Reinforced Concrete Beam Strength

Concrete takes the squeeze, steel takes the pull, and together they form a couple.

Squeeze 4,000 psi concrete, and it holds 4,000 psi. Pull on it, and it lets go at a few hundred. A loaded beam is squeezed along its top and stretched along its bottom, so a plain concrete beam cracks at the bottom, the crack runs straight up, and the beam breaks in two without warning.

So engineers put steel near the bottom, and then they do something that sounds like giving up: they let the concrete crack. Here's why that works, and how to put a number on what the beam can carry.

Let it crack

Load a beam that has steel bars near its bottom, and hairline cracks soon open along the bottom face. Each one climbs to the neutral axis, where stretching below turns into squashing above, and stops there. A crack can't pass a pull across itself, so below the neutral axis the steel carries all the tension. Above it, the concrete carries the compression.

w neutral axis compression cracked concrete tension steel
A reinforced concrete beam under load, with its cracks exaggerated

That leaves a push CC in the concrete near the top and an equal pull TT in the steel. Two equal, opposite forces a distance apart make a couple, and the couple is the beam's moment: force times lever arm.

The Handbook's Design of Reinforced Concrete Components (ACI 318-14) section names the parts: bb, the width of the compression face; dd, the effective depth, from the extreme compression fiber to the centroid of the tension steel; AsA_s, the area of that steel; fc′f'_c, the concrete's strength from Concrete Strength and the Water-Cement Ratio; and fyf_y, the steel's yield strength, usually 60,000 psi. And hh is the overall height.

The pull acts in the steel, so the lever arm starts there, and that's why strength uses dd, not hh. The cover below the bars keeps fire and corrosion away from them, but it sits on the cracked side and carries nothing.

What the concrete is doing when the beam fails

Keep loading. In a well-proportioned beam the steel yields first, so TT stops growing at AsfyA_sf_y. The beam keeps bending, the cracks climb, and the compression zone gets shallower and more squashed, until the top fiber reaches a strain of 0.003 and crushes. The moment then is the nominal moment strength, MnM_n.

The strain grows in a straight line, from zero at the neutral axis, a depth cc below the top, to 0.003 at the top. The stress follows concrete's curved stress-strain curve, which is a nuisance to integrate. But the couple needs only two things from it: how big the push CC is, and where it acts. Charles Whitney swapped the curve for a rectangle that gets both right, which the Handbook calls the equivalent rectangular stress block: a uniform 0.85fc′0.85f'_c over a depth a=β1ca = \beta_1 c.

As neutral axis b h d 0.003 εt c no concrete tension 0.85f′c a = β1 c d − a/2 C C = 0.85f′c  b a T = As  fy Section Strain Actual stress Equivalent rectangle
Strain, stress, and forces at the moment the concrete crushes
The curved stress and the rectangle push with the same force C, at the same depth. Below the neutral axis, the concrete carries nothing.

Source: Adapted from the FE Reference Handbook, Design of Reinforced Concrete Components (ACI 318-14), Internal Stress, Strain, and Forces due to Positive Moment Loading. Actual stress curve and labels added.

The Handbook's β1\beta_1 table gives 0.85 for fc′f'_c up to 4,000 psi, then 0.05 less for each 1,000 psi above that, down to 0.65 from 8,000 psi up:

β1=0.85−0.05 fc′−4,0001,000(4,000<fc′<8,000 psi)\beta_1 = 0.85 - 0.05\,\frac{f'_c - 4{,}000}{1{,}000} \qquad (4{,}000 < f'_c < 8{,}000\ \text{psi})

Stronger concrete has a more triangular stress curve, whose push sits higher, so the rectangle that matches it is shallower. The stress block rests on five assumptions, which the Handbook builds into its formulas without listing:

  1. Strain varies linearly with depth.
  2. The concrete crushes when the top fiber's strain reaches 0.003.
  3. The concrete carries no tension.
  4. The compression is a uniform 0.85fc′0.85f'_c over a=β1ca = \beta_1 c.
  5. The steel has yielded, so its stress is fyf_y. This one gets checked.

The couple gives the strength

The steel pulls with T=AsfyT = A_sf_y, and the rectangle pushes with C=0.85fc′ b aC = 0.85f'_c\,b\,a. They must balance, and that fixes aa:

a=Asfy0.85fc′ ba = \frac{A_sf_y}{0.85f'_c\,b}

The steel decides how big the force is, and the concrete only decides how deep the block reaches to supply it. CC acts at a/2a/2 below the top, so the lever arm is d−a/2d - a/2:

Mn=Asfy(d−a2)M_n = A_sf_y\left(d - \frac{a}{2}\right)

The design strength is ϕMn\phi M_n, with ϕ=0.9\phi = 0.9 when the section passes the check in the next section, and the Handbook requires ϕMn≥Mu\phi M_n \ge M_u: demand versus capacity, ϕRn≥Ru\phi R_n \ge R_u.

The Handbook works in psi and in.-lb. Kips and inches work too and keep the numbers small, with MnM_n in in.-kip divided by 12 for ft-kip. Just don't pair fc′f'_c in psi with fyf_y in ksi. AsA_s comes from the Handbook's bar table:

Areas of common bar sizes
Bar sizeDiameter (in.)Area (in²)
#50.6250.31
#60.7500.44
#70.8750.60
#81.0000.79
#91.1281.00
#101.2701.27

Source: Adapted from the FE Reference Handbook, Design of Reinforced Concrete Components (ACI 318-14), ASTM Standard Reinforcement Bars

Worked Example The moment strength of a beam
1 of 3

A rectangular beam is 12 in. wide and 22.5 in. tall, with four #8 bars at d=20d = 20 in. It has fc′=4,000f'_c = 4{,}000 psi and fy=60,000f_y = 60{,}000 psi. Find aa and ϕMn\phi M_n.

Did the steel yield first?

The strain line can check the fifth assumption, and it tells you how much warning the beam gives. Since a=β1ca = \beta_1 c, the stress block gives c=a/β1c = a/\beta_1. Carry the line down to the steel, and similar triangles give the net tensile strain:

εtdt−c=0.003c⇒εt=0.003 dt−cc\frac{\varepsilon_t}{d_t - c} = \frac{0.003}{c} \quad\Rightarrow\quad \varepsilon_t = 0.003\,\frac{d_t - c}{c}

The Handbook writes dtd_t, the depth to the lowest layer of steel. With one layer, dt=dd_t = d.

Grade 60 steel yields at about 60/29,000=0.002160/29{,}000 = 0.0021, with the 29,000 ksi the Handbook gives for steel. The Handbook's Resistance Factors table asks for more: ϕ=0.9\phi = 0.9 only for a tension-controlled section, with εt≥0.005\varepsilon_t \ge 0.005. By the time the concrete crushes, that steel has stretched more than twice its yield strain, so the beam has cracked and sagged where everyone can see it. That warning is what ϕ=0.9\phi = 0.9 rewards. Below 0.005, ϕ\phi drops, as Designing Reinforced Concrete Beams shows.

For the worked example's beam, c=4.65/0.85=5.47c = 4.65/0.85 = 5.47 in., so εt=0.003(20−5.47)/5.47=0.0080\varepsilon_t = 0.003(20 - 5.47)/5.47 = 0.0080, and ϕ=0.9\phi = 0.9 holds. Add steel, and CC has to grow, so cc gets deeper. The line pivots on the 0.003 at the top, and less strain is left for the steel:

d = 20 in. 0.005 0.003 εt  = 0.0080 c = 5.47 in. As  = 3.16 in2 steel 0.005 0.003 εt  = 0.0025 c = 10.93 in. As  = 6.32 in2
The worked example's beam, and the same beam with its steel doubled
Checkpoint
1 of 2

A beam is 12 in. wide, with three #9 bars at d=19.5d = 19.5 in. It has fc′=5,000f'_c = 5{,}000 psi and fy=60,000f_y = 60{,}000 psi. What is its net tensile strain εt\varepsilon_t?

What makes a beam stronger

The steel sets the force, and dd sets the lever arm. The width and the concrete strength appear only as 0.85fc′ b0.85f'_c\,b, inside aa, which reaches the lever arm only as a/2a/2. Here's the worked example's beam with one input doubled at a time:

The worked example's beam, with one input doubled
Doubledaa (in.)MnM_n (ft-kip)Changeεt\varepsilon_t
Nothing4.65279.3none0.0080
AsA_s9.29485.2+74%0.0025
dd4.65595.3+113%0.0189
bb2.32297.6+7%0.0189
fc′f'_c2.32297.6+7%0.0138

Doubling dd more than doubles MnM_n, because the lever arm gains the full 20 in. while aa stays put. Doubling the steel falls short, because the block deepens and the arm shrinks, and εt\varepsilon_t drops below 0.005, so ϕ\phi falls too. Doubling bb or fc′f'_c only halves aa, which is worth 7%. The concrete just has to hold up its end of the couple, and a thin band across the top does that.

Checkpoint
1 of 3

A tension-controlled beam needs more moment strength, and the designer can make one change. Which raises ϕMn\phi M_n the most?

A.
Double the width bb
B.
Increase AsA_s by 25%
C.
Increase dd by 25%
D.
Double fc′f'_c

From strength to load

Set the demand equal to the capacity, and solve for the load:

wuL28=ϕMn⇒wu=8 ϕMnL2\frac{w_uL^2}{8} = \phi M_n \quad\Rightarrow\quad w_u = \frac{8\,\phi M_n}{L^2}

That wuw_u includes the beam's own weight, which comes from the whole section, bb by hh. The Handbook prints no unit weight for reinforced concrete, so a question gives one, usually 150 lb/ft³:

wself=b h144 (150) lb/ft(b, h in inches)w_{\text{self}} = \frac{b\,h}{144}\,(150)\ \text{lb/ft} \qquad (b,\ h \text{ in inches})

For the largest service live load, take 1.2wD1.2w_D out of wuw_u, self-weight included, and divide what's left by 1.6.

Worked Example The live load a beam can carry
1 of 3

The worked example's beam, 12 in. wide and 22.5 in. tall with ϕMn=251.4\phi M_n = 251.4 ft-kip, spans 24 ft. Besides its own weight, it carries 0.50 kip/ft of superimposed dead load. Concrete weighs 150 lb/ft³. Find the largest service live load it can carry.

Recap

  • Once the concrete cracks, the steel carries the tension and the concrete above the neutral axis the compression. The couple's lever arm starts at the steel, so strength uses dd, not hh.
  • The stress block swaps the curved stress for 0.85fc′0.85f'_c over a=β1ca = \beta_1 c, with the same force and centroid. β1\beta_1 is 0.85 up to 4,000 psi, then falls 0.05 per 1,000 psi to 0.65.
  • a=Asfy/(0.85fc′ b)a = A_sf_y/(0.85f'_c\,b) and Mn=Asfy(d−a/2)M_n = A_sf_y(d - a/2), and ϕMn≥Mu\phi M_n \ge M_u. ϕ=0.9\phi = 0.9 needs εt≥0.005\varepsilon_t \ge 0.005, from c=a/β1c = a/\beta_1, so the steel stretches well past yield and the beam warns before it fails.
  • Depth is the strongest lever. More steel helps less than in proportion, and bb and fc′f'_c barely matter.
  • On a simple span, the largest factored uniform load is 8ϕMn/L28\phi M_n/L^2. For the service live load, take out 1.2wD1.2w_D, self-weight included, and divide by 1.6.