Influence Lines

An influence line shows where to park the truck to do the most damage.

Before this Lesson

Glue a strain gauge to a bridge girder, 10 ft in from one end of a 40 ft span, where it reads the bending moment. Roll a small cart across. The needle creeps up as the cart approaches, peaks when the cart is right over the gauge, and sinks to zero as the cart rolls off the far end. The gauge never moved. Only the cart did.

Plot the reading against where the cart was, and you've drawn an influence line: that one spot's answer to "where's the worst place to put a load?"

One effect, one section, a moving load

Start with a reaction. Put a 1 kip load on a 40 ft simple beam, xx feet from AA, and take moments about BB:

Ay=1−x40A_y = 1 - \frac{x}{40}

This is the plank from Beam Reactions: each foot of travel shifts P/LP/L off one support and onto the other. Plot it against the load's position, and you have an influence line.

40 ft x = 10 ft 1 kip A B Ay 1 0 0.75 where the load stands
The reaction at A as a 1 kip load travels across the beam

The Handbook's Influence Lines for Beams and Trusses, under Structural Analysis, defines one in just those terms, as the variation of an effect "caused by moving a unit load across the structure," and says it's used to position a moveable set of loads for the maximum effect. That's the whole section, with no shapes or rules, so the rest is yours to bring. The Moving Concentrated Load Sets rule right below it is about the absolute maximum moment anywhere on a span, a different question that this Lesson leaves alone.

Now back to the gauge. Fix a section, CC, 10 ft from AA, and follow the moment there. With the load right of CC, the left piece holds only AyA_y, so MC=10Ay=10−x/4M_C = 10A_y = 10 - x/4. With the load left of CC, the right piece holds only ByB_y, so MC=30By=0.75xM_C = 30B_y = 0.75x. That's two straight lines, meeting at 7.5 with the load on CC.

That triangle looks like a moment diagram, and reading it as one is the classic mistake. A moment diagram parks the load and walks the cut. An influence line parks the cut and walks the load.

Moment diagram: the load is parked 10 ft 15 ft 15 ft 1 kip A B C 3.75 9.375 M (ft-kip) where you cut Influence line for MC: the section is parked 1 kip A B C 3.75 7.5 MC per kip (ft) where the load stands
A moment diagram and an influence line for the same beam and load

The diagram's peak follows the load. The line's peak stays at CC, the only section it knows about. They agree on one fact: with 1 kip at 25 ft, the moment at CC is 3.75 ft-kip, shown above CC in the diagram and above the load in the line. The line is per kip of load, so a moment line's ordinates are in ft, and a reaction or shear line's have no units.

Müller-Breslau: cut the beam and push

You could build every line from free bodies. There's a shortcut, and it starts with a lever. Take away the support at AA and hold that end up with your hand, with the 1 kip load still at xx. The beam is now a rigid bar pivoting on BB. Raise your hand 1 ft, and the load rises some height yy. A lever trades force for distance, so your hand's work equals the work on the load:

Ay(1)=(1)(y)⇒Ay=yA_y(1) = (1)(y) \quad\Rightarrow\quad A_y = y

The height the beam rises at xx is the reaction with the load at xx. The displaced beam is the influence line. That's the Müller-Breslau principle, which the Handbook doesn't mention, and it works for any effect:

  1. Remove the restraint that carries the effect.
  2. Push the structure through a unit displacement in the direction of that effect.
  3. Read the displaced shape. It's the influence line.

On a determinate beam, the pieces swing as rigid bars on the supports that remain, so every line is made of straight segments, and every ordinate comes from similar triangles. Here, CC is a=10a = 10 ft from AA and b=30b = 30 ft from BB.

Reaction at A: remove the support, lift it by 1 A C B 1 0 Shear at C: insert a slider, separate by 1 A C B 1 +0.75 −0.25 Moment at C: insert a hinge, bend it by 1 radian A C B 1 rad 7.5 10 ft 30 ft
Three releases on the same beam, and the influence line each one draws

Shear's release is a slider: the faces at CC can slide but can't change angle, so the pieces stay parallel, with one slope ss. That slope has to open a gap of 1 at CC: sa+sb=1sa + sb = 1, so s=1/Ls = 1/L. The left piece ends at −a/L=−0.25-a/L = -0.25 and the right at +b/L=+0.75+b/L = +0.75. The jump of 1 is the load changing sides of the cut.

Moment's release is a hinge, bent through 1 radian. The pieces rise to one height hh, at angles h/ah/a and h/bh/b that add to 1 radian, so h=ab/L=7.5h = ab/L = 7.5. With P=1P = 1, that's the Pab/LPab/L in the Handbook's Simply Supported Beam Slopes and Deflections table.

One catch: the push follows the force on each piece, which runs against how the beam deforms. In the Handbook's Shearing Force and Bending Moment Sign Conventions, a positive moment bends a beam into a smile, yet its push makes a tent. A positive shear has the right portion tending down, yet its push sends the right piece up. When in doubt, place a load. A load just right of CC goes mostly to AA, shoving the left piece up against the right. That's positive shear, so the line just right of CC is above the axis.

Past the support, the line keeps going

Now run the beam 10 ft past BB. The pieces are still rigid bars, so each line goes straight through the support it pivots on and carries on to the tip, on the other side of the axis.

10 ft 30 ft 10 ft A B C tip Ay 1 −0.25 + − VC −0.25 +0.75 −0.25 − + − MC 7.5 −2.5 + − MB 0 −10 −
Influence lines on the beam with a 10 ft overhang

For MBM_B, the hinge goes right at BB. The back span sits on two supports and can't move, so its line is zero, and only the overhang swings. A section out on the overhang works the same way: everything behind it stays at zero.

Now the placement rules from Design Moments and Shears are just reading. MCM_C is above the axis on the span and below it on the overhang, so for the largest positive moment at CC, load the span only. MBM_B is zero on the span, so the span's load can't change it. AyA_y goes negative only on the overhang, so that's the load that lifts the back support.

Checkpoint
1 of 3

A beam has a pin at AA, a roller at BB, and an overhang past BB. Which is the influence line for the reaction at BB?

A.
A B 1
B.
A B 1
C.
A B 1

Load times ordinate

A beam is linear, so effects scale and add. A point load PP at ordinate yy contributes PyPy. A uniform load is a row of slivers w dxw\,dx, and they sum to ww times the area under the line.

effect=∑Pi yieffect=w×(area under the loaded part)\text{effect} = \sum P_i\, y_i \qquad\qquad \text{effect} = w \times (\text{area under the loaded part})

The word that matters is loaded. Live load goes where the ordinates have the sign you want, and nowhere else. Take the shear at CC on our simple beam, with w=2w = 2 kip/ft. The line has 12(30)(0.75)=11.25\tfrac{1}{2}(30)(0.75) = 11.25 ft of area above the axis and 12(10)(0.25)=1.25\tfrac{1}{2}(10)(0.25) = 1.25 ft below. Load only the right 30 ft, and VC=2(11.25)=22.5V_C = 2(11.25) = 22.5 kips. Load the whole span, and it falls to 2(11.25−1.25)=202(11.25 - 1.25) = 20 kips. Dead load gets no choice: it sits on the whole line and takes the net area.

A truck's axle spacing is fixed, so all you choose is where it stops. As it rolls, the total changes at a steady rate until an axle crosses the peak, so the largest total always comes with some axle on the peak. Start with the heaviest axle there, then try its neighbors. The heaviest axle is only a first guess.

Worked Example Where to stop the truck
1 of 4

A truck rolls from AA to BB on our 40 ft beam, with a 30 kip front axle and a 20 kip rear axle 8 ft behind it. Find the largest moment at CC.

20 kips 30 kips 8 ft A B C 10 ft 30 ft 7.5 MC
The truck on the beam, above the influence line for the moment at C

Continuous beams: load the spans that bow your way

A continuous beam takes the same recipe, with one difference: the other supports still hold the beam, so its pieces bend instead of swinging as rigid bars, and the line comes out curved. Its ordinates take real work, but its sign in each span takes only a sketch, and the sign is all you need. The Handbook says nothing about which spans to load.

Two facts draw the sketch. The beam passes through every support, and apart from your release, its slope carries straight across each one. So a span that bows up leaves its support heading down, and the next span bows down. Each span bows opposite to its neighbor, fading with distance.

Take four equal spans over supports AA through EE. For the largest positive moment in span BCBC, put a hinge at its midspan and push it up. BCBC bows up, ABAB and CDCD bow down, and DEDE bows up, so load BCBC and DEDE. For the largest negative moment over BB, put the hinge at BB. It can't rise off its support, so the push rotates both sides down: ABAB and BCBC bow down, CDCD up, and DEDE down. Load ABAB, BCBC, and DEDE.

Largest positive moment in span BC live load live load A B C D E − + − + Largest negative moment over B live load live load live load A B C D E − − + −
Two influence lines on a four-span beam, and the live load each calls for
The shapes are qualitative, with the far spans' bows exaggerated so their signs read clearly.
Which spans get the live load
Largest momentLoad
Positive, in a spanThat span and every other span
Negative, over a supportThe two spans beside it, then every other span

Dead load stays on every span, so only live load gets a pattern. Loading everything is the natural guess and a bad one, because a loaded span where the line has the wrong sign subtracts.

Checkpoint
1 of 3

A beam runs continuously over three equal spans, and section SS sits at the midspan of the center span. Which live load gives the largest positive moment at SS?

A.
S
B.
S
C.
S
D.
S

Recap

  • An influence line fixes one effect at one section and plots it against where a unit load stands. A moment diagram fixes the load and walks the cut.
  • Müller-Breslau: remove the restraint, push through a unit displacement, and the shape is the line. A reaction line is 1 at its support, a shear line jumps by 1 from −a/L-a/L to +b/L+b/L, and a moment line peaks at ab/Lab/L. On an overhang, each runs straight on to the tip.
  • The effect is ∑Py\sum Py or ww times the loaded area. Load only the part with the sign you want, and try each neighboring axle on the peak.
  • On a continuous beam the line alternates from span to span. For positive moment in a span, load it and every other span. For negative moment over a support, load the two spans beside it and every other span beyond.