Power and Efficiency

Power is how fast work gets done, and every drive loses some on the way.

Walk up a flight of stairs, then sprint up it. Same body, same height, so you did the same work both times. Only one of them leaves you gasping.

Hoists split the same way. A 2 hp hoist and a 10 hp hoist will each lift a ton of steel 33 ft. One takes a minute, and the other takes 12 seconds. That difference is what you're paying for when you buy a motor, and it's one line of arithmetic away.

Work per unit time

What separates the two hoists is the rate at which they do the work, and that rate is power. The Handbook's Power and Efficiency entry, in its Dynamics chapter, defines it from the work UU of Work and Energy:

P=dUdtP = \frac{dU}{dt}

A ton through 33 ft is 2,000(33)=66,000 ft-lb2{,}000(33) = 66{,}000\ \text{ft-lb}, whichever hoist does it. Graph work against time, and both lines end at the same height. Power is the slope.

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 0 20,000 40,000 60,000 80,000 time, t (s) work done, U (ft-lb) 66,000 ft-lb 10 hp: done at 12 s 2 hp: done at 60 s slope = power
The same work done at two rates

In SI, power comes out in joules per second, which is the watt: 1 W=1 N⋅m/s1\ \text{W} = 1\ \text{N}\cdot\text{m/s}. That W is a unit. The WW in an equation is still a weight. In U.S. units, power comes out in ft-lb/s, which the Handbook's Units and Conversion Factors table writes as (ft-lbf)/sec and converts to horsepower:

1 hp=550 ft-lb/s=745.7 W≈0.746 kW1\ \text{hp} = 550\ \text{ft-lb/s} = 745.7\ \text{W} \approx 0.746\ \text{kW}

There's no physics in the 550. It's James Watt's estimate of what a working horse could keep up, chosen to sell steam engines to people who owned horses. The table also prints 33,000 ft-lb/min, which is the same horse, per minute. So the 2 hp hoist delivers 1,100 ft-lb/s and needs 60 s for the lift, and the 10 hp hoist delivers 5,500 ft-lb/s and needs 12 s.

Often a problem gives you a whole job and the time it took. Then only the start and the finish matter. The energy the body gained, divided by the time, is the average power:

Pavg=ΔEtP_{\text{avg}} = \frac{\Delta E}{t}

Here ΔE\Delta E is 12mv2\tfrac12 mv^2 for a body brought from rest up to speed, WhWh for one raised a height hh, and the sum if it does both. It's the slope of a straight line from start to finish, whatever the power did along the way. The Handbook prints only the rate, dU/dtdU/dt, so this form is yours to build.

Worked Example A car brought up to speed
1 of 3

A 3,220 lb car accelerates from rest to 60 mph in 10 s on a level road. Find the average power that goes into its speed, in hp.

Force times speed

A motor's job usually comes with a load and a speed, not a distance and a time. So get those into the formula. Over a tiny time dtdt, a force FF moving with a body does work F dxF\,dx. Divide by dtdt, and dx/dtdx/dt is the speed:

P=dUdt=Fdxdt=FvP = \frac{dU}{dt} = F\frac{dx}{dt} = Fv

That's the Handbook's P=F⋅vP = \mathbf{F}\cdot\mathbf{v}. The dot keeps only the part of the force along the motion, the same Fcos⁡θF\cos\theta you used for work. The picture is simple. Each second, the force moves through a distance vv, so it does FvFv of work every second.

at time t 1 s later v × 1 s F v
Each second, the force moves through a distance v

This clears up something that seems odd. A column can hold 500 kips for a century and use no power at all, because its speed is zero. Force costs nothing by itself. Power takes force and motion together.

The 10 hp hoist took its ton up 33 ft in 12 s, which is 2.75 ft/s. If that speed is steady, the load isn't accelerating, so the cable pulls with exactly the weight and not a pound more. There's no mama term to add:

P=2,000(2.75)=5,500 ft-lb/s=10 hpP = 2{,}000(2.75) = 5{,}500\ \text{ft-lb/s} = 10\ \text{hp}

That's the same 10 hp. Now look at the units. The 550 is ft-lb per second, so the speed has to be in ft/s. Hoist speeds often come in ft/min (divide by 60), and vehicle speeds in mph (multiply by 1.467). In SI, newtons times m/s gives watts, not kilowatts, and a mass has to become a weight first, W=mgW = mg.

Every drive takes its cut

Run that hoist off a real motor, and 10 hp at the load takes more than 10 hp going in. Bearings warm up, gear teeth rub, windings get hot. Power goes in one end, and less comes out the other. The ratio is the efficiency:

η=PoutPin⇒Pin=Poutη\eta = \frac{P_{\text{out}}}{P_{\text{in}}} \quad\Rightarrow\quad P_{\text{in}} = \frac{P_{\text{out}}}{\eta}

The Handbook's Power and Efficiency entry writes this with ε\varepsilon. Its motor and pump sections use η\eta, and so does this Lesson.

Efficiency only ever loses, so the input is always the larger of the two, and that gives you a check every time. Working back from the load to the motor, you divide. If your input comes out smaller than your output, you multiplied, and you've invented a machine that makes power out of nothing.

A drive often has stages, such as a motor feeding a gearbox feeding a drum. Each stage passes on a fraction of what it receives, so the fractions multiply. The Handbook says this only for a pump and its motor, ηt=ηpump×ηmotor\eta_t = \eta_{\text{pump}} \times \eta_{\text{motor}}, but the reasoning fits any chain.

Motor η = 0.90 Gearbox η = 0.80 Pin = 10 hp 9 hp Pout = 7.2 hp lost: 1 hp lost: 1.8 hp overall η = 0.90 × 0.80 = 0.72
Each stage passes on a fraction of what it receives
A 0.90 motor and a 0.80 gearbox turn 10 hp in into 7.2 hp out, for an overall η\eta of 0.72.
Worked Example Sizing a hoist motor
1 of 3

A hoist lifts a 4,400 lb load at a steady 45 ft/min through a drive that's 80% efficient. Find the input power, in hp and in kW.

A slope is a slow hoist

A vehicle at a steady speed works like the hoist: no acceleration, so the drive force just matches whatever it's pushing against. On a level road, that's the resisting force RR, the rolling resistance and air drag. Real drag grows with speed, but a problem hands you one number. Uphill, the weight's component along the slope joins in:

F=R+Wsin⁡θP=FvF = R + W\sin\theta \qquad\qquad P = Fv
θ θ W W cos θ W sin θ N F R v
A truck climbing a slope at a steady speed

NN and Wcos⁡θW\cos\theta are square to the motion, so they take no power. Now look at gravity's share: (Wsin⁡θ)v=W(vsin⁡θ)(W\sin\theta)v = W(v\sin\theta), the weight times the rate of climb. So a truck on a hill is a hoist, lifting itself slowly up a long ramp, and an inclined conveyor is the same thing.

Slopes often come as a percent grade. A 5% grade rises 5 ft per 100 ft of horizontal run, so tan⁡θ=0.05\tan\theta = 0.05. On slopes that gentle, sin⁡θ\sin\theta and tan⁡θ\tan\theta agree to about a tenth of a percent, so Wsin⁡θ≈0.05WW\sin\theta \approx 0.05W. The Handbook defines grade in its Transportation section but has nothing on vehicle power, so you build this from P=FvP = Fv yourself.

Turn that around, and a fixed power sets the greatest speed it can hold against a given force:

vmax=PFv_{\text{max}} = \frac{P}{F}

Take a 40,000 lb truck with 160 hp at its wheels, which is 88,000 ft-lb/s, against 1,000 lb of resistance. On the level, it can hold 88 ft/s, or 60 mph. A 2.5% grade adds another 1,000 lb, the force doubles, and the speed halves to 30 mph. That's the truck crawling up the right lane.

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 0 40 80 120 160 200 240 speed, v (mph) power, P (hp) 30 mph 60 mph level: F = 1,000 lb 2.5% grade: F = 2,000 lb power available: 160 hp
The greatest speed is where the power needed meets the power available
Worked Example A car on a grade
1 of 4

A 4,000 lb car climbs a 5% grade at a steady 45 mph against a 150 lb resisting force. Find the power needed at the wheels, in hp.

Power through a shaft

A motor doesn't pull on anything in a straight line. It turns a shaft. So put a force FF on the rim of a drum at radius rr. The rim moves at v=rωv = r\omega, so:

P=Fv=F(rω)=(Fr)ω=TωP = Fv = F(r\omega) = (Fr)\omega = T\omega

FrFr is the torque TT, the moment about the axis. So TT picks up yet another job: it was a tension in Newton's Second Law and a kinetic energy in Work and Energy, and here it's a torque.

r ω T = Fr F v = rω
A force on the rim of a turning drum

The Handbook's Dynamics chapter stops at P=F⋅vP = \mathbf{F}\cdot\mathbf{v}. You'll find the turning form in the Rotating Machines section of its Electrical and Computer Engineering chapter, as P=TωmP = T\omega_m, with ωm=(2π/60)n\omega_m = (2\pi/60)n for a speed nn in rpm. It's printed in SI, but ft-lb times rad/s gives ft-lb/s just the same, since the radian drops out.

At a fixed power, T=P/ωT = P/\omega, so torque and speed trade against each other the way force and speed do. Find the torque and stop there. What it does to the steel is the business of Torsion of Circular Shafts.

Worked Example Torque from a nameplate
1 of 4

A motor delivers 25 hp at 1,750 rpm. Find its torque.

Recap

  • Power is the rate of doing work: P=dU/dt=FvP = dU/dt = Fv, counting only the force along the motion. Average power is the energy change divided by the time.
  • 1 hp=550 ft-lb/s=0.746 kW1\ \text{hp} = 550\ \text{ft-lb/s} = 0.746\ \text{kW}. The 550 needs a speed in ft/s, and newtons times m/s gives watts, not kilowatts.
  • At a steady speed there's no mama term. The force is the load's weight on a hoist, and R+Wsin⁡θR + W\sin\theta on a slope. The greatest speed a power can hold is v=P/Fv = P/F.
  • η=Pout/Pin\eta = P_{\text{out}}/P_{\text{in}}, so the input is the output divided by the efficiency, never multiplied. Efficiencies in series multiply.
  • For anything turning, P=TωP = T\omega, with ω\omega in rad/s. At a fixed power, less speed means more torque.