Internal Shear and Moment in Beams
Cut the beam anywhere, and either piece must still be in equilibrium.
Before this Lesson
- Beam Reactions · Statics
Lay a plank across two sawhorses and stand in the middle of it. You know how to find what each sawhorse pushes with. But if that plank ever breaks, it won't break at a sawhorse. It'll break out in the span, and the reactions say nothing about what the wood out there is going through. So try a thought experiment: saw through the plank out there, with you still standing on it. Down you go. What would you have to put back across the cut to stop that?
What the cut has to put back
- From Beam Reactions: take moments about one support for the other reaction, then sum vertical forces. Moment equations count counterclockwise as positive.
- From Distributed Loads: a uniform load is at its middle. A triangular load is , a third of its length from the high end.
Put numbers on it. The plank is 12 ft long with a sawhorse under each end, you weigh 200 lb, and you stand at the middle, so each sawhorse pushes up with 100 lb. (Ignore the plank's own weight.) Saw through it 4 ft from the left sawhorse, and look at just the left piece.
The whole plank is sitting still, so this piece is sitting still too. That's the idea this whole Lesson runs on: if a beam is in equilibrium, so is any piece of it. The only outside force on the piece is the sawhorse's 100 lb, pushing up. Alone, that would send it flying. So the wood across the cut must push down on it with 100 lb. That force across the cut is the internal shear, .
But now the piece has 100 lb up at one end and 100 lb down at the other, 4 ft away. That's a couple of 400 lb·ft, trying to spin it clockwise. It isn't spinning, so the wood across the cut must also twist it back, 400 lb·ft counterclockwise. That twist is the bending moment, . The cut has to put back both.
Now try the right piece, which has more on it: your 200 lb down, 2 ft from the cut, and 100 lb up, 8 ft from the cut. Those leave a net 100 lb down, so the cut must push up with 100 lb. Their moment about the cut is counterclockwise, so the cut must twist back 400 lb·ft clockwise. The same two sizes, in opposite directions, because whatever the left piece does to the right piece, the right piece does back. So you never need both pieces. Pick the one with fewer forces on it.
It's the same cut that finds the force in a rod in Axial Stress. With no load along the beam, there's no axial force in the cut, so and are all there is.
Why does it take both? Picture a cantilever cut in two and rejoined. A hinge passes force but no twist, so the outer piece folds. A sliding guide passes twist but no force, so the outer piece slips. Solid material has to do both jobs at every section: shear stops the sliding, and moment stops the folding.
Positive means a shape
In Beam Reactions, counterclockwise was positive. That can't work here, because the same is counterclockwise on one side of a cut and clockwise on the other, and one section would get two signs. So beams get their own convention, tied to what the beam does. The Handbook prints it in Mechanics of Materials, under Beams, as Shearing Force and Bending Moment Sign Conventions:
The bending moment is positive if it produces bending of the beam concave upward (compression in top fibers and tension in bottom fibers). The shearing force is positive if the right portion of the beam tends to shear downward with respect to the left.
Adapted from the FE Reference Handbook, Shearing Force and Bending Moment Sign Conventions
Positive moment is a smile, and negative moment is a frown. Your plank sags into a smile, with its top squeezed and its bottom stretched, so its moment is positive. Its left piece gets pushed up and its right piece gets pushed down, so its shear at that cut is positive too.
The Handbook draws only shapes, with no arrows. Translated to a cut face, they mean this:
Those are the plank's arrows exactly, so at that section, and . This figure also handles the signs for you. Always draw and positive on the cut face of the piece you keep, whichever piece that is, and solve. A negative answer then means a negative shear or moment, with nothing left to interpret.
You can often read a sign with no numbers at all. Grip the beam at the section, as if your hand were a wall, and look at one piece. Push up on it, and its free end curls up, which is part of a smile: positive moment, on either side of your hand. Push down, and it droops into a frown: negative moment. For shear, ask which way the outside forces shove that piece. Left piece up or right piece down is positive. The arrow on the cut face opposes that shove, which is why a left piece shoved up has drawn down.
| Piece | Outside forces | Moment | Shear |
|---|---|---|---|
| Left | Up | + | + |
| Left | Down | − | − |
| Right | Up | + | − |
| Right | Down | − | + |
When the outside forces point both ways, you need the numbers.
Cut, keep, balance
Here's the whole method. The Handbook prints no procedure for cutting a beam, so this one's yours to carry.
- Cut at the section and keep the piece with fewer forces.
- Find any reaction on that piece. A cantilever's free end has none.
- Draw every force on that piece, with and positive on the cut face.
- Use to find .
- Take moments about the cut to find . passes through the cut, so that equation can't see it.
A distributed load goes in as a resultant, as always, but only for the part on your piece, at the centroid of that part. The rest of the load sits on the other piece, and this one can't feel it. If the load varies along the beam, the part on your piece is its own shape, with its own height at the cut. A concentrated couple on your piece goes into the moment equation with no arm, and it never touches .
The moment equation still counts counterclockwise as positive, as it always has. comes out with the beam's sign because you drew it positive.
Two shears at a point load
Ask for the shear at a point load, and you've asked a question with two answers. Take a 12 ft simple beam with 12 kip, 4 ft from , so and . Cut just left of the load and keep the left piece. It holds only , so . Slide the cut just past the load, and the piece picks up the 12 kip: . The shear jumps by the size of the load. In the figure, stays drawn positive, so that minus sign says it really pushes up.
The moment doesn't jump. As the cut slides across, the load's arm about the cut is next to nothing, so on both sides. A reaction is a point load too, so the shear jumps at a support the same way. The jump is a small fiction, since a real load spreads over a few inches, but it's a very good model. The Handbook doesn't mention the jump. When a question wants the shear at a load or a support, look for which side it names.
Run this cut along a whole beam and you have the plots in Shear and Moment Diagrams.