Specific Energy and Critical Flow

The same flow can run shallow and fast or deep and slow, and critical depth divides the two.

Before this Lesson

Open the kitchen tap over the flat bottom of a sink. The water lands and spreads in a thin, glassy sheet that races outward until, a few inches out, it suddenly thickens into a slower, deeper ring. The same water crosses that ring every second. It just switches from running shallow and fast to running deep and slow.

Every open channel has those two choices. Here's how the flow picks one, where the dividing line sits, and what the switch costs.

Two ways to carry the same flow

In Continuity and Bernoulli's Equation, the energy of flowing water was a sum of heights. In an open channel, measure them from the bed. A point on the bed has a pressure head equal to the depth yy. A point on the surface has none, but sits yy above the bed. Either way, pressure head plus height is yy, so the energy per pound of water is its depth plus its velocity head. The Handbook's Specific Energy section writes it as

E=αv22g+y=αQ22gA2+yE = \alpha\frac{v^2}{2g} + y = \alpha\frac{Q^2}{2gA^2} + y

where EE is the specific energy and α\alpha is a kinetic energy correction factor, usually 1.0. With α=1\alpha = 1, E=y+v2/2gE = y + v^2/2g.

Now fix the flow. In a rectangular channel, each foot of width carries the unit discharge q=Q/bq = Q/b in ft²/sec (the Handbook writes the width as BB), at v=q/yv = q/y:

E=y+q22g y2E = y + \frac{q^2}{2g\,y^2}

Deep water barely moves, so EE is about yy. Squeeze the same flow into a thin sheet and it has to race: the velocity head grows as 1/y21/y^2, and EE shoots up. Somewhere between, EE is smallest. Plotted, this is the Handbook's Specific Energy Diagram:

0 1 2 3 4 0 1 2 3 4 E (ft) y (ft) E = y q = 10 ft²/sec yc = 1.46 ft Emin = 2.19 ft E = 3.00 ft v2/2g 2.80 ft 0.85 ft subcritical: deep, slow supercritical: shallow, fast
The specific-energy curve for q = 10 ft²/sec
Every specific energy above the minimum is carried at two depths. The horizontal gap between the curve and the 45° line E=yE = y is the velocity head.

Adapted from the FE Reference Handbook, Specific Energy Diagram

At E=3.00E = 3.00 ft, the curve gives two depths. The same 10 ft²/sec can run 2.80 ft deep at 3.57 ft/sec, or 0.85 ft deep at 11.8 ft/sec, with most of its energy in a 2.15 ft velocity head. The Handbook calls these alternate depths, depths with the same specific energy. Flow on the upper branch, deep and slow, is subcritical. Flow on the lower branch, shallow and fast, is supercritical. The branches meet at the nose, the critical depth, which the Handbook defines as the depth at minimum specific energy. With less energy than that, the channel can't carry this qq at all.

Critical depth in a rectangular channel

At the nose, the slope of the curve is zero:

dEdy=1−q2g y3=0⇒yc=(q2g)1/3\frac{dE}{dy} = 1 - \frac{q^2}{g\,y^3} = 0 \quad\Rightarrow\quad y_c = \left(\frac{q^2}{g}\right)^{1/3}

That last form is the Handbook's critical depth for rectangular channels. Two more results follow that the Handbook doesn't print. Rearranged, the condition says (q/yc)2=g yc(q/y_c)^2 = g\,y_c, and q/ycq/y_c is the critical velocity:

vc=g ycvc22g=yc2Emin⁡=1.5 ycv_c = \sqrt{g\,y_c} \qquad \frac{v_c^2}{2g} = \frac{y_c}{2} \qquad E_{\min} = 1.5\,y_c

At critical depth in a rectangle, the velocity head is exactly half the depth. For the curve above, yc=1.46y_c = 1.46 ft, vc=6.85v_c = 6.85 ft/sec, and Emin⁡=2.19E_{\min} = 2.19 ft. All of this runs on qq. Put the whole channel's QQ in, and you've found the critical depth of a channel 1 ft wide carrying all of it.

Worked Example Critical flow in a rectangular channel
1 of 3

A rectangular channel 8 ft wide carries 120 ft³/sec. Find the critical depth, the critical velocity, and the minimum specific energy.

Critical depth in other shapes

For other shapes, find the minimum of E=y+Q2/(2gA2)E = y + Q^2/(2gA^2) the same way. A sliver more depth adds a strip of area as wide as the water surface, dA=T dydA = T\,dy, so:

dEdy=1−Q2 Tg A3=0⇒Q2g=A3T\frac{dE}{dy} = 1 - \frac{Q^2\,T}{g\,A^3} = 0 \quad\Rightarrow\quad \frac{Q^2}{g} = \frac{A^3}{T}

That's the Handbook's general condition for critical depth, with TT the width of the water surface. A rectangle gives back (q2/g)1/3(q^2/g)^{1/3}. A trapezoid's AA and TT won't untangle into a formula for yy, so test depths: compute A3/TA^3/T and compare it with the fixed Q2/gQ^2/g. A3/TA^3/T grows with depth, so a value that's too small means the trial is too shallow. Start with the answer options, or use the calculator's equation solver.

Dividing the condition by A2A^2 gives vc2=g A/Tv_c^2 = g\,A/T, so the velocity head at critical is half of A/TA/T, not half of yy. Only a rectangle, where A/T=yA/T = y, gets Emin⁡=1.5 ycE_{\min} = 1.5\,y_c.

Worked Example Critical depth of a trapezoidal channel by trial
1 of 2

A trapezoidal channel has a 6 ft bottom width and 2:1 side slopes, and it carries 200 ft³/sec. Find the critical depth.

The Froude number

The critical velocity, g A/T\sqrt{g\,A/T}, is also the speed of a wave. Dip a board into still water and lift it out, and a low swell runs off along the surface at c=g yhc = \sqrt{g\,y_h}, with yh=A/Ty_h = A/T: 5.7 ft/sec in water 1 ft deep. (Short ripples, like a pebble's, follow other rules.) In moving water, the swell rides the current, so a wave heading upstream gains ground at c−vc - v. If the water is slower than the wave, news of what happens downstream travels up the channel. If it's faster, every wave is swept away. The Handbook's Froude number is that ratio of speeds:

Fr=vg yh=Q2 Tg A3yh=AT\mathrm{Fr} = \frac{v}{\sqrt{g\,y_h}} = \sqrt{\frac{Q^2\,T}{g\,A^3}} \qquad y_h = \frac{A}{T}
v upstream downstream Fr = 0.5: subcritical v Fr = 1: critical v Fr = 2: supercritical
Wave fronts from a fixed disturbance in three flows
Each circle is a front sent out earlier, spreading at cc while the current carries it downstream at vv. Only when v<cv < c does any front get upstream of its source.

Fr2\mathrm{Fr}^2 is exactly the Q2T/(gA3)Q^2T/(gA^3) that equaled 1 at the nose, so critical flow is Fr=1\mathrm{Fr} = 1, water moving exactly as fast as a wave. The Handbook classifies the rest. Subcritical flow, Fr<1\mathrm{Fr} < 1, is the upper branch, where a gate or bridge downstream sends its effects upstream. Supercritical flow, Fr>1\mathrm{Fr} > 1, is the lower branch, where nothing downstream reaches upstream.

The depth in Fr\mathrm{Fr} is the hydraulic depth A/TA/T, not the hydraulic radius A/PA/P. In a rectangle, yh=yy_h = y. In a wide channel RHR_H is close to yy too, so the mistake hides until a channel is narrow and deep.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

A rectangular channel 2.0 m wide carries 5.0 m³/s at a depth of 1.0 m. How would you classify the flow?

A.
Supercritical, with Fr = 1.13
B.
Subcritical, with Fr = 0.80
C.
Subcritical, with Fr = 0.64
D.
Subcritical, with Fr = 0.25

Raised floors and narrow spots

Take the subcritical flow from before, q=10q = 10 ft²/sec at 2.80 ft deep and E=3.00E = 3.00 ft, and let the floor rise smoothly by 0.50 ft. Friction takes almost nothing over the short rise, so the energy line stays level. But EE is measured from the floor, so over the step it's 2.50 ft. With qq unchanged, the flow stays on the same curve and the same branch, since switching would mean passing through the nose. The upper branch at 2.50 ft gives a depth of 2.17 ft. The depth fell 0.63 ft, more than the floor rose, so the surface over the step is 0.13 ft lower. Raise the floor, and the surface drops.

energy line flow E1 = 3.00 ft y1 = 2.80 ft y2 = 2.17 ft E2 = 2.50 ft Δz = 0.50 ft 0.13 ft 0 1 2 3 4 0 1 2 3 4 E (ft) y (ft) E = y 2.80 2.17 Δz = 0.50 ft q = 10 ft²/sec 1 2
Subcritical flow over a raised floor
Left, the profile: the energy line stays level, so the specific energy over the step is 0.50 ft less. Right, the same change on the curve: 0.50 ft to the left along the upper branch drops the depth from 2.80 ft to 2.17 ft.

On the upper branch, the curve climbs more steeply than the 45° line, so any move to the left drops the depth by more than the move. That's why a slow river's surface dips over a submerged boulder. The step can take away at most 3.00−2.19=0.813.00 - 2.19 = 0.81 ft, the slack above Emin⁡E_{\min}. At that height the flow over it is critical, and any higher, the flow chokes: it backs up, deepening upstream until it has the energy to get over.

Narrowing a rectangular channel, with the floor unchanged, keeps EE but raises q=Q/bq = Q/b, which moves the whole curve to the right and raises Emin⁡E_{\min}. Like the raised floor, it shrinks the slack between the energy the flow has and the least it needs, so the depth moves toward critical.

Checkpoint
1 of 3
E y A B C
A specific-energy curve with three marked points

On this curve for one discharge, points A and C have the same specific energy, and B is at the nose. Which statements are true?

A.
Flow at A is subcritical.
B.
Flow at C moves faster than flow at A.
C.
B is the depth at which this discharge carries the most energy.
D.
Flow at B has a Froude number of 1.
E.
A and C have the same velocity head.

The hydraulic jump

Supercritical flow pours off spillways and out under sluice gates, usually into a river that's deep and slow. No wave can travel up the fast flow to warn it, so it slams into the deep water and switches branches all at once, in a hydraulic jump: the surface leaps up under a churning roller of white water. That's the ring in your sink.

The roller turns much of the energy into heat, so specific energy can't find the new depth. Momentum can. Over the jump's short length, the only horizontal forces are the water pressures on its two ends, and the deeper end's larger push is what slows the flow. Balancing them in a rectangular channel gives the Handbook's Hydraulic Jump equation:

y2=y12(−1+1+8 Fr12)y_2 = \frac{y_1}{2}\left(-1 + \sqrt{1 + 8\,\mathrm{Fr}_1^2}\right)

with y1y_1 and Fr1\mathrm{Fr}_1 on the upstream, supercritical side and y2y_2 on the downstream, subcritical side. The Handbook calls such a pair sequent (or conjugate) depths, depths with the same momentum. At Fr1=1\mathrm{Fr}_1 = 1, y2=y1y_2 = y_1: there's nothing to jump. The Handbook prints no formula for the energy lost, so find it as ΔE=E1−E2\Delta E = E_1 - E_2, with v2=q/y2v_2 = q/y_2.

roller energy line ΔE v1 v2 supercritical subcritical y1 y2 E y ΔE jump 1 2
A hydraulic jump below a sluice gate, in profile and on the curve
The jump leaps from the lower branch to the upper one at the same qq, landing ΔE\Delta E to the left of where it started.

A jump only goes from supercritical to subcritical. Run backward, a slow flow would leap down into a fast one and gain energy from nowhere.

Worked Example A jump below a sluice gate
1 of 2

Water leaves a sluice gate in a rectangular channel 0.60 ft deep at 20 ft/sec and forms a hydraulic jump. Find the depth after the jump and the energy lost in it.

Running a jump backward

A stilling basin turns the question around: the river downstream sets the tailwater depth y2y_2, and you need the supercritical depth y1y_1 that jumps to it. The momentum balance behind the Handbook's equation is

q2g=y1 y2 (y1+y2)2\frac{q^2}{g} = \frac{y_1\,y_2\,(y_1 + y_2)}{2}

and swapping y1y_1 and y2y_2 leaves it unchanged. So the Handbook's forward equation works in reverse with the subscripts swapped, using Fr2=v2/g y2\mathrm{Fr}_2 = v_2/\sqrt{g\,y_2}:

y1=y22(−1+1+8 Fr22)y_1 = \frac{y_2}{2}\left(-1 + \sqrt{1 + 8\,\mathrm{Fr}_2^2}\right)
Checkpoint

A stilling basin carries a unit discharge of 40 ft²/sec, and the tailwater downstream stands 8.0 ft deep. What depth must the incoming supercritical flow have for a jump to form against that tailwater?

ft

Recap

  • Each specific energy E=y+v2/2gE = y + v^2/2g above the minimum has two alternate depths: deep and slow, or shallow and fast.
  • Critical depth has the least EE. A rectangle has yc=(q2/g)1/3y_c = (q^2/g)^{1/3} and Emin⁡=1.5 ycE_{\min} = 1.5\,y_c; other shapes, trial depths in Q2/g=A3/TQ^2/g = A^3/T.
  • Fr=v/g A/T\mathrm{Fr} = v/\sqrt{g\,A/T} compares the flow with a surface wave: below 1, subcritical; above 1, supercritical.
  • A raised floor or a narrowing moves the depth toward critical, so a subcritical surface drops over a step.
  • A jump goes only from supercritical to subcritical. Its equation runs backward with subscripts swapped, and it loses E1−E2E_1 - E_2.