Flow in Sewers

A sewer carries the most a little below full.

Before this Lesson

Lift a manhole cover on a dry afternoon, and you'll see a few inches of wastewater trickling along the floor of a pipe two feet across. Come back in a storm, and the same pipe runs nearly to the top. Either way, the water slides downhill with air above it, so a sewer isn't a pressure main. It's an open channel that happens to be round, and its designer asks channel questions: how much it carries, how deep and how fast a given flow runs, whether the trickle keeps the pipe clean, and how far the pipe drops to the next manhole.

A round open channel

A sewer runs on gravity. Its slope supplies the pull, its wetted wall supplies the drag, and when the two balance, the flow is uniform. That is the balance from Manning's Equation, and the Handbook's version of it, under Hydrology/Water Resources, applies unchanged:

Q=Kn ARH2/3S1/2v=Kn RH2/3S1/2Q = \frac{K}{n}\,A R_H^{2/3} S^{1/2} \qquad v = \frac{K}{n}\,R_H^{2/3} S^{1/2}

with K=1.486K = 1.486 for feet and seconds and RH=A/PR_H = A/P. Here SS is the slope of the pipe, which in uniform flow is also the slope of the water surface. The only new work is the geometry of a circle.

Flowing full, the water touches the whole circumference, so P=πDP = \pi D and A=πD2/4A = \pi D^2/4. The Handbook doesn't print the result, but it's one line:

RH=πD2/4πD=D4R_H = \frac{\pi D^2/4}{\pi D} = \frac{D}{4}

That's a quarter of the diameter, not the radius D/2D/2, one more reminder that the hydraulic radius isn't the radius of anything. Pipe sizes come in inches, and K=1.486K = 1.486 wants feet, so an 18-in. pipe has D=1.5D = 1.5 ft and RH=0.375R_H = 0.375 ft.

Now let the pipe drain to exactly half full. The water fills the lower half of the circle, so it has half the area. It touches the lower half of the wall, so it has half the wetted perimeter. The free surface across the middle drags on nothing, as always. Half over half leaves RH=D/4R_H = D/4, the same as full.

D free surface (not wetted) Full A = πD2/4 P = πD RH = D/4 Half full A = πD2/8 P = πD/2 RH = D/4
Full and half full, a pipe has the same hydraulic radius

Same RHR_H, same slope, same nn, so the water in a half-full pipe moves exactly as fast as in the full one. With half the area, it carries half the flow. The Handbook writes full-pipe values with a subscript ff, so half full, v=vfv = v_f and Q=Qf/2Q = Q_f/2.

Worked Example Velocity and capacity of a concrete sewer
1 of 2

A 24-in. concrete sewer is laid on a slope of 0.25 percent, with n=0.013n = 0.013. Find its velocity and capacity flowing full.

Why the last few inches cost flow

Between half full and full, something odd happens. Fill a pipe from the middle toward the top, and both the area and the wetted perimeter keep growing, but not at the same pace. Near the middle, the walls stand nearly upright, so each extra inch of depth adds a strip of water the full width of the pipe and only an inch of wall on each side. Near the crown, the pipe narrows and its wall curves over toward flat. An extra inch there adds only a narrow strip of water, but the water has to climb a long, gently sloping stretch of wall on each side to rise that inch.

d = 0.95D last 14% of P last 2% of A
A pipe flowing at 95 percent of full depth

The numbers are lopsided. At 95 percent of full depth, the water already has 98 percent of the full area but only 86 percent of the full wetted perimeter. Closing that last 5 percent of depth adds 2 percent more water and 14 percent more wall to drag on it. RHR_H falls, the water slows, and the flow drops. So a pipe running full carries less than the same pipe running a little below full. Design still treats QfQ_f as the capacity, since the extra is small, and a pipe that close to its crown can seal and run full with the next surge.

Work out AA and RHR_H at every depth, divide each by its full-pipe value, run them through Manning's equation, and you have the Handbook's Hydraulic-Element (Partial Flow) Graph for Circular Sewers, under Hydrology/Water Resources. Each ratio compares a pipe with itself, so KK, nn, and SS cancel, and one chart serves every circular pipe.

0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1.0 1.1 1.2 1.3 0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1.0 Q/Qf,v/vf,A/Af,R/Rf d/D A/Af Q/Qf v/vf R/Rf
Hydraulic elements of a circular pipe, n constant

Adapted from the FE Reference Handbook, Hydraulic-Element (Partial Flow) Graph for Circular Sewers, constant-n curves

The Handbook's graph draws the discharge and velocity curves twice: dashed for constant nn, which matches Manning's equation and is what this Lesson uses, and solid for an nn that grows as the pipe empties. Read the solid ones only when a problem says nn varies with depth.

Checkpoint

Which of these statements about a circular sewer with constant nn are true?

A.
At 90 percent of full depth, it carries more flow than it does running full.
B.
At a quarter of its full depth, it carries about a quarter of its full flow.
C.
Its velocity is greatest when it runs completely full.
D.
Half full, it carries half its full flow at its full-pipe velocity.
E.
At 30 percent of full depth, its water moves at about 30 percent of the full-pipe velocity.

From a design flow to a depth and a velocity

A problem rarely hands you the depth. It hands you a design flow, such as the sewage a neighborhood sends at its peak hour or, for a storm sewer, the peak runoff from The Rational Method. Then it asks how deep and how fast that flow runs. The chart answers in three moves:

  1. Find QfQ_f and vfv_f for the pipe with Manning's equation.
  2. Divide the design flow by QfQ_f. Find that ratio on the bottom axis, go straight up to the Q/QfQ/Q_f curve, passing the other curves on the way, and read d/Dd/D across on the left axis.
  3. At that same d/Dd/D, go across to the v/vfv/v_f curve and read v/vfv/v_f straight down on the bottom axis. Then multiply: d=(d/D) Dd = (d/D)\,D and v=(v/vf) vfv = (v/v_f)\,v_f.

The flow is what you know, so you enter the chart through the discharge curve. Reading Q/QfQ/Q_f as if it were the depth ratio is the usual slip, and the chart shows how far off it is: a pipe carrying a quarter of its full flow runs about a third full.

Sewage flows often come in millions of gallons per day. The Handbook's Units and Conversion Factors table gives 1 ft³/sec (cfs) = 0.646317 MGD, so 1 MGD is 1/0.646317=1.5471/0.646317 = 1.547 ft³/sec.

Worked Example Depth and velocity at a design flow
1 of 3

The 24-in. sewer from the first example carries Qf=11.3Q_f = 11.3 ft³/sec at vf=3.60v_f = 3.60 ft/sec. Its design flow is 2.2 MGD. Find the depth and velocity of flow at the design flow.

Fast enough to stay clean

Sewage carries grit, sand, and organic solids, and they settle wherever the water slows down. A sewer that runs too slowly grows a bed of sediment that eats its capacity and turns septic. So sewers are laid steep enough to be self-cleansing: the water moves fast enough to scour its own floor. The Handbook prints no sewer velocity criteria, so a problem states the velocity it wants, and 2 ft/sec flowing full is the common one. Half full is the same velocity, so the criterion holds there too.

For a pipe of a given size and nn, only the slope sets the velocity, so the criterion becomes a minimum slope. Solve the velocity form of Manning's equation for SS, with RH=D/4R_H = D/4:

S=[nvKRH2/3]2S = \left[\frac{n v}{K R_H^{2/3}}\right]^2

Square the whole bracket. It's the step people drop, and without it the answer comes out more than ten times too steep.

A smaller pipe has a smaller RHR_H, so it needs a steeper slope to reach the same speed. Turn the question around, with the slope fixed by the street, and the same equation gives the smallest pipe that reaches the velocity flowing full:

D=4[nvKS1/2]3/2D = 4\left[\frac{n v}{K S^{1/2}}\right]^{3/2}
Worked Example Minimum slope for an 8-in. sewer
1 of 3

An 8-in. sewer with n=0.013n = 0.013 must reach 2.0 ft/sec flowing full. Find its minimum slope.

Inverts from manhole to manhole

A sewer runs straight from one manhole to the next, at one slope per run, so its profile is a chain of straight grades. The elevation that matters is the invert, the inside bottom of the pipe, where the water runs. It isn't the crown (the inside top), the outside of the pipe, or the manhole's rim up at the street. The Handbook doesn't cover sewer profiles, so this part you carry in your head.

drop = SL flow MH 1 MH 2 rim crown (inside top) invert (inside bottom) L (horizontal distance between stations)
A sewer run between two manholes

A sewer's slope is normally stated as a positive fall in the direction of flow, so the downstream invert is lower, by the slope times the horizontal length of the run:

Invdown=Invup−SLS=Invup−InvdownL\text{Inv}_\text{down} = \text{Inv}_\text{up} - S L \qquad S = \frac{\text{Inv}_\text{up} - \text{Inv}_\text{down}}{L}

The manholes are usually located by station, and LL is the difference of their stations in feet, not in stations.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

Manhole 4 sits at station 6+40, with its rim at 421.80 ft and the outgoing sewer's invert at 412.36 ft. The sewer runs at 0.40 percent to manhole 5 at station 9+90, whose rim is at 419.25 ft. What is the sewer's invert at manhole 5?

ft

Recap

  • A sewer is a round open channel, so Manning's equation runs it, with RH=D/4R_H = D/4 flowing full and DD in feet. Half full, the area and wetted perimeter both halve, so RHR_H is still D/4D/4, v=vfv = v_f, and Q=Qf/2Q = Q_f/2.
  • Near the crown, extra depth adds wall faster than water, so with constant nn the velocity peaks at about 81 percent depth and the flow at about 94 percent, about 8 percent above QfQ_f.
  • For a design flow, find Q/QfQ/Q_f first, read d/Dd/D off the discharge curve, then read v/vfv/v_f at that depth. 1 MGD is 1.547 ft³/sec.
  • A self-cleansing sewer usually reaches 2 ft/sec flowing full. The minimum slope is S=[nv/(KRH2/3)]2S = [nv/(K R_H^{2/3})]^2, and smaller pipes need steeper slopes.
  • The invert is the inside bottom of the pipe. It falls by SLSL between manholes, with LL in feet from the stations.