Design Moments and Shears

Factor the loads first, and the beam diagrams give the demand.

Before this Lesson

A beam spans 16 ft between two supports and runs 8 ft past the second one to hold up a balcony. Crowd the whole thing, and the largest factored positive moment in the span is 54 ft-kip. Send everyone off the balcony, and it climbs to 87. Now clear the span and pack only the balcony, and the far end of the beam tries to lift off its support.

Fewer people, worse beam. Settling that takes factored loads and overhang statics, so those come first, and they build MuM_u and VuV_u, the demand every design Lesson checks. Then this beam comes back, and the last stop is a beam with a hinge in it.

Factor the loads, then run the beam

Tributary Areas and Load Paths left you with line loads on beams and point loads on girders, all at service level. The demand, the right side of ϕRn≥Ru\phi R_n \ge R_u, comes from factored loads, and there are two roads to it. Run the beam once for dead load and once for live load, then combine the moments. Or factor the loads first and run the beam once.

A beam is linear: double the load, and the moment doubles. So the two roads end at the same number. Take that Lesson's 25 ft floor beam, with wD=0.90w_D = 0.90 and wL=0.50w_L = 0.50 kip/ft. Run it twice with wL2/8wL^2/8, and MD=70.3M_D = 70.3 and ML=39.1M_L = 39.1 ft-kip. Factor first, and wu=1.2(0.90)+1.6(0.50)=1.88w_u = 1.2(0.90) + 1.6(0.50) = 1.88 kip/ft. Either way:

effects first:Mu=1.2(70.3)+1.6(39.1)=146.9 ft-kiploads first:Mu=wuL28=1.88(25)28=146.9 ft-kip\begin{aligned} \text{effects first:}\quad M_u &= 1.2(70.3) + 1.6(39.1) = 146.9\ \text{ft-kip} \\ \text{loads first:}\quad M_u &= \frac{w_u L^2}{8} = \frac{1.88(25)^2}{8} = 146.9\ \text{ft-kip} \end{aligned}

Loads first takes one run instead of two, so that's the habit. The Handbook's beam tables will take a factored ww as happily as a service one, so the arithmetic won't warn you. Its concrete section defines MuM_u and VuV_u as the factored moment and factored shear force at a section, and a moment from service loads is neither.

Worked Example A floor beam with a hanging load
1 of 3

Floor beams span 20 ft at a 10 ft spacing, under 70 psf of dead load and 80 psf of live load. Each one also holds up a 5 kip dead load hung at midspan. Find MuM_u.

A girder takes its load in lumps

Now the girder those floor beams land on, with two equal loads PuP_u at its third points. Walk the shear from the left. It starts at the reaction, PuP_u, holds level to the first load, drops to zero, stays there through the middle third, and drops to −Pu-P_u. The moment climbs along the first third, and then, with no shear left to push it, goes flat.

Pu Pu Pu Pu L/3 L/3 L/3 V +Pu −Pu M Pu L/3
Two equal loads at the third points: a moment plateau
Vu=PuMu=Pu(L3)=PuL3V_u = P_u \qquad M_u = P_u\left(\frac{L}{3}\right) = \frac{P_u L}{3}

The Handbook's beam tables have no row for this case, and it's easy to reach for one that exists. PL/4PL/4 is one load at midspan. Lump the two loads into a single 2Pu2P_u at midspan and you get PuL/2P_u L/2, 50% high. Use PuL/4P_u L/4, or spread the loads out uniformly, which comes to the same thing, and you're 25% low.

VuV_u is the shear right beside a support. Under downward loads, the shear only loses ground as you walk in from a reaction, so on a simple beam VuV_u is the larger factored reaction: half the total when the load is symmetric, and a moment equation when it isn't.

Worked Example The girder on our floor
1 of 4

A 30 ft girder carries floor-beam reactions at its third points, with PD=22.5P_D = 22.5 kips and PL=12.5P_L = 12.5 kips at each point. Find VuV_u and MuM_u.

When a beam runs past its support

Let a beam run past its support, and wL2/8wL^2/8 stops being true. That formula assumes zero moment at both supports. An overhang's load bends the beam down over the support, so the moment there isn't zero. It's negative. In the Handbook's sign convention, from Internal Shear and Moment in Beams, positive moment bends a beam concave upward with tension in the bottom fibers, so negative moment is a frown with tension on top. The span still sags, but the overhang is levering it up, so its peak comes in below wL2/8wL^2/8.

A B tension on the bottom tension on top span overhang
An overhanging beam, with its bending exaggerated

The Handbook's tables have no overhanging beam, so both peaks come from the statics you already know. With an overhang of length aa, a cut at the support sees only what's out there, so you need no reactions:

MB=−(wua22+Pua)M_B = -\left(\frac{w_u a^2}{2} + P_u a\right)

For the positive one, take moments about BB to find the back reaction, AyA_y. Under a uniform wuw_u with no point load in the span, the shear falls from AyA_y to zero at x=Ay/wux = A_y/w_u, and the triangle under it is the moment:

M+=Ay22wuM^{+} = \frac{A_y^2}{2w_u}

A cantilevered balcony beam is the first move and nothing else. The wall takes the place of the support, so MuM_u at the fixed end has the same form as MBM_B, and VuV_u there is the whole load, wua+Puw_u a + P_u.

Worked Example The two moments of an overhanging beam
1 of 3

The loads shown are factored. Find the negative moment over BB and the positive moment in the span.

8 kips 2.0 kip/ft A B C 20 ft 6 ft
A beam with a 6 ft overhang and a load at its tip

Where should the live load stand?

So far, the loads have been handed to you. In design, you have to pick. Dead load is the building itself, so it's on every foot of the beam all the time. Live load is people and furniture, and it can be anywhere, including nowhere. The demand at a section is the worst the live load can do there, and the worst may come from leaving part of the beam empty.

Think of the beam as a seesaw pivoting on BB. Load on the overhang pushes that end down and rocks the back span up. Load on the span pushes the other way. Three questions follow:

  • Largest positive moment in the span. Press down on the span and take away what lifts it: live load on the span only.
  • Largest negative moment over the support. The cut at BB sees only the overhang, so load the overhang. Whatever is on the span makes no difference to this moment.
  • Uplift at the back support. Only the span's load holds AA down, and only the overhang's pries it up: live load on the overhang only.

Here's the Hook's beam: a 16 ft span and an 8 ft overhang, with wD=0.5w_D = 0.5 and wL=1.5w_L = 1.5 kip/ft. The figure draws them factored, with 1.2(0.5)=0.61.2(0.5) = 0.6 kip/ft of dead load on every foot and 1.6(1.5)=2.41.6(1.5) = 2.4 kip/ft of live load where it's placed. So a loaded stretch carries 3.0 kip/ft, and an empty one 0.6.

Live load on the span only live 2.4 kip/ft dead 0.6 kip/ft A B Ay = 22.8 kips 16 ft 8 ft +86.6 −19.2 Live load on the overhang only live 2.4 kip/ft dead 0.6 kip/ft A B Ay = −1.2 kips lifts off 16 ft 8 ft −96 Live load on both live 2.4 kip/ft dead 0.6 kip/ft A B Ay = 18.0 kips 16 ft 8 ft +54 −96 M in ft-kip
One beam, three live load placements
Each moment diagram is drawn with positive moment above the line.
The Hook's beam under each placement
Live load onAyA_y (kips)M+M^{+} (ft-kip)MBM_B (ft-kip)
Span only22.886.6−19.2
Overhang only−1.2none−96
Both18.054−96

Loading everything wins none of these three outright, though it does give the largest reaction and shear at BB, which matters for VuV_u. A negative AyA_y means the beam needs its back support to pull down. A support that only bears can't, so the beam lifts off unless it's anchored. The empty span keeps its 1.2D1.2D here because the Handbook's 0.9D0.9D lines pair dead load only with wind or earthquake.

Over BB, the top face is in tension in all three, because even the overhang's dead load bends the beam down there. At the span's positive peak, the bottom face is. That's why a concrete beam's bars run along its top over a support. The Handbook says nothing about where to place live load, so this reasoning is yours to bring. Influence Lines makes it a general tool.

Checkpoint
1 of 3

This beam's overhang is at its left end, so its back support, AA, is on the right. The thin band is dead load, and the tall blocks are live load. Which placement comes closest to lifting the beam off AA?

A.
B A
B.
B A
C.
B A

A hinge passes shear and nothing else

Some beams have an internal hinge, a pin built in partway along where two pieces meet, and a beam like that is a compound beam. Think of a door hinge. Push one leaf up and the other goes with it, so a force gets across. Try to bend across it, and it just folds, so it can't carry a moment. That zero is a gift: one extra equation. The Handbook mentions it once, in passing, as an "internal moment of zero at a hinge" in Stability, Determinacy, and Classification of Structures, which Determinacy and Stability puts to work. Its beam tables have no hinged beams.

With one hinge, one piece can stand on its own and the other can't. The one that can't has a support at one end and only the hinge at the other. That's the suspended span. To it, the hinge is a pin, giving a vertical force and no moment, so it's just a simple beam. Its reaction at the hinge, VHV_H, pushes back down on the piece holding it up, as a point load on the end of a cantilever or an overhang. You've already solved both.

Whole beam wu A H C Cut at the hinge VH wu A H supporting piece: a cantilever VH Cy wu H C suspended span: a simple beam
Cutting a compound beam at its hinge

So the order of work is: suspended span first, then pass VHV_H along, then the supporting piece. A uniform load that crosses the hinge gets split there, and each piece carries only the load sitting on it. And zero moment at the hinge applies to one side at a time. Write it for the whole beam, and you've only restated equilibrium.

Worked Example A uniform load across a hinge
1 of 3

A two-span girder has a hinge HH in its right span, and the load shown is factored. Find the shear through the hinge and all three reactions.

2.0 kip/ft A B H C 20 ft 5 ft 10 ft
A two-span girder with a hinge in one span

From the hinge back to the support

The hinge force reaches the supporting piece's support with a long lever arm, so that's usually where the big moment sits. For a supporting piece of length aa with a load wuw_u of its own, it's the overhang expression again, with VHV_H as the tip load:

Msupport=−(wua22+VH a)M_{\text{support}} = -\left(\frac{w_u a^2}{2} + V_H\, a\right)

Everything here is linear in the load, so it also runs backward. Write VHV_H in terms of the unknown load, write the support moment in terms of VHV_H, and set the result equal to the design strength ϕMn\phi M_n. That's demand versus capacity, ϕRn≥Ru\phi R_n \ge R_u, with the capacity given and the load left to find.

Worked Example The largest load on a suspended span
1 of 3

The uniform load is factored, and the fixed end has a design strength ϕMn=300\phi M_n = 300 ft-kip. Find the largest factored point load PuP_u the suspended span can carry at its midspan.

Pu 1.6 kip/ft A φMn = 300 ft-kip H C 10 ft 10 ft 10 ft
A suspended span on a cantilevered segment

Recap

  • Factor first, then run the beam. A beam is linear, so factoring loads or effects gives the same demand, MuM_u and VuV_u.
  • Two equal third-point loads give Vu=PuV_u = P_u and Mu=PuL/3M_u = P_u L/3, not PuL/4P_u L/4. On a simple beam, VuV_u is the larger factored reaction.
  • wL2/8wL^2/8 doesn't work on an overhang. Cut at the support for the negative moment, with the top face in tension there, and find AyA_y for the positive one.
  • Dead load is always everywhere, and live load can be anywhere. Load the span only for the largest positive moment, the overhang for the largest negative moment, and the overhang only for uplift at the back support.
  • A hinge carries shear but no moment. Solve the suspended span first as a simple beam, splitting any uniform load at the hinge, then put VHV_H on the supporting piece as a point load.