Forces from Jets on Plates and Vanes

To turn a jet, a vane has to push on it, and the jet pushes back just as hard.

A fire hose throws 0.6 ft³ of water each second at 86 ft/s, about 270 gallons a minute. Aim it square at a wall, and the wall takes a steady push of about 100 lb. Yet the water doesn't bounce back at the hose. It splashes off sideways along the wall.

So what is doing the pushing? And why would a curved bucket that turns the stream right back toward the nozzle take twice the push?

Momentum per second is a force

Impulse and Momentum said that changing a body's momentum takes an impulse, ΣF Δt=m(v−v0)\Sigma F\,\Delta t = m(v - v_0). A stream works the same way, one second at a time. Each second, 0.6 ft³ of water reaches the wall: at 1.94 slug/ft³, that's 1.164 slugs moving toward it at 86 ft/s. Each second, the same water slides off along the wall with no speed toward it at all. So the wall takes away 1.164(86)=100 lb⋅s1.164(86) = 100\ \text{lb}\cdot\text{s} of momentum every second, and an impulse of 100 lb·s every second is a steady 100 lb force. The wall pushes the water back that hard, and the water pushes the wall just as hard.

In general, watch the water on a plate or vane for a short time Δt\Delta t. A parcel of mass ρQ Δt\rho Q\,\Delta t flows in at v1v_1, and an equal parcel flows out at v2v_2, while the steady flow between them stays as it was. So the momentum changes by ρQ Δt (v2−v1)\rho Q\,\Delta t\,(v_2 - v_1), and the impulse is ΣF Δt\Sigma F\,\Delta t. Cancel Δt\Delta t:

ΣF=ρQ (v2−v1)\Sigma F = \rho Q\,(v_2 - v_1)

ρQ\rho Q is the mass flow rate from Continuity and Bernoulli's Equation, so a stream carries momentum at the rate ρQv\rho Qv, and the force on it is the momentum flowing out each second minus the momentum flowing in. The Handbook's Impulse-Momentum Principle writes it as:

ΣF=ΣQ2ρ2v2−ΣQ1ρ1v1\Sigma \mathbf{F} = \Sigma Q_2\rho_2 v_2 - \Sigma Q_1\rho_1 v_1

The sums cover a stream that splits, and the Handbook applies it "in a given direction." Velocity is a vector, so you write the equation once per direction, with each velocity's component in that direction.

Here ρ\rho is the mass density, 1.94 slug/ft³ or 1,000 kg/m³, and the force comes out in lb or N. The Handbook's water table prints the first as 1.940 lbf-sec²/ft⁴, which is the same unit. Use γ=62.4\gamma = 62.4 lb/ft³ by mistake, and the hose's push becomes 3,220 lb, 32.2 times too big.

The control volume around a free jet

The water you watch sits inside a control volume: a boundary around the water on the plate or vane, cutting square across the jet where it enters and where it leaves. ΣF\Sigma F is every outside force on that water, and for a free jet, a jet in open air, the list is short. Air surrounds the jet, so its gauge pressure is zero everywhere, and there are no pressure forces. The water on a vane at any instant weighs little, and problems ignore it. That leaves the plate or vane, so its push on the water, FF, is the whole ΣF\Sigma F.

The speed doesn't change, either. With no friction, atmospheric pressure throughout, and almost no change in height, Bernoulli leaves the velocity head as it was. The water leaves as fast as it arrived, so all a plate or vane can change is its direction.

The steps go the same way every time, and Forces on Pipe Bends and Nozzles keeps them:

  1. Draw the control volume, cutting square across each stream.
  2. Point x along the incoming flow, with y square to it.
  3. Find the force on the water in each direction from F=ρQ(v2−v1)F = \rho Q(v_2 - v_1).
  4. Reverse it for the force on the plate or vane.

Plates and cups

At a plate square to the jet, the water leaves along the plate, so v2=0v_2 = 0 along x:

Fx=ρQ(0−v)=−ρQvF_x = \rho Q(0 - v) = -\rho Qv

The minus sign says the plate pushes the water back toward the nozzle, so the water pushes the plate ρQv\rho Qv away from it. For the hose, that's the 100 lb. The water fans out evenly on every side, so its sideways momenta cancel.

Now the bucket. A cup carries the water around its curve and sends it back toward the nozzle at full speed, so v2=−vv_2 = -v:

Fx=ρQ(−v−v)=−2ρQvF_x = \rho Q(-v - v) = -2\rho Qv

Twice the plate. The plate only stops the water's motion toward it. The cup stops it and then sends it back just as fast, a second job of the same size, like the rubber ball bouncing off a wall, kept up without a break. Don't let the same speed coming back fool you into calling the change zero. A 180° turn changes the velocity by 2v2v.

flat plate cup v Q x v Q/2 v Q/2 ρQv force on water v Q x v Q/2 v Q/2 2ρQv force on water
A plate stops the jet, and a cup sends it back

Now tilt the plate so it meets the jet at an angle θ\theta. A frictionless plate can't grip the water. It can only push square to its own face, so here it pays to trade x for the plate's normal, nn. The jet arrives with a velocity component vsin⁡θv\sin\theta into the plate, and both streams leave sliding along the plate, with no component along nn at all. So the plate's push on the water, out from its face, is:

Fn=ρQvsin⁡θF_n = \rho Qv\sin\theta

At θ=90∘\theta = 90^\circ, it's the square-on plate again. The Handbook has no case for a flat plate or a cup. Both come straight from the Impulse-Momentum Principle, as here.

θ n v v Q v v sin θ v cos θ Fn
A frictionless plate pushes only along its normal
Worked Example A jet square onto a plate
1 of 3

A 50 mm nozzle shoots a horizontal water jet at 20 m/s square onto a fixed flat plate. Find the force the jet exerts on the plate.

A vane turns the jet through any angle

Between the plate and the cup lies every other turn. A fixed curved vane takes the jet in along x and sends it out at an angle α\alpha, measured from the direction the jet was moving. The speed stays vv, so the outgoing velocity has components vcos⁡αv\cos\alpha along x and vsin⁡αv\sin\alpha along y, with y pointing toward the side the jet turns. Write the momentum equation once per direction for the force on the water:

Fx=ρQ(vcos⁡α−v)=−ρQv(1−cos⁡α)Fy=ρQ(vsin⁡α−0)=ρQvsin⁡α\begin{aligned} F_x &= \rho Q(v\cos\alpha - v) = -\rho Qv(1 - \cos\alpha) \\[4pt] F_y &= \rho Q(v\sin\alpha - 0) = \rho Qv\sin\alpha \end{aligned}

Reverse both for the vane. The water pushes it ρQv(1−cos⁡α)\rho Qv(1 - \cos\alpha) along the incoming jet's direction and ρQvsin⁡α\rho Qv\sin\alpha away from the side the jet turns toward.

The velocity triangle shows why. Put v1v_1 and v2v_2 tail to tail, and the change, Δv=v2−v1\Delta v = v_2 - v_1, runs from the tip of one to the tip of the other. The force on the water is ρQ Δv\rho Q\,\Delta v, so it points the way the velocity changed: back along the jet and toward the turn. The vane takes the opposite push.

the vane velocity triangle v1 v2 α x y force on vane v(1 − cos α) v sin α v1 v2 α Δv force on water points along Δv
The force on the water points the way its velocity changed

The Handbook's Deflectors and Blades section prints this as its Fixed Blade case:

−Fx=Qρ(v2cos⁡α−v1)Fy=Qρ(v2sin⁡α−0)-F_x = Q\rho(v_2\cos\alpha - v_1) \qquad F_y = Q\rho(v_2\sin\alpha - 0)

Its FF is the blade's push on the water too, but its sketch draws FxF_x pointing upstream, which is why the equation starts with −Fx-F_x. Either way, the size is ρQv(1−cos⁡α)\rho Qv(1 - \cos\alpha).

How the turn sets the force on the vane
Turn, αAlong the jetAcross the jet
0°00
60°0.5 ρQv0.87 ρQv
90°ρQvρQv
120°1.5 ρQv0.87 ρQv
180° (cup)2 ρQv0

The push along the jet keeps growing all the way to a full reversal, while the push across it peaks at 90°. Measure α\alpha from the incoming direction. If a figure marks the outgoing jet's angle from some other line, find α\alpha first, or the sines, cosines, and signs come out wrong.

Worked Example A vane that turns a jet through 60°
1 of 3

A horizontal water jet carries 0.4 ft³/s at 80 ft/s onto a fixed vane that turns it through 60° in a horizontal plane. Ignoring friction, find the x and y components of the force the water exerts on the vane.

Judging the reaction by inspection

Plenty of exam questions skip the arithmetic and ask what happens, and the rules above answer most of them. One more is worth a thought: what does a faster jet do? ρQv\rho Qv holds the velocity twice, once in plain sight and once inside Q=AvQ = Av. Which of the two changes depends on what the problem holds fixed.

Checkpoint
1 of 3

The fixed vane shown turns a jet moving to the right so it leaves heading down and to the left. Which way does the water push the vane?

v v 45°
A vane that turns the jet down and back
A.
Down and to the left
B.
Down and to the right
C.
Up and to the right
D.
Up and to the left

Recap

  • A stream carries momentum at the rate ρQv\rho Qv, so ΣF=ρQ(v2−v1)\Sigma F = \rho Q(v_2 - v_1) on the water, once per direction, with ρ\rho the mass density.
  • A free jet has no pressure force and keeps its speed, so the plate or vane's push is the only force on the water. Point x along the incoming flow, find that force, then reverse it for the plate or vane.
  • A square-on plate takes ρQv\rho Qv, a cup 2ρQv2\rho Qv, and a plate tilted at θ\theta takes ρQvsin⁡θ\rho Qv\sin\theta along its normal.
  • A vane turning the jet through α\alpha is pushed ρQv(1−cos⁡α)\rho Qv(1 - \cos\alpha) downstream and ρQvsin⁡α\rho Qv\sin\alpha away from the turn.
  • Through one nozzle, ρQv=ρAv2\rho Qv = \rho Av^2, so twice the jet speed means four times every one of these forces.