel beam tables, has AISC's fuller version. It describes each end by whether it can rotate and whether it can translate, and it adds a recommended design value:

Effective length factors for six end conditions
End conditionsTheoretical KRecommended K
(a) Fixed–fixed0.50.65
(b) Fixed–pinned0.70.80
(c) Fixed base, top sways without rotating1.01.2
(d) Pinned–pinned1.01.0
(e) Fixed–free2.02.10
(f) Pinned base, top sways without rotating2.02.0

Adapted from the FE Reference Handbook, Table C-A-7.1 AISC Approximate Values of Effective Length Factor, K

A real fixed end is never perfectly fixed. A footing or a welded connection lets it turn a little, the inflection points drift apart, and the effective length grows. That's why most recommended values are larger. Use the value the question names. Cases (c) and (f), whose tops sway, come next.

Worked Example A fixed–pinned pipe column
1 of 3

A steel pipe column has a 6 in outside diameter and 0.5 in walls. It is 20 ft tall, fixed at its base, and pinned at its top. Using the theoretical KK, find its Euler critical load.

A top that can sway

Picture a one-story frame: two columns with a stiff roof girder welded across their tops, and no bracing or walls. The girder keeps the column tops from rotating, but nothing stops the roof from sliding sideways. So when the columns buckle, their tops move over while staying vertical: rotation fixed, translation free.

P P rigid girder P P L/2 L/2 L Δ Fixed bases K = 1.0 Pinned bases K = 2.0
Frame columns under a rigid girder, free to sway

With a fixed base, each column bends into an S, with an inflection point at mid-height. Each half is a flagpole L/2L/2 tall, so KL=2(L/2)=LKL = 2(L/2) = L. That's case (c): theoretical K=1.0K = 1.0, recommended 1.2. It's fixed–fixed with the top let loose, and the sway alone doubles KK.

With a pinned base, the column is an upside-down flagpole. The girder holds the top vertical, like the ground at a flagpole's base, and the pin has zero moment, like a flagpole's tip. That's case (f), with K=2.0K = 2.0 both ways.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

A one-story frame column is 14 ft tall, with a weak-axis II of 40 in⁴. Its base is fixed to the footing, and its top is welded to a rigid roof girder. The frame has no bracing. Using the recommended KK, what is the column's Euler critical load?

A.
960 kip
B.
282 kip
C.
1,623 kip
D.
406 kip

Comparing columns without the whole formula

Euler's formula says the capacity goes as EI/(KL)2EI/(KL)^2. When two columns share the material and the section, everything but KLKL cancels from their ratio:

Pcr,1Pcr,2=(K2L2K1L1)2\frac{P_{cr,1}}{P_{cr,2}} = \left(\frac{K_2L_2}{K_1L_1}\right)^2

So a flagpole carries (1.0/2.0)2=1/4(1.0/2.0)^2 = 1/4 of what the same column carries with pinned ends. To rank several columns, find each KLKL and sort: the shortest effective length is the strongest. When only the section changes, the ratio is the ratio of the II values. For solid round sections, that's the diameter to the fourth power, so doubling the diameter multiplies the capacity by 16.

Checkpoint
1 of 3

Column A is pin-ended and 12 ft long. Column B has the same section and material, is fixed at both ends, and is 18 ft long. Using the theoretical KK, what is the ratio of B's Euler critical load to A's?

Sizing a column with a factor of safety

A designer wants the column to stay well clear of buckling under its working load. A factor of safety against buckling, FS, asks that the critical load be FS times the load the column carries:

Pcr=FS×PP_{cr} = \text{FS} \times P

The Handbook prints no buckling safety factor, so a question will state it. From there, solve Euler's formula backward for whatever is unknown: the longest length, the smallest II, or, for a round section, the smallest diameter from I=πD4/64I = \pi D^4/64.

The factor goes on the load, never on the length. Length is squared in the formula, so a factor of 4 on the load is only a factor of 2 on the length.

Worked Example The longest a strut can be
1 of 3

A pin-ended steel strut has a weak-axis II of 12.0 in⁴. It must carry 60 kip with a factor of safety of 2.5 against buckling. Find its longest allowable length.

Recap

  • A slender column bows sideways at Pcr=π2EI/(KL)2P_{cr} = \pi^2EI/(KL)^2, where the load's PyPy matches the column's stiffness. Strength never enters.
  • It buckles about the weak axis, the smallest II. Cube a rectangle's short side, take fourth powers before subtracting a hole, and keep the length in inches with ksi.
  • KLKL is the distance between inflection points. Theoretical KK: 0.5 fixed–fixed, 0.7 fixed–pinned, 1.0 pinned–pinned, 2.0 fixed–free. Recommended: 0.65, 0.80, 1.0, 2.10.
  • A top held against rotation but free to sway gives K=1.0K = 1.0 (recommended 1.2) over a fixed base, and 2.0 over a pinned one.
  • Ratios and rankings come from KLKL alone. A factor of safety goes on the load, Pcr=FS×PP_{cr} = \text{FS} \times P.