Truss Deflection by Virtual Work

Put an imaginary unit load where you want the deflection, and it tells you which members matter.

Before this Lesson

A sign hangs from two steel rods, one from each side, each falling 5 ft over a run of 12 ft. Under the sign's weight, each rod stretches 0.02 in. Yet the sign drops 0.052 in., more than two and a half times as far. A truss joint is that sign with more rods, each stretching or shortening a little at its own angle. This Lesson finds one number per member that says how much its stretch moves the joint, using statics alone.

Stretch turns into motion

The rods are pinned at their tops, A and B, and meet at C. When C drops a small distance Δ\Delta, each rod swings a hair and gets longer. Only the part of the drop along the rod adds length, and the rod falls 5 for every 13 of its length, so that part is 5/13 of the drop. Call a member's change in length ΔL\Delta L, as the Handbook does:

ΔL=513 Δ⇒Δ=135 ΔL=2.6 ΔL\Delta L = \tfrac{5}{13}\,\Delta \quad\Rightarrow\quad \Delta = \tfrac{13}{5}\,\Delta L = 2.6\,\Delta L
12 ft 5 ft 13 ft A B C C′ Δ ΔL C C′
C drops, and only the part of the drop along each rod lengthens it (motion exaggerated)

The part of the drop across the rod only swings it, which doesn't change its length. So a stretch of 0.02 in. lets C sink 0.052 in. The shallower the rod, the farther the joint must fall to use up the same stretch, which is why a clothesline pulled nearly flat sags so far.

A unit load measures leverage

Now forget the sign and hang a load of exactly 1 at C, in any units. Each rod pulls up with 5/13 of its force, so:

2(513)f=1⇒f=1.32\left(\tfrac{5}{13}\right)f = 1 \quad\Rightarrow\quad f = 1.3
1 f = +1.3 f = +1.3 A B C
A unit load at C and the force it puts in each rod

The shallow slope that made C move far also makes the rods work hard: each carries more than the whole load. Multiply each rod's ff by its stretch and add: (1.3)(0.02)+(1.3)(0.02)=0.052(1.3)(0.02) + (1.3)(0.02) = 0.052 in., the drop exactly.

Here's why. Keep the unit load at C, and let one rod out by a small ΔL\Delta L with a turnbuckle while the other keeps its length. C sinks by Δ\Delta, and the unit load with it. (C also slides a little sideways, which the hanging load doesn't feel, so it sinks only half as far as when both rods stretch.) The rod holds its tension ff all along, so letting it out is like lowering a bucket on a rope: your hands absorb f ΔLf\,\Delta L of work. Nothing else moves against a force, so that's the work the unit load gave up:

1⋅Δ=f ΔL1 \cdot \Delta = f\,\Delta L

So ff is how far the joint moves, along the unit load, per unit of that member's change in length. Change every member at once, and for motions this small the shares add. That's the Handbook's Truss Deflection by Unit Load Method:

Δjoint=∑fi (ΔL)i\Delta_{\text{joint}} = \sum f_i\,(\Delta L)_i

The entry's signs: ff is positive in tension, ΔL\Delta L is positive when a member gets longer, and Δ\Delta is positive in the direction the unit load points. A member the unit load compresses is propping the joint against it, so lengthening that member shoves the joint the other way, and its share is negative.

The unit load is imaginary, a measuring device that never touches the real truss. That's why this is called virtual work, and why ΔL\Delta L can come from anything: the loads, the weather, or a mistake in the shop.

Stretch from the loads

When the loads do the stretching, each member's ΔL\Delta L is FL/AEFL/AE, with FF its real force:

Δjoint=∑fiFiLiAiEi\Delta_{\text{joint}} = \sum \frac{f_i F_i L_i}{A_i E_i}

Keep the two forces apart. FF is what the real loads put in a member, and ff is what the unit load puts there alone. Both are tension-positive, so a member whose FF and ff share a sign moves the joint along the unit load, and one whose signs differ pulls it back.

The formula won't convert units for you: with EE in ksi, the lengths go in inches. Set it up as a table with a column for fFL/AfFL/A, and divide the total by EE when every member shares one. A calculator's list mode makes the sum quick.

Worked Example Reading the sum off a table
1 of 2

The steel truss below has a pin at A and a roller at C. The table gives each member's force FF under the loads shown, and its force ff under a unit load pointing down at D. With E=29,000 ksiE = 29{,}000\ \text{ksi}, find how far D moves down.

24 kip 12 kip 9 ft 9 ft 12 ft A B C D
A truss with a pin at A, a roller at C, and two loads at D
Member data, with f for a unit load down at D
MemberL (ft)A (in²)F (kip)f
AB92150.375
BC92150.375
AD153−5−0.625
CD153−25−0.625
BD12100

Two passes through the joints

Usually you get only the truss, so you run the method of joints twice:

  1. Real loads. Solve the truss as loaded for FF.
  2. Unit load. Take every real load off, put a single 1 at the joint whose motion you want, pointing the way you want it measured, and solve again for ff, reactions included.

Often the second pass is free. With one load PP, at the joint and in the direction asked about, the unit-load pass is the real one divided by PP, so f=F/Pf = F/P. With a second load anywhere, run the joints again.

Worked Example One load, two passes
1 of 2

Each member of this steel truss has A=2 in2A = 2\ \text{in}^2, with E=29,000 ksiE = 29{,}000\ \text{ksi}. Find how far C moves down.

25 kip 6 ft 8 ft 4.5 ft 10 ft 7.5 ft A B C
A truss on a pin at A and a roller at B, with a load at C

Where the unit load goes, and who sits out

The unit load goes at the joint whose motion you want, pointing along that motion, and it reports only the motion along its own line. If the sign's left rod alone stretched, C would sink 1.3 ΔL1.3\,\Delta L and slide 0.54 ΔL0.54\,\Delta L to the right, and a vertical unit load sees only the sink. To catch the slide, you hang it sideways, as the table's checkpoint did.

Some members drop out before any arithmetic, because their fFfF is zero:

  • F=0F = 0. The real loads leave the member alone, so it keeps its length, like the hanger BD in the table's truss.
  • f=0f = 0. Its stretch can't move this joint this way. Hang a load at B of that truss, and BD stretches. But with the unit load at D, joint B has no load and three members, two of them in line, so BD gets f=0f = 0. Stretching BD lowers B, and D, resting on its rafters, doesn't care.

The zero-force rules find both kinds in seconds: run them once for the real loads and once for the unit load.

Checkpoint
1 of 2
25 kip 6 ft 8 ft 4.5 ft 10 ft 7.5 ft A B C
A truss on a pin at A and a roller at B, with a load at C

You want to know how far the roller at B rolls under the 25 kip load. Where does the unit load go?

A.
1 kip down at C, where the real load acts
B.
1 kip down at B
C.
1 kip horizontal at B
D.
1 kip horizontal at C

Heat and misfits

Nothing in ∑f ΔL\sum f\,\Delta L asks why a member changed length. Warm one member, and it alone grows, by the free expansion from Thermal Strain and Indeterminate Bars, which the Handbook's entry writes as:

(ΔL)i=αLi (ΔT)i(\Delta L)_i = \alpha L_i\,(\Delta T)_i

So the sum has one term. A member fabricated too long or too short, a member misfit in the Handbook's words, works the same way, with ΔL\Delta L equal to the error, positive if it's too long. All you need is that member's ff. The loads, AA, and EE never enter. And in a determinate truss none of this causes stress: the truss just takes a slightly different shape.

The sign of ff says which way the joint goes. With a unit load down at C of the triangle truss from the second worked example, the tie AB pulls and the rafters push. A warm tie lets the rafters splay, and C sinks. A rafter that's too long props C up.

A B C AB longer fAB = +0.48 C sinks A B C BC longer fBC = −0.8 C rises
The triangle truss with its tie lengthened, then with a rafter lengthened (motion exaggerated)

If the tie warms 50°F, with steel's α=6.5×10−6\alpha = 6.5 \times 10^{-6} per °F from the Handbook's Table 1 - Typical Material Properties:

ΔC=fAB αL ΔT=(0.48)(6.5×10−6)(150)(50)=0.0234 in.\Delta_C = f_{AB}\,\alpha L\,\Delta T = (0.48)(6.5 \times 10^{-6})(150)(50) = 0.0234\ \text{in.}

It's positive, so C sinks 0.023 in.

Checkpoint
1 of 2
6 kip 10 kip 6 ft 8 ft A B C D
A truss pinned to a wall at A and B, with loads at C and D

The steel top chord AC warms 60°F, while the other members stay at their original temperature. Using Table 1, how far does D move down because of it?

in.

Recap

  • A unit load's force ff in a member is how far the joint moves, along the unit load, per unit of that member's change in length, so Δ=∑f ΔL\Delta = \sum f\,\Delta L. Tension, lengthening, and motion the way the unit load points are positive.
  • For the loads, Δ=∑fFL/AE\Delta = \sum fFL/AE: FF from the real loads, ff from the unit load alone, and lengths in inches with EE in ksi.
  • Find both by two passes of the method of joints. With one load PP at the joint and in the direction asked about, f=F/Pf = F/P.
  • Put the unit load at the joint, pointing along the motion you want. A member whose FF or ff is zero adds nothing.
  • For heat or a misfit, only that member counts: f αL ΔTf\,\alpha L\,\Delta T, or ff times the error, with too long as positive.