Bending Stress

A bent beam is squeezed on one face and stretched on the other, and its middle feels nothing.

Take a kitchen sponge, draw a few straight lines down its long side from top to bottom, and bend it into a smile. The lines stay straight. They only tilt, crowding together along the top edge and spreading apart along the bottom, and somewhere between is a level where their spacing doesn't change at all. A steel beam does the same thing, just too slightly to see. That one picture tells you where a beam's stress is, how big it gets, and why depth is worth so much more than width.

The lines stay straight

Cut a short slice out of a beam carrying a positive moment. Its two faces started out parallel. Bending tilts them toward each other at the top, but each face stays flat, like the lines on the sponge. That's the one assumption behind this whole Lesson: plane sections stay plane.

Before After M M shortens lengthens keeps its length: neutral axis
A slice of beam before and after bending

Now look at the fibers running between the two faces. The ones along the top got shorter, the ones along the bottom got longer, and one level kept its length. That level is the neutral axis. Because the faces are flat, the change in length grows in a straight line as you move away from the axis: twice as far, twice the change. Every fiber started out the same length, so the strain grows in a straight line too.

Stress is strain times EE, so it follows the same straight line: zero at the neutral axis, and largest at the fibers farthest from it, the extreme fibers, a distance cc from the axis. Call the distance to any fiber yy, and the stress is some constant times that distance, σ=ky\sigma = ky. That leaves two questions: where is the axis, and what is kk?

Cross section Strain Stress y c shortening lengthening ε × E compression tension σ σmax σmax neutral axis
Strain and stress over the depth of a beam under positive moment

The neutral axis runs through the centroid

Statics locates the axis. A section in bending carries a moment but no net axial force, so all the push above the axis has to cancel all the pull below it. A patch of area dAdA carries a force σ dA\sigma\,dA, so:

∫σ dA=k∫y dA=0\int \sigma\,dA = k\int y\,dA = 0

That integral is the first moment of the area about the axis, and among horizontal lines, it's zero about only one: the one through the centroid. So the neutral axis runs through the centroid of the cross section. For a rectangle or a W-shape, that's mid-depth. The Handbook uses the neutral axis without saying where it is, so this is yours to carry in.

The flexure formula

The push and the pull form a couple, and that couple is the internal moment MM.

neutral axis σ dA compression tension y M
The stresses on a cut face add up to the moment

A patch at distance yy pushes with a force of ky dAky\,dA on a lever arm of yy, so its moment about the axis is ky2 dAky^2\,dA. Add up every patch:

M=k∫y2 dA=kIM = k\int y^2\,dA = kI

Distance counts twice, once in how hard the patch pushes and once in its arm. So material near the axis barely contributes, and material far out does most of the work, which is why II from Moment of Inertia of Areas shows up here. Now k=M/Ik = M/I, and the stress at any fiber is:

σ=MyI\sigma = \frac{My}{I}

The Handbook prints this under Stresses in Beams as σx=−My/I\sigma_x = -My/I, with yy the distance from the neutral axis to the fiber. The largest stress is at the extreme fiber, a distance cc from the axis:

σmax=McI\sigma_{\text{max}} = \frac{Mc}{I}

The minus sign keeps tension positive: count yy upward, and under a positive moment, a fiber above the axis gets a negative stress, which is compression. You can skip the sign. Find the size from the formula and read the direction off the bend. In the Handbook's sign convention, from Internal Shear and Moment in Beams, a positive moment is a smile, and a negative moment is a frown.

Checkpoint

Which statements about bending stress over a beam's depth are true?

A.
A fiber twice as far from the neutral axis carries four times the stress.
B.
The stress varies linearly with distance from the neutral axis.
C.
Under a negative moment, the bottom fibers are in tension.
D.
The stress is zero at the neutral axis.
E.
The stress is greatest at the extreme fibers.
F.
Under a positive moment, the top fibers are in compression.

The largest stress in a rectangular beam

A typical question has a statics half and a materials half. Statics finds the largest moment, and the flexure formula turns it into stress.

For a rectangle, the Handbook's area table gives I=bh3/12I = bh^3/12, and cc is half the depth, h/2h/2. Watch the units on the way in. The moment usually comes in kip⋅ft\text{kip}\cdot\text{ft} and the section in inches, so multiply by 12 before they meet. In SI, use N⋅mm\text{N}\cdot\text{mm} and mm, and the stress comes out in MPa, since 1 MPa is 1 N/mm².

Worked Example A timber beam under a uniform load
1 of 3

Find the maximum bending stress.

0.5 kip/ft 12 ft 4 in. 12 in.
A simply supported timber beam and its section

One number for the whole section

The largest stress depends on the section only through the ratio I/cI/c, so that ratio gets a name, the section modulus:

S=Icσmax=MSS = \frac{I}{c} \qquad \sigma_{\text{max}} = \frac{M}{S}

The Handbook prints both under Stresses in Beams, with a lowercase ss, as the elastic section modulus. It doesn't print the rectangle's value, but that's one line away:

S=bh3/12h/2=bh26S = \frac{bh^3/12}{h/2} = \frac{bh^2}{6}

For a steel shape, you look it up. The Handbook's Table 1-1: W Shapes Dimensions and Properties, in its Civil Engineering chapter, lists it for each shape. A name such as W18X50 means about 18 in. deep and 50 lb/ft.

Five W-shapes, with the columns this Lesson needs
Shapedd (in.)tft_f (in.)IxI_x (in⁴)SxS_x (in³)
W24X6823.70.5851830154
W21X4420.70.45084381.6
W18X5018.00.57080088.9
W16X3615.90.43044856.5
W12X4011.90.51530751.5

Adapted from the FE Reference Handbook, Table 1-1: W Shapes Dimensions and Properties

Check a row. The W18X50 has c=18.0/2=9.0c = 18.0/2 = 9.0 in., so I/c=800/9.0=88.9 in3I/c = 800/9.0 = 88.9\ \text{in}^3, the printed value. The full table prints IxI_x and SxS_x as plain II and SS under Axis X-X, the strong axis, which is how a W-shape normally works, with its web vertical. Its Axis Y-Y columns are for the weak axis and hold no SS, so don't reach for them. It also prints a ZZ beside the SS, the plastic section modulus, which waits for Steel Beam Flexural Strength.

Checkpoint

A W21X44 carries a moment of 150 kip⋅ft\text{kip}\cdot\text{ft} about its strong axis. What is the maximum bending stress?

ksi

Working back from an allowable stress

A design question runs the formula backward. It states an allowable bending stress, since the Handbook lists none for timber or steel beams, and the largest stress can't exceed it. That limit answers three different questions:

  • Required section modulus: Sreq=M/σallowS_{\text{req}} = M/\sigma_{\text{allow}}.
  • Minimum depth of a rectangle: set bh2/6bh^2/6 equal to SreqS_{\text{req}} and solve for hh.
  • Largest load: find Mallow=σallowSM_{\text{allow}} = \sigma_{\text{allow}}S, then run the moment formula backward for the load.
Worked Example The minimum depth of a timber beam
1 of 4

A timber beam 6 in. wide spans 14 ft, simply supported, under 1 kip/ft. The allowable bending stress is 1.5 ksi. Find the required section modulus and the minimum depth.

A fiber that isn't at the face

σ=My/I\sigma = My/I works at any level, as long as yy is measured from the neutral axis and not from a face. A favorite level is where the web meets the flange. Put 200 kip⋅ft\text{kip}\cdot\text{ft}, or 2,400 kip⋅in\text{kip}\cdot\text{in}, on a W18X50. The face is c=9.0c = 9.0 in. from the axis, and the flange is 0.57 in. thick, so the junction is y=9.0−0.57=8.43y = 9.0 - 0.57 = 8.43 in. from the axis:

σ=MyI=2,400(8.43)800=25.3 ksi\sigma = \frac{My}{I} = \frac{2{,}400(8.43)}{800} = 25.3\ \text{ksi}
W18X50 d tf y c NA 27.0 ksi 25.3 ksi compression tension d = 18.0 in. tf = 0.57 in. c = 9.0 in. y = 8.43 in.
A W18X50: the junction sits almost as high as the face

The face works at 27.0 ksi, so the whole flange runs close to full stress, which is what a flange is for. Plug in the 0.57 in. itself and you'd get 1.71 ksi, the stress at a fiber that close to the axis, not to the top.

Checkpoint
1 of 2
10 in. 1 in. 16 in. 1 in. 1/2 in. NA web-flange junction I = 1,620 in4
A built-up I-section

This section carries a moment of 300 kip⋅ft\text{kip}\cdot\text{ft}. What is the bending stress at the web-flange junction?

ksi

Two faces, two distances

A T-section has a wide flange at one end and only a narrow stem at the other, and that pulls the centroid, and the neutral axis with it, toward the flange. Now the two faces sit at different distances from the axis. The Handbook defines cc only for a symmetrical section, so go back to σ=My/I\sigma = My/I and give each face its own yy.

Those distances fix the sizes: the farther face always has the larger stress. The sign of the moment fixes the directions: which face is in tension.

Worked Example The largest stresses in a T-section
1 of 3

This T-section, from Moment of Inertia of Areas, carries a positive moment of 50 kip⋅ft\text{kip}\cdot\text{ft}. Find the largest tensile and compressive stresses.

7 in. NA 12 in. 2 in. 2 in. 8 in. I = 333 in4
A T-section with its neutral axis

Why depth beats width

In S=bh2/6S = bh^2/6, width counts once and depth counts twice. Here hh is the side perpendicular to the neutral axis, whichever way the page is turned. Take the 10 in. by 2 in. plank from Moment of Inertia of Areas, flat and then on edge:

Sflat=(10)(2)26=6.67 in3Sedge=(2)(10)26=33.3 in3S_{\text{flat}} = \frac{(10)(2)^2}{6} = 6.67\ \text{in}^3 \qquad S_{\text{edge}} = \frac{(2)(10)^2}{6} = 33.3\ \text{in}^3

Under the same moment, turning the plank on edge cuts the stress to a fifth, and five is the long side over the short side. That Lesson showed II growing 25 times, so why not 25 here? Because cc also grew five times. On edge, the plank curves a twenty-fifth as much, but its extreme fibers sit five times farther out, and for any given curve, farther fibers stretch more. So they stretch a fifth as much, not a twenty-fifth. The plank sags a twenty-fifth as far, but it's only five times as strong.

Flat 10 in. 2 in. NA σ compression tension I = 6.67 in4 c = 1 in. S = 6.67 in3 On edge 2 in. 10 in. NA σ/5 compression tension I = 166.7 in4 c = 5 in. S = 33.3 in3
One plank under one moment, flat and on edge

So a question about changing a rectangle needs no numbers. For the same moment, the stress goes as 1/(bh2)1/(bh^2).

Checkpoint
1 of 3

A rectangular beam's depth doubles, with the same width and the same moment. What happens to its maximum bending stress?

A.
It falls to one-half.
B.
It falls to one-eighth.
C.
It falls to one-fourth.
D.
It stays the same.

Recap

  • Plane sections stay plane, so strain and stress vary linearly with distance from the neutral axis, which runs through the centroid. The stress is zero at the axis and greatest at the extreme fibers.
  • σ=My/I\sigma = My/I at any fiber, with yy measured from the neutral axis, and σmax=Mc/I=M/S\sigma_{\text{max}} = Mc/I = M/S at the extreme fiber. Convert kip⋅ft\text{kip}\cdot\text{ft} to kip⋅in\text{kip}\cdot\text{in} first, and use c=h/2c = h/2 for a rectangle.
  • S=I/cS = I/c is bh2/6bh^2/6 for a rectangle, and it's in Table 1-1 for a W-shape. For an allowable stress, Sreq=M/σallowS_{\text{req}} = M/\sigma_{\text{allow}} and Mallow=σallowSM_{\text{allow}} = \sigma_{\text{allow}}S.
  • A positive moment compresses the top, and a negative moment compresses the bottom. In a T-section, each face uses its own distance, and the bend says which face is in tension.
  • Depth counts twice in S, and width once. Doubling the depth cuts the stress to a fourth, and doubling the width cuts it to a half.