Hazen-Williams Head Loss

Water utilities use a friction formula built for water in real pipes.

Before this Lesson

On summer evenings, when the whole neighborhood waters its lawns at once, the pressure sags at the far end of an 8 in. water main. The fix on the table is a 10 in. main, a quarter more diameter.

A quarter more diameter suggests a quarter less friction, and the bore's 56 percent more area suggests a little better. Both guesses are far too timid: the wider main loses about a third as much head. One exponent explains why.

One number for the pipe wall

In The Energy Equation, the head loss hfh_f was a number the problem handed you. For a length of pipe, physics supplies it through the Handbook's Darcy-Weisbach equation, under Head Loss Due to Flow:

hf=f LD v22gh_f = f\,\frac{L}{D}\,\frac{v^2}{2g}

Its friction factor ff depends on the Reynolds number and the pipe's relative roughness, so finding it takes the water's viscosity and the Moody diagram. Pipe Friction does all of that, for any fluid in any pipe.

A water utility moves one fluid, at ordinary temperatures, through pipes wide enough that the flow is always turbulent. There the Reynolds number shifts ff only a little, and the pipe wall does most of the work. So in the early 1900s, Allen Hazen and Gardner Williams fit an equation to losses measured in real water pipes, with the wall boiled down to one number, the Hazen-Williams coefficient CC. There's no Reynolds number and no chart. The price is that it's a formula for water and nothing else.

CC is a smoothness score: the higher it is, the less head the pipe loses. That's backward from Manning's nn, where a higher number means a rougher channel. These are the values this Lesson's problems use:

Hazen-Williams C for common pipe materials
Pipe materialC
Plastic150
Ductile iron140
Concrete (regardless of age)130
Cast iron, new130
Cast iron, 5 yr old120
Cast iron, 20 yr old100
Welded steel, new120

Adapted from the FE Reference Handbook, Values of Hazen-Williams Coefficient C

The cast-iron rows show what age does. Unlined cast iron rusts from the inside into knobs called tubercles, which roughen the wall and narrow the bore. The formula keeps the pipe's original diameter, so the lower CC carries both effects.

tubercles New C = 130 20 yr old C = 100
A cast-iron main when new and after 20 years

Why diameter rules

Darcy-Weisbach already tells you the formula's shape. The loss goes as Lv2/DLv^2/D, and at a fixed flow the velocity goes as Q/D2Q/D^2, so

hf∝L Q2D5h_f \propto \frac{L\,Q^2}{D^5}

Try it in your head. Halve the diameter and push the same flow through. The water moves four times as fast, so its velocity head is 16 times as big, and the narrower pipe has twice as much wall for each gallon to rub against. That's 32 times the loss, from half the diameter.

Hazen and Williams's measurements come out close to that. The Handbook's Circular Pipe Head Loss Equation (Head Loss Expressed in Feet) is

hf=4.73 L Q1.852C1.852 D4.87h_f = \frac{4.73\,L\,Q^{1.852}}{C^{1.852}\,D^{4.87}}

with hfh_f and the length LL in feet, the flow QQ in cfs, and the diameter DD in feet. Keep a diameter like 10/12 ft unrounded in your calculator, since the 4.87 power magnifies any rounding nearly fivefold. The flow's exponent is a little under 2 because a real pipe's friction factor eases off slightly as the water speeds up. (The Handbook first prints Hazen-Williams as a velocity, v=k1CRH0.63S0.54v = k_1 C R_H^{0.63} S^{0.54}, in the style of Manning's equation. For a pipe flowing full, it's the same equation.)

Change one quantity, hold the rest, and everything else cancels in the ratio of the new loss to the old. The loss goes as LL, and nearly as Q2Q^2. CC shares the flow's exponent and sits under it, so the loss really depends on (Q/C)1.852(Q/C)^{1.852}: dividing CC by some factor costs exactly as much as multiplying the flow by it. And the diameter, at 4.87, dominates. For the Hook's main,

h10h8=(810)4.87=0.34\frac{h_{10}}{h_8} = \left(\frac{8}{10}\right)^{4.87} = 0.34

The wider main loses about a third as much head. The inches cancel in the ratio, so there was nothing to convert.

0 5 10 15 20 25 30 28.8 ft 7.1 ft 2.4 ft 1.0 ft 6 8 10 12 Q = 600 gpm, C = 130 Diameter (in.) Head loss per 1,000 ft (ft)
Head loss in four mains carrying the same flow
Each main carries 600 gpm with C=130C = 130. The circles under the bars are the pipes' cross-sections, to scale.
Checkpoint
1 of 2

A new cast-iron main loses 5.0 ft of head per 1,000 ft at its design flow. Using the Handbook's C values, about how much will it lose per 1,000 ft at the same flow once it's 20 years old?

ft

Gallons, psi, and the pressure form

The 4.73 has its units built in: cfs and feet. Water problems love gallons, though, so much of the work is converting the flow. The Handbook's Units and Conversion Factors table gives 1 ft³ = 7.481 gal and 1 cfs = 0.6463 million gallons per day (MGD). The rest follow from the 60 seconds in a minute and the 1,440 minutes in a day:

  • 1 cfs = 7.481 × 60 = 449 gallons per minute (gpm)
  • 1 MGD = 1,000,000 / 1,440 = 694 gpm
  • 1 MGD = 1 / 0.6463 = 1.547 cfs

Utilities also think in pressure rather than head, so the Handbook prints a second version, its Circular Pipe Head Loss Equation (Head Loss Expressed as Pressure):

P=4.52 Q1.85C1.85 D4.87P = \frac{4.52\,Q^{1.85}}{C^{1.85}\,D^{4.87}}

Here PP is the pressure loss in psi per foot of pipe, a rate rather than a total, so the drop over a length is ΔP=PL\Delta P = PL. It's the feet form with the conversions folded into the constant, and the two agree within about half a percent. Each constant works only with its own units:

The Handbook's two head-loss forms
FormConstantResultQ inD in
Head loss4.73ft, over the whole lengthcfsft
Pressure4.52psi per ft of pipegpmin.
Worked Example Head loss and pressure drop in a steel main
1 of 2

A new 12 in. welded steel main runs level for 3,000 ft and carries 2.0 MGD. Find its head loss, and the pressure drop from one end to the other.

Running it backward

Many problems give you all but one of the five quantities and ask for the last. Each sits in the equation raised to a power, so the move is always the same: get the unknown's power alone on one side, then take the root. Your calculator's equation solver can also take the formula as written and solve for whichever one is missing.

The flow a main can carry

An allowable loss caps the flow. Say the steel main from the Worked Example may lose only 10 ft over its 3,000 ft. Isolate Q1.852Q^{1.852}, then take the 0.54 power, since 1/1.852=0.541/1.852 = 0.54:

Q=[hf C1.852D4.874.73 L]0.54=[10(120)1.852(1)4.874.73(3,000)]0.54=2.38 cfsQ = \left[\frac{h_f\,C^{1.852}D^{4.87}}{4.73\,L}\right]^{0.54} = \left[\frac{10(120)^{1.852}(1)^{4.87}}{4.73(3{,}000)}\right]^{0.54} = 2.38\ \text{cfs}

That's down from 3.09 cfs. The flow falls more gently than the allowable loss, because it answers to the loss only at the 0.54 power. With an allowable pressure drop instead, divide it by the length to get PP, and solve the pressure form the same way.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

A 10 in. concrete main is 4,000 ft long. If it may lose no more than 15 ft of head, how much flow can it carry?

gpm

The smallest main, or the longest

The Handbook lists no standard pipe sizes, so a sizing problem gives you the choices. Solve for the diameter the allowable loss calls for,

D=[4.73 L Q1.852C1.852 hf]1/4.87D = \left[\frac{4.73\,L\,Q^{1.852}}{C^{1.852}\,h_f}\right]^{1/4.87}

then round up to the next size on the list. Rounding to the nearest size can land on a pipe slightly too small, and a pipe 5 percent too narrow loses 28 percent too much. You can also test the choices from the smallest up and take the first that stays within the limit. A limit per length, such as 4 ft per 1,000 ft, is just hf=4h_f = 4 ft with L=1,000L = 1{,}000 ft.

Length is the easiest unknown, because the loss is proportional to it: divide the allowable loss by the loss per foot at the design flow.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

A ductile iron main must carry 1.44 MGD and lose no more than 4 ft of head per 1,000 ft. It comes in 8, 10, 12, and 14 in. sizes. What is the smallest size that works?

A.
8 in.
B.
10 in.
C.
12 in.
D.
14 in.

C from a field test

An old main's CC can only be guessed from the table, so utilities measure it. They run a known flow through the main and read two pressure gauges a known distance apart. On a level main of one diameter, the pressure drop is the friction loss over that length, and the equation hands back C=Q [4.73L/(hfD4.87)]0.54C = Q\,[4.73L/(h_f D^{4.87})]^{0.54}. A value well below the table's for the pipe's material and age points to heavy tuberculation.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

In a field test, 1.2 cfs flows through 2,000 ft of 8 in. main, and the hydraulic grade line drops 18 ft along that length. What is the main's C?

Pressures in Water Mains puts these losses into the energy equation to find the pressure left at a delivery point, and splits a flow between mains in parallel.

Recap

  • Hazen-Williams folds the friction factor into one smoothness number, CC, for water only. Higher CC is smoother, the reverse of Manning's nn, and cast iron falls from 130 new to 100 at 20 years.
  • hf=4.73 L Q1.852/(C1.852D4.87)h_f = 4.73\,L\,Q^{1.852}/(C^{1.852}D^{4.87}) takes cfs and feet. P=4.52 Q1.85/(C1.85D4.87)P = 4.52\,Q^{1.85}/(C^{1.85}D^{4.87}) gives psi per foot from gpm and inches.
  • 1 ft³ = 7.481 gal, 1 cfs = 449 gpm, 1 MGD = 1.547 cfs = 694 gpm, and 1 psi = 2.31 ft of water.
  • The loss goes as LL, Q1.852Q^{1.852} (3.6 times for double the flow), and C−1.852C^{-1.852}, but diameter dominates at D−4.87D^{-4.87}.
  • Run it backward by isolating the unknown's power and taking the root, and round a required diameter up.