Pressures in Water Mains

The pressure at the tap is what's left of the reservoir's height after friction takes its share.

Before this Lesson

Screw a pressure gauge onto a fire hydrant 150 ft below the surface of the reservoir that feeds it through a mile of 12 in. main. With nothing flowing, it reads 65 psi. Then a crew opens a hydrant down the street, 1,500 gpm pours out, and the needle sinks to 54 psi and holds there.

The reservoir didn't drop, and neither did the hydrant. So where did 11 psi go?

The grade line sets the pressure

With no water moving, nothing is lost, so the HGL is a level line at the reservoir's surface, and the pressure head is just the pipe's depth below it: 150 ft, or 150/2.31 = 65 psi. Utilities call that the static pressure.

Open the hydrant, and the main starts paying friction. The HGL still starts at the reservoir's surface, but now it slopes down and arrives at the hydrant hfh_f lower. The pipe hasn't moved, so the pressure head, the HGL's height above the pipe, shrinks by hfh_f. What's left is the residual pressure.

flow node HGL, no flow HGL, flowing hf P/γ zR − z
The HGL along a main, with and without flow
The water surface is at zRz_R and the node at zz. In a long main, the entrance loss and velocity head are too small to show.

So a pressure question on a main is a question about where the HGL is. Write the energy equation from the reservoir's surface, where the pressure and velocity heads are zero, to a node in the main. The HGL there is the surface, less every loss on the way and the velocity head the water still carries:

HGL=zR−hf−Kev22g−v22gPγ=HGL−z\text{HGL} = z_R - h_f - K_e\frac{v^2}{2g} - \frac{v^2}{2g} \qquad \frac{P}{\gamma} = \text{HGL} - z

From here on, hfh_f is the pipe friction alone. The Handbook writes the entrance coefficient as CC; calling it KeK_e keeps it apart from Hazen-Williams CC. For psi, divide feet by 2.31, or multiply by 0.433, per the Handbook's conversion table. In a long main friction dwarfs the other terms, but use them when they're given.

Between two reservoirs, both surfaces drop their pressure and velocity heads, and the difference in level pays for the friction, the entrance, and the exit. That's the water-surface difference a main needs:

z1−z2=hf+(Ke+1.0)v22gz_1 - z_2 = h_f + (K_e + 1.0)\frac{v^2}{2g}
Worked Example The residual pressure at the hydrant
1 of 3

The Hook's reservoir has its surface at elevation 820 ft, and the node at the hydrant is at 670 ft. The main is 5,280 ft of 12 in. ductile iron with a sharp entrance, carrying 1,500 gpm. Find the HGL elevation and the residual pressure at the node.

Over the ridge

The HGL knows nothing about the pipe's route. The reservoirs and friction set it, and the pipe may dip below it or climb above it. In a long gravity main of one diameter, with the minor losses small, friction is spread evenly along the length, so the HGL runs straight from one water surface to the other. Where the pipe climbs above it, the pressure head HGL−z\text{HGL} - z is negative: the water is below atmospheric pressure.

HGL 0 4,000 ft 10,000 ft El. 600 ft El. 520 ft crest, El. 590 ft 22 ft El. 568 ft P < 0
A gravity main crossing a ridge
One diameter throughout, 10,000 ft long. Vertical distances are exaggerated.

Here the HGL falls 80 ft over 10,000 ft, so at the crest, 4,000 ft along, it stands at 600−0.4(80)=568600 - 0.4(80) = 568 ft. The crest is at 590 ft, so P/γ=−22P/\gamma = -22 ft, or −22/2.31=−9.5-22/2.31 = -9.5 psi. Water still flows, since the total head keeps falling, as in a siphon, but a gauge at the crest reads a vacuum.

A main shouldn't run that way. Dissolved air comes out at low pressure and collects at the crest, choking the flow, and leaky joints there suck groundwater in. Nor can the pressure fall more than one atmosphere below gauge zero, 33.9 ft of water by the Handbook's conversion table; the water boils just short of that, and the column breaks. The fix is to keep the main below the HGL.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

A gravity main of one diameter runs 16,000 ft from a reservoir with its surface at elevation 1,240 ft to one with its surface at 1,160 ft. 6,000 ft from the upper reservoir, it crosses a crest at elevation 1,215 ft. Neglecting minor losses and the velocity head, what is the pressure at the crest?

psi

Pipes in series

A main often changes size along its route. Pipes joined end to end are in series: each carries the same flow, since water can't pile up at a reducer, and the losses add, since the water pays each pipe's toll in turn. The Handbook doesn't print this rule; it's continuity and the energy equation, one pipe at a time.

hf=hf1+hf2+⋯h_f = h_{f1} + h_{f2} + \cdots

With the loss going as D−4.87D^{-4.87}, the narrowest pipe usually dominates: at the same flow and CC, a foot of 8 in. pipe loses (12/8)4.87=7.2(12/8)^{4.87} = 7.2 times as much as a foot of 12 in., so each foot of 8 in. counts as 7.2 ft of 12 in. That's the idea of an equivalent pipe, a single pipe that loses the same head at the same flow. With one CC throughout, a series set equals a length LeL_e of a chosen diameter DeD_e, or a single diameter for a chosen total length:

Le=∑Li(DeDi)4.87De=[∑Li∑Li/Di4.87]1/4.87L_e = \sum L_i\left(\frac{D_e}{D_i}\right)^{4.87} \qquad D_e = \left[\frac{\sum L_i}{\sum L_i/D_i^{4.87}}\right]^{1/4.87}

Both work with the diameters left in inches.

Worked Example Losses through a main that narrows
1 of 3

A main runs 2,000 ft of 12 in. pipe and then 1,500 ft of 8 in. pipe, all with C=120C = 120, and carries 800 gpm. Find the total head loss, and the length of 12 in. pipe that would lose the same head.

Grade lines through a series main

On a profile, each pipe in a series main draws its own stretch of grade line. The HGL's slope along a pipe is that pipe's head loss per foot, and the gap up to the energy line is that pipe's velocity head. At a fitting, the energy line steps down by the fitting's loss. Where the pipe size changes, the HGL steps by whatever keeps it one velocity head below.

energy line HGL P J H 12 in. 8 in.
A gravity main of two sizes between two reservoirs
Checkpoint

The figure shows a 12 in. pipe and an 8 in. pipe in series between two reservoirs, with the energy line and HGL. Which statements are true?

A.
The pressure head at P is the vertical distance from P up to the energy line.
B.
The pressure at H is below atmospheric.
C.
The HGL falls more steeply along the 8 in. pipe because that pipe carries less flow.
D.
The gap between the lines is wider along the 8 in. pipe because the water moves faster there.
E.
A pump installed at J would make both lines jump up there by the pump head.

Pipes in parallel

Pipes that leave one junction and meet again at another, such as a new main laid beside an old one, are in parallel.

Q Q Q1 Q2 1 2 A B HGLA HGLB
Two mains in parallel

At junction A there's one pressure, and so one HGL, whichever branch you look into, and the same goes for B. So both branches lose the same head, HGLA−HGLB\text{HGL}_A - \text{HGL}_B. The Handbook's Multipath Pipeline Problems section puts it plainly: "For pipes in parallel, the head loss is the same in each pipe." The flows add, Q1+Q2=QQ_1 + Q_2 = Q, but the losses don't.

Think of the water choosing its path. If the big branch lost less head than the small one, more water would crowd into it until the losses evened out. So the larger, smoother branch ends up with most of the flow.

Set the two branches' Hazen-Williams losses equal, and the 4.73 cancels. Taking both sides to the 0.54 power, since 1/1.852=0.541/1.852 = 0.54 and 4.87/1.852=2.634.87/1.852 = 2.63, gives

Q1Q2=C1C2(D1D2)2.63(L2L1)0.54\frac{Q_1}{Q_2} = \frac{C_1}{C_2}\left(\frac{D_1}{D_2}\right)^{2.63}\left(\frac{L_2}{L_1}\right)^{0.54}

Then Q1+Q2=QQ_1 + Q_2 = Q finishes the split, and either branch gives the common loss. For a 12 in. and an 8 in. main of equal length and CC, the ratio is (12/8)2.63=2.90(12/8)^{2.63} = 2.90, so the 12 in. main takes 74 percent: more than half, and more than its 69 percent share of the area, because the water in the bigger pipe also moves faster. A single pipe of the same length and CC replaces the pair if De2.63=D12.63+D22.63D_e^{2.63} = D_1^{2.63} + D_2^{2.63}.

Worked Example Splitting a flow between two mains
1 of 2

Two parallel mains, both with C=120C = 120, join junctions A and B. One is 3,000 ft of 12 in. pipe, and the other is 2,000 ft of 8 in. pipe. Together they carry 1,500 gpm. Find the flow in each and the head loss from A to B.

The same rules with Darcy-Weisbach

The rules come from continuity and one HGL per junction, so they hold for any friction formula. With Darcy-Weisbach and given friction factors, use the flow-rate form from Pipe Friction:

hf=8fLQ2π2gD5h_f = \frac{8fLQ^2}{\pi^2 g D^5}

In series, add each pipe's loss, with its own ff. When the flow is unknown, as between two reservoirs, factor it out: z1−z2=Q2∑8fiLi/(π2gDi5)z_1 - z_2 = Q^2 \sum 8f_iL_i/(\pi^2 g D_i^5). In parallel, equal losses give the split below, which follows from the Handbook's Multipath Pipeline Problems equation, written there with velocities. The exponents are 2 and 5, so a square root replaces the 0.54 power.

Q1Q2=(D1D2)5f2L2f1L1\frac{Q_1}{Q_2} = \sqrt{\left(\frac{D_1}{D_2}\right)^5\frac{f_2L_2}{f_1L_1}}
Checkpoint
1 of 2

Two parallel pipes share 4.0 cfs: 800 ft of 6 in. pipe with f=0.022f = 0.022, and 1,200 ft of 10 in. pipe with f=0.018f = 0.018. How much flow goes through the 6 in. pipe?

cfs

Junctions and loops

A city's distribution system is a grid of mains, with many paths to each house. Two rules hold it together, and the Handbook prints neither:

  • Junctions: at every junction, the flow arriving equals the flow leaving, counting any demand drawn off there. That's continuity.
  • Loops: around any closed loop, the head losses add to zero, counted positive where you travel with the flow and negative where you travel against it. You end where you started, at the same HGL, so the drops and climbs have to cancel.

A parallel pair is the simplest loop: out along branch 1 and back along branch 2, the rule reads hf1−hf2=0h_{f1} - h_{f2} = 0, the equal-loss rule again. Big networks are solved by guessing the flows and correcting them until every loop balances, as the Hardy Cross method does, but exam questions stop at the rules and small loops.

Checkpoint
1 of 2
5.0 cfs 5.0 cfs A B C D 3.0 cfs hf = 12 ft 3.0 cfs hf = 8 ft 2.0 cfs hf = 15 ft 2.0 cfs hf = ?
A pipe loop with four junctions

In the loop shown, water enters at A and leaves at C. What is the head loss in pipe DC?

ft

Recap

  • The HGL starts at the reservoir's surface and falls by every loss. The pressure head is its height above the pipe, P/γ=HGL−zP/\gamma = \text{HGL} - z, and feet over 2.31 give psi.
  • Between two reservoirs, z1−z2=hf+(Ke+1.0) v2/2gz_1 - z_2 = h_f + (K_e + 1.0)\,v^2/2g, and in a long gravity main the HGL runs straight from surface to surface.
  • Where a pipe rises above the HGL, as at a ridge, the pressure is below atmospheric, which invites air pockets and inflow.
  • Series: one flow, losses add. Parallel: one head loss, flows add, and Q1/Q2=(C1/C2)(D1/D2)2.63(L2/L1)0.54Q_1/Q_2 = (C_1/C_2)(D_1/D_2)^{2.63}(L_2/L_1)^{0.54} with Hazen-Williams.
  • Flows balance at every junction, and signed head losses add to zero around every loop.