Steel Tension Members

A bolted plate is only as strong as its weakest path between the holes.

Before this Lesson

Take an A36 steel plate 6 in. wide and 1/2 in. thick. It's good for about 97 kips of factored tension. Now drill a hole through it for a 3/4 in. bolt. The design rules count 15% of the steel at that section as gone, and the plate is still good for 97 kips. Drill a second hole beside the first, and they count 29% as gone, yet the strength falls only to 92 kips.

The arithmetic is fine. A tension member can stop working in two different ways, and a hole matters to only one of them.

Stretching and tearing

Pull on a plate with bolt holes near its ends, and raise the load. The first steel to yield is beside the holes, where the section is smallest. It sounds alarming, and it doesn't matter. Say the plate is a 20 ft hanger and the yielded zone is about an inch long. Stretch that inch by 1% and the hanger grows by 0.01 in. Nobody will ever know.

Keep raising the load, and one of two things ends the member's job.

Yielding of the gross section. The plate reaches its yield stress FyF_y along its whole length. Now all 240 in. are stretching, and 1% is 2.4 in. Whatever the hanger holds has dropped 2.4 in. and keeps dropping with almost no added load. Nothing has broken, but the member has stopped being useful, slowly and in plain sight. Most of the length has no holes, so this check uses the gross area AgA_g.

Rupture of the net section. The steel at the holes doesn't stop at FyF_y. It hardens and carries more, until it reaches the ultimate strength FuF_u and tears. So this check pairs FuF_u with the reduced area at the holes, the effective net area AeA_e. A tear comes suddenly, and a sudden failure gets a smaller ϕ\phi.

Local yielding at the holes P P Short length, almost no stretch. Not a limit state. Yielding of the gross section P P stretch The whole length yields: Fy on Ag Rupture of the net section P P Tears across the holes: Fu on Ae
One plate, with local yielding and the two limit states

The Handbook lists both limit states under Tension Members: Flat Bars or Angles, Bolted or Welded. It writes the factors as ϕy\phi_y and ϕf\phi_f, where many references write ϕt\phi_t for both. Each ϕ\phi times its PnP_n is a design strength:

ϕyPn=0.90FyAgϕfPn=0.75FuAe\phi_y P_n = 0.90 F_y A_g \qquad\qquad \phi_f P_n = 0.75 F_u A_e

The same list has Ω\Omega values for ASD and a third limit state, block shear, which this Lesson leaves out.

Demand versus capacity works as it always does: ϕPn≥Pu\phi P_n \ge P_u, with PuP_u from the combinations in Loads and Load Combinations. The design strength is the smaller of the two, though the Handbook doesn't say so. Compare them after each gets its own ϕ\phi, because rupture's lower factor can change which is smaller.

A question states the stresses or names a grade. The Handbook's Table 2 - Average Mechanical Properties of Typical Engineering Materials gives A36 as 36 ksi and 58 ksi, printed as σy\sigma_y and σu\sigma_u. It lists no other structural grade, so a question using one states its values.

What's left at the holes

In Axial Stress, you cut straight across a hole and deducted its diameter: An=(bg−dh)tA_n = (b_g - d_h)t. Steel design keeps the cut and deducts more. A bolt hole is 1/16 in. larger than its bolt so the bolt will fit, and another 1/16 in. gets written off, the usual reason being that making the hole roughs up the steel around it. The Handbook gives dh=db+1/16 in.d_h = d_b + 1/16\ \text{in.} and this net area, with the sum running over the holes the cut passes through:

An=[bg−∑(db+18 in.)]tA_n = \left[ b_g - \sum \left( d_b + \tfrac{1}{8}\ \text{in.} \right) \right] t

If a question gives the hole diameter instead, the deduction is dh+1/16 in.d_h + 1/16\ \text{in.}

bg net width: bg − Σ(db + 1/8 in.) db deducted: db + 1/8 in. dh = db + 1/16 in.
What a bolt hole takes from the cut

Only holes on the cut count. Bolts side by side across the plate each take a deduction. Bolts in a line along the load take one between them, since a straight cut meets only one of them. For a bolted plate, which the Handbook calls a flat bar, the effective net area is simply the net area: Ae=AnA_e = A_n.

Worked Example The plate from the Hook
1 of 4

An A36 plate, 6 in. wide and 1/2 in. thick, is connected by two 3/4 in. bolts side by side across its width. Find its design tensile strength.

A tear can zigzag

Stagger the bolts and a tear gets a choice. It can go straight across, through few holes, or zigzag from hole to hole, through more of them. Each extra hole makes the path easier. But each slanted leg is longer than the width it crosses, and all of that steel has to tear too.

P P straight path zigzag path g s g s √(g² + s²)
Two ways across a plate with staggered holes

How much longer? A leg that crosses gg while moving ss along the plate has length g2+s2\sqrt{g^2 + s^2}, which is about g+s2/2gg + s^2/2g when ss isn't large. The Handbook gives back half of that extra, s2/4gs^2/4g, for each diagonal:

An=[bg−∑(db+18 in.)+∑s24g]tA_n = \left[ b_g - \sum \left( d_b + \tfrac{1}{8}\ \text{in.} \right) + \sum \frac{s^2}{4g} \right] t

Here ss is the spacing along the load and gg the spacing across it, between lines of holes. The Handbook writes the deduction here as dh+1/16 in.d_h + 1/16\ \text{in.}, the same thing.

Why only half? Steel on a slanted line isn't simply pulled apart. Part of the load acts along the line as shear, so an inch of diagonal is worth less than an inch of straight cut. The term is a simple rule that tests back up, not pure geometry, so take it as printed.

The Handbook stops at the formula, but the plate tears wherever it's weakest, so you go looking. A tear runs from edge to edge and meets each line of holes once, without doubling back. Sketch each such path, work out its bracket in inches, and take the smallest. That's the critical path. Multiply by tt last, so that s2/4gs^2/4g gets multiplied too.

Worked Example Straight or zigzag?
1 of 3

An 8 in. by 1/2 in. plate has 3/4 in. bolts in two staggered lines. Find its net area.

3/4 in. bolts t = 1/2 in. straight zigzag 8 in. 2.5 in. g = 3 in. 2.5 in. s = 2 in.
An 8 in. plate with two staggered lines of holes

When only part of the section is connected

Bolts across a plate's width feed load into every part of it. Now bolt an angle through one leg. The load enters through that leg, and the other leg, sticking out into space, gets its share only after the stress has spread around the corner, which takes distance. Near the connection, the connected leg is overworked and the outstanding leg is along for the ride, so not all of the net area counts. That's shear lag. The Handbook never uses the term, but it prints the factor that accounts for it:

Ae=UAnU=1−xˉLA_e = U A_n \qquad\qquad U = 1 - \frac{\bar{x}}{L}
outstanding leg, edge-on P stress bunched near the bolts spread out L centroid x̄ connected leg outstanding leg
An angle bolted through one leg

xˉ\bar{x}, the Handbook's connection eccentricity, is the distance from the connected face to the member's centroid. LL is the length of the connection, from first bolt to last or along the weld, though the Handbook defines it only for welds. The formula reads the way it should: a centroid far off to the side lowers UU, and a longer connection gives the stress more room to spread, which raises it.

The Handbook has no angle table, despite its note to use tabulated areas, so a question gives you AgA_g and xˉ\bar{x}, or UU itself. Start from AgA_g, subtract (db+1/8 in.)t(d_b + 1/8\ \text{in.})t for each hole on the cut, and then apply UU. A welded member has no holes, so its AnA_n is just AgA_g.

The Handbook also prints fixed values. A bolted flat bar, or a flat bar or angle with transverse welds, gets 1.0. A flat bar welded only along its edges takes load from the sides, so the middle lags, and UU runs 1.0, 0.87, then 0.75 as the weld length falls from 2w2w toward the bar's width ww.

Worked Example An angle bolted through one leg
1 of 3

An A36 L4×4×1/2 angle, with Ag=3.75 in2A_g = 3.75\ \text{in}^2 and xˉ=1.18\bar{x} = 1.18 in., is bolted through one leg with one line of three 3/4 in. bolts spaced 3 in. apart. Find its rupture strength.

Which one governs?

Two questions sound alike here. The critical path is about geometry: which path leaves the least steel? The governing limit state is about strength: with that area in hand, is rupture weaker than yielding? A plate always has a critical path, and yielding can still govern. The Hook's plate shows how.

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1.0 Ae/Ag Design strength (kips) Yielding: 0.90FyAg Rupture: 0.75FuAe 0.745 design strength no holes one hole 97.2 kips two holes, 92.4 kips
Design strength of the Hook's plate as holes remove section
A 6 in. by 1/2 in. A36 plate. Yielding doesn't notice the holes. Rupture falls in step with AeA_e, and it takes over at Ae/Ag=0.745A_e/A_g = 0.745.

That crossing comes from setting the two strengths equal: 0.90FyAg=0.75FuAe0.90F_yA_g = 0.75F_uA_e, so Ae/Ag=1.2Fy/FuA_e/A_g = 1.2F_y/F_u. For A36 it's 0.745, so holes can take about a quarter of the section before they cost anything. For a steel with Fy=50F_y = 50 ksi and Fu=65F_u = 65 ksi it's 0.923, so rupture takes over after only 8%. The stronger steel gained more in FyF_y than in FuF_u, which leaves less room.

Checkpoint
1 of 3

Two plates have the same size and hole pattern, with Ae/Ag=0.85A_e/A_g = 0.85. One is A36, and the other has Fy=50F_y = 50 ksi and Fu=65F_u = 65 ksi. Which limit state governs each?

A.
Yielding governs both
B.
Rupture governs both
C.
Yielding governs the A36 plate, and rupture governs the other
D.
Rupture governs the A36 plate, and yielding governs the other

Recap

  • A tension member has two limit states: yielding on the gross area, ϕyPn=0.90FyAg\phi_y P_n = 0.90F_yA_g, and rupture on the effective net area, ϕfPn=0.75FuAe\phi_f P_n = 0.75F_uA_e. The smaller design strength governs and must be at least PuP_u.
  • Yielding over a short length at the holes is harmless. Yielding along the whole length stretches the member, with warning. Tearing at the holes happens at FuF_u and comes suddenly, so it gets a lower ϕ\phi.
  • Each hole on the cut deducts db+1/8 in.d_b + 1/8\ \text{in.} Bolts side by side all count, and bolts in a line along the load count once.
  • With staggered holes, An=[bg−∑(db+1/8 in.)+∑s2/4g]tA_n = [b_g - \sum(d_b + 1/8\ \text{in.}) + \sum s^2/4g]t. Check each path, and the smallest is critical, whether or not it has the most holes.
  • Ae=UAnA_e = UA_n, with U=1.0U = 1.0 for a bolted flat bar and U=1−xˉ/LU = 1 - \bar{x}/L when only part of the section is connected. UU goes on the net area, which equals the gross only when there are no holes.