Beam Reactions
Take moments about one support, and the other reaction falls out in one line.
Before this Lesson
Two sawhorses stand 10 ft apart. Across them lies a 14 ft plank weighing 80 lb, with its left end on one sawhorse and its last 4 ft sticking out past the other. You weigh 160 lb, and what you need to reach is out past the end. Everybody knows that if you walk far enough, the far end comes up and you come down. How far is far enough? Take a guess now, and hold on to it.
An equation that can't see A
- From Free-Body Diagrams and Supports: a pin gives and , a roller gives one force, and a fixed support adds . A negative answer means the opposite sense.
- From Moments and Couples: , counterclockwise positive. A couple has the same moment about every point.
- From Distributed Loads: a uniform load is at its middle. A triangular load is , a third of its length from the high end.
Start somewhere safe, standing between the sawhorses, 5 ft from . Draw the plank free. Each sawhorse pushes up and can't pull down, so each gets one arrow: and . The plank's 80 lb acts at its middle, 7 ft from .
That's two unknowns, and summing forces won't separate them. says , which is true and leaves you stuck.
So take moments about instead. The line of runs right through , so its arm is zero, and so is its moment, however big it turns out to be. The equation can't see it. Only one unknown is left:
pushes up to the right of , which turns the plank counterclockwise. Both weights push down to the right of , which turns it clockwise. Now finishes the job: . Or play the same trick about , where disappears instead, and you have a check:
That's the move for nearly every beam on the exam. The Handbook's Equilibrium Requirements, under Systems of Forces, prints and but not where to take the moments, and that choice is most of the skill. Its beam tables print no reactions either, so you'll work these out yourself.
Pins, overhangs, and spread-out loads
A real beam adds a few details, and none of them changes the move. A beam with a pin at one end and a roller at the other is simply supported, or a simple beam, and if it runs on past a support, it's overhanging. The pin at brings along with , but both act through , so moments about can't see either one. A distributed load goes in as its resultant. And a load past a support turns the beam the other way about that support, so its term takes the opposite sign. Here's the routine:
- Draw the free-body diagram, with each distributed load swapped for its resultant.
- Take moments about one support to get the reaction at the other.
- Use for the first support's vertical reaction, and moments about the other support to check it.
- Use for the pin's horizontal reaction.
A load at a slant gets resolved first. Its vertical part goes through the routine like any other load. Its horizontal part, acting along the beam, passes through both supports with no arm, so it never enters a moment equation. It goes entirely to the pin, because a roller on a level surface can't push sideways.
Walk along the plank
Back on the plank, and this time keep walking. Let be your distance from , and leave it in the equation:
So . Plot both.
Both are straight lines, because your moment about a support grows in step with your distance from it. Each foot you walk moves the same 16 lb off and onto : your 160 lb over the 10 ft span. And the two always add to 240 lb, since doesn't care where you stand. Any load on any span behaves this way, shifting per foot of travel, which is the idea that Influence Lines builds on.
Now look where hits zero: 11.5 ft from , only 1.5 ft past . How was your guess? The other 2.5 ft of that overhang is there to fool you. A sawhorse can only push, so at zero the plank is touching it with no force at all, and it's about to rise. That's lift-off. Past that, the line goes negative, which would take a sawhorse pulling down on a plank it isn't tied to. That can't happen, so the dashed part never does: the plank has already swung down about . So lift-off isn't a negative reaction. It's the load or position at which the reaction reaches zero.
You don't need the whole line to find it. Set the lifting reaction to zero, then take moments about the other support. No unknown reactions are left in that equation, only the loads on one side of the pivot against the loads on the other. The Handbook doesn't mention lift-off, so this one's yours to carry.
Trade the load for a couple
Now take a load off a beam and apply a pure twist instead: a counterclockwise couple , the Handbook's symbol in its beam tables, somewhere on a span . A couple has zero resultant, so says . The reactions are equal and opposite, which makes them a couple of their own, and only a couple can balance a couple. About , has the arm , and counts with no arm at all:
Look at what's missing from that answer: where the couple sits. A couple has the same moment about every point, so the beam can't tell.
For the sense, picture the beam turning the way the couple pushes it. Counterclockwise lifts the right end and presses the left one down, so has to hold down and has to push up. When other loads act too, the reactions add, so the couple just moves from one reaction to the other.
One honest note about that pull at . A beam just resting on a roller can't get it, as the plank showed. By convention, which the Handbook doesn't spell out, a beam problem treats its roller as able to hold down as well as push up, unless the problem says the beam rests on it or asks about lift-off.
One support, three unknowns
A cantilever has only one support, so there's no other support to take moments about. There's also no need. All three unknowns sit at the wall, and each equation catches exactly one: gives , gives , and gives .
Moments about still can't see or . is different. It's a couple, and a couple counts the same about every point, so it's the one reaction a moment equation always sees. Physically, it's the wall twisting back against every load out on the beam. Leave it off, and the beam would swing down like a door on a hinge.