End Areas and Volumes
Slice the earthwork into thin prisms and average their ends.
Before this Lesson
A new road has to go through a ridge, and before anyone can bid the job, somebody has to say how many cubic yards are coming out. You can't put a tape on a ridge. But you can stake a slice of it every so often, draw the slice, and measure its area, and two slices with the distance between them give you a volume. This Lesson takes you from stakes to cubic yards, and shows you the one place where the easy formula runs half again too high.
Two slices make a volume
Between two slices, the dirt does whatever it likes, and nobody measured it. So make the simplest guess that respects both ends: treat the stretch between them, called a reach, as a prism whose cross section is the average of the two ends. A prism's volume is its cross section times its length, and that's the Average End Area Formula in the Handbook's Earthwork formulas:
Here and are the two end areas, and is the distance between them along the road. When the ends match, the reach really is a prism and the formula is exact. When they don't, it's an estimate, and later you'll see which way it leans.
The length comes from the stations: delete the pluses and subtract, as in Stations and Grades. Square feet times feet gives cubic feet, but earthwork is bid and paid by the cubic yard. A cubic yard is 3 ft on each side, or 27 ft³, so the last step is to divide by 27. The Handbook's conversion table has no row for this one, so carry it in your head.
Down the table, one pair at a time
A real job has a section at every full station and wherever the ground changes, so the spacing is often uneven. That changes nothing. Each pair of neighboring stations is its own reach with its own length, so work down the table and add. Here's a cut with three reaches, no two the same length:
| Reach | End areas (ft²) | L (ft) | Volume (ft³) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 30+00 to 31+00 | 120, 200 | 100 | 16,000 |
| 31+00 to 31+60 | 200, 260 | 60 | 13,800 |
| 31+60 to 33+00 | 260, 140 | 140 | 28,000 |
| Total | 300 | 57,800 |
That's 57,800 / 27 = 2,141 yd³. Most jobs carry a cut column and a fill column, and those stay apart. A cut area is dirt to dig out and a fill area is dirt to place, so averaging one with the other describes no dirt at all. Total each column on its own. Comparing the totals is a job for Cut, Fill, Shrinkage, and Mass Haul.
What a slice looks like
So where do end areas come from? Stand on the road's centerline, look ahead on station, and imagine slicing straight across the ground. The drawing of that slice is a cross section. You measure across it in offsets, feet left or right of the centerline, and up it in elevation. A road's section has three parts:
- The roadbed, the flat finished surface of width , centered on the centerline. Its elevation is the finished grade.
- The side slopes, from each roadbed edge out to the ground, written H:V as :1, so feet across for every 1 ft up or down.
- The slope stakes, or catch points, where each side slope meets the ground, telling the crew where the work starts.
The Handbook doesn't draw a cross section or mention slope stakes. It's all geometry, so you can build it right here.
Start on level ground, with the roadbed a depth below it. Each side slope climbs , so its horizontal run is : the ratio times the depth. The slope stake sits that far past the roadbed edge, and the edge is half the roadbed from the centerline:
The section is a trapezoid, across the bottom and across the top. A trapezoid's area is its height times its average width, as the plane-figure table in the Handbook's Statics pages prints it (), so:
A fill on level ground is the same trapezoid flipped, with the roadbed on top and the slopes running down and out to a stake at each toe. The same two formulas apply.
Stakes on tilted ground
Ground rarely lies flat across a road. Tilt it, and the two stakes stop matching. The rule stays , but now is the depth at the stake, not at the centerline. On the uphill side of a cut, the ground keeps rising as you walk out, so the slope has farther to climb and the stake lands farther out. On the downhill side, it lands closer in. A fill flips this, with its far stake on the downhill side.
If a problem gives the depth at the stake, that one line finishes it. If it gives the centerline depth and the ground's cross slope as a decimal, the depth also changes by for every foot out, so . Substitute and solve:
Take the minus on the side where the ground pulls away from grade, and the plus on the side where it closes in. Put the last road on ground rising at 10% to the right. On the right, , where the cut is . On the left, .
Any section is a polygon
Real ground has bumps. A crew records each place the ground changes slope as a break point, with its offset and elevation. Join those to the side slopes and the roadbed, and the section's outline is a polygon, and you already have a formula for polygons: the coordinate method from Area by Coordinates and Offsets, with offset in place of and elevation in place of . In the Handbook's Area by Coordinates, that's offset as and elevation as .
Offsets left of the centerline go in as negative. Only coordinate differences matter, so subtract the finished grade from every elevation and work in heights above it, which keeps the products small. And sketch it first: section notes usually list points from left to right, which isn't the order around the outline.
Stack the corners in order around the boundary and repeat the first at the bottom. Total each times the one row down, total each times the one row down, subtract, and halve. A minus sign only says which way you walked.
You can also split the outline by hand. Drop a line from each ground break point to the grade, and each strip under the ground line is a trapezoid: its width times its average height. Those strips reach all the way out to the stakes, so they include the triangle outside each side slope, and you subtract those.
A side-hill section is two areas
Now put a road across a hillside. The uphill side cuts into the hill, the downhill side stands on fill, and somewhere across the roadbed the ground passes through the finished grade. That point splits the section into a cut polygon and a fill polygon, and each gets its own area, in its own column.
The ground between two break points is a straight line, so find the crossing by proportion. Then that point becomes a corner of both pieces. Don't run the whole outline through one stack. That path crosses itself at the split, the two loops take opposite signs, and the formula hands you their difference, which is neither the cut nor the fill.
When a section runs out
Follow a cut triangle like that one down the road. Say the hillside falls away ahead, so each section has less cut than the one before. The triangle gets narrower and shallower at the same time, until at the cut-fill transition it's gone. A solid that pinches from a full base down to nothing isn't a prism. It's a pyramid, and the Handbook's Earthwork formulas give it its own line, Pyramid or Cone: . The there is the distance along the road to where the area reaches zero, which is the you've been using:
Why a third, when average end area would say half? Stand halfway along the pyramid. The section there is half as wide and half as deep, so its area is a quarter of the base, not a half. Area goes with the square of the distance from the tip.
Average end area sees only the two ends, so it draws the area falling in a straight line. That gives , half again more than the real . You've seen that straight line before: average end area is the trapezoidal rule, with section area in place of offset. Where the curve dishes in, the straight top rides above it and counts dirt that isn't there.
It takes shrinking both ways. If the width held steady and only the depth fell, the area really would drop in a straight line, and average end area would be right. A real transition usually falls somewhere between those two, and the pyramid is the standard model. When a question says a section runs out to zero, it means the pyramid, unless it tells you to carry average end area through a zero in a table.
Average end area against the prismoidal method
The Handbook's Earthwork formulas print one more, the Prismoidal Formula, where is the area of the mid-section:
Those weights of 1, 4, 1 should look familiar: this is Simpson's 1/3 rule over two intervals of . A third measurement lets it follow a curve that average end area can only cut across. Try it on the pyramid: gives , exactly right. Try it on a steady section, with all three areas equal: it gives , the same as average end area.
The mid-section is a real slice with its own dimensions, so average the end dimensions, then compute its area. Going from 10 ft by 10 ft to 20 ft by 20 ft, it's 15 ft by 15 ft, or 225 ft². Averaging the end areas would say 250 ft². The Handbook names but doesn't say how to get it.