Moments and Couples

A force can push and twist at once, and the moment measures the twist.

Before this Lesson

A bolt has rusted tight, and you have a wrench and 50 lb of pull. Pull across the handle near the bolt, and nothing happens. Move your hand out to the end, same 50 lb, and the bolt starts to creak. Now pull straight along the handle, away from the bolt: same 50 lb, nothing, and ten times that wouldn't help. One force, three results. The twist has to depend on something besides the force.

How far the line misses

Extend each pull into its line of action, and the three cases sort themselves out. What matters is how far that line misses the bolt. Call that miss distance dd. The twist, called the moment, is the force times the miss distance:

M=FdM = Fd
O d 50 lb a little twist O d 50 lb a lot of twist O 50 lb d = 0 no twist at all
One 50 lb pull along three different lines

The miss distance is measured the short way, at a right angle to the line, and a tilted pull shows why. Take a handle of length LL with a force FF at its end, at an angle θ\theta to the handle, and split the force in two. The part along the handle, Fcos⁡θF\cos\theta, only tugs on the bolt, like the Hook's third pull. The part across the handle, Fsin⁡θF\sin\theta, does all the twisting, with the whole handle as its lever: (Fsin⁡θ)L(F\sin\theta)L. Group that differently, and it's F(Lsin⁡θ)F(L\sin\theta). And Lsin⁡θL\sin\theta is exactly the perpendicular distance from the bolt to the line.

θ O A L F line of action d
The perpendicular distance, not the handle's length
In the right triangle, d=Lsin⁡θd = L\sin\theta.

The Handbook's Moments (Couples) entry defines the moment as the cross product M=r×F\mathbf{M} = \mathbf{r} \times \mathbf{F}, with r\mathbf{r} running from the point to the force's line of action. Its size is rFsin⁡θrF\sin\theta, and rsin⁡θr\sin\theta is dd. So M=FdM = Fd is the same thing, though the Handbook never prints it.

A moment also has a sense. Pin the body at the point, let the force push, and see which way it wants to turn. This Topic counts counterclockwise as positive and clockwise as negative, a rule the Handbook never states, though its component formula works out that way. The units are force times length: lb·ft, kip·ft, N·m, and kN·m. A kip·in is a twelfth of a kip·ft.

Worked Example A guy cable on a pole
1 of 3

A 20 ft pole stands at OO, held by a cable to a ground anchor 15 ft away. The cable's tension is 500 lb. Find the moment of the cable's pull on the pole about OO.

T = 500 lb O B A 20 ft 15 ft
A pole and its guy cable

Slide a force along its line, and nothing changes

M=FdM = Fd has no term for where along the line the force acts. So slide a force along its own line, and its moment about every point stays the same. The distance from the point to the arrow grows or shrinks, but the line hasn't moved, so dd hasn't either.

F A F B F C O d
One force at three places on its line

It matches what you'd feel. Shove a long, stiff plank lengthwise from one end, or pull it from the other, and the plank as a whole goes the same way. Inside the plank it matters, since one squeezes and the other stretches, but that's a later question. The Handbook doesn't mention sliding, so this one is yours to carry.

Two quick judgments follow. If a force's line passes through the point, d=0d = 0 and the moment is zero, however big the force is and however far away it acts. That's the pull along the handle. And to compare several forces, ignore where the arrows sit. Extend each line, read off its dd, and weigh that against the force's size. The biggest force, or the one farthest out, may not win.

Checkpoint
1 of 2
O F1 F2 F3 F4 F1 = 200 lb F2 = 100 lb F3 = 150 lb F4 = 200 lb Each square is 1 ft.
Four forces on a plate with a 1 ft grid

Which force produces the largest moment about OO, and which produces none?

A.
Largest: F1F_1. None: F4F_4.
B.
Largest: F2F_2. None: F1F_1.
C.
Largest: F3F_3. None: F1F_1.
D.
Largest: F3F_3. None: F4F_4.

When d is hard to see, use components

Finding dd can take real geometry, and there's often a way around it. Replace the force with its components. Together they do exactly what the force does, so their twists add up to its twist, and each one's arm is right there in the figure: a vertical force's arm is a horizontal distance, and a horizontal force's arm is a vertical one.

x y A F Fx Fy x y O +xFy −yFx
Each component's arm comes straight off the figure

Measure xx and yy from the moment point to any point on the force's line. In the figure, FyF_y pushes up to the right of OO, turning counterclockwise, for +xFy+xF_y. FxF_x pushes right above OO, turning clockwise, for −yFx-yF_x. Together:

Mz=xFy−yFxM_z = xF_y - yF_x

That's MzM_z as the Handbook's Moments (Couples) entry prints it, the k component of r×F\mathbf{r} \times \mathbf{F} from The Cross Product. Plug in signed values, or take each term's size as force times arm and give it a sign by which way it turns. The answer is the same.

Here's where sliding pays off. Any point on the line will do for (x,y)(x, y), so choose an easy one. Where the line crosses the horizontal through OO, y=0y = 0 and the FxF_x term vanishes. Where it crosses the vertical through OO, the FyF_y term does.

Worked Example An inclined force on a bent bar
1 of 3

A 500 lb force acts at AA, the tip of a bent bar, along the slope shown. Find its moment about OO.

O A 500 lb 2 ft 6 ft 4 3
A bent bar with a force set by a slope

Several forces: add the twists

Moments about one point are signed numbers, so the net moment of several forces is their sum. The Handbook's Systems of Forces entry writes it as M=Σ(rn×Fn)\mathbf{M} = \Sigma(\mathbf{r}_n \times \mathbf{F}_n). In practice, go force by force: size, arm, sense. Forces whose lines pass through the point drop out, an inclined force gets resolved first, and the sign of the total is the net sense. Keep every term's sign in the one sum, since a clockwise moment and a counterclockwise moment fight each other.

Checkpoint
1 of 2
O 100 lb 200 lb 150 lb 300 lb 8 ft 6 ft 3 ft
Four forces on a rectangular plate

What is the net moment of the four forces about OO?

A.
2,900 lb·ft counterclockwise
B.
1,100 lb·ft clockwise
C.
200 lb·ft counterclockwise
D.
1,100 lb·ft counterclockwise

A couple is pure twist

Turn a steering wheel with both hands: one pushes up, the other pushes down, equally hard. Their forces add to zero, so the wheel's center isn't pushed anywhere, and yet the wheel turns. That pair is a couple. The Handbook's Moments (Couples) entry defines it as two forces equal in magnitude, opposite in direction, and parallel. It stops there, so the rest is worth working out.

Take moments about a point a distance aa from the nearer force, with the two lines dd apart:

M=F(a+d)−Fa=FdM = F(a + d) - Fa = Fd

The aa cancels. That's the strange part: a couple has the same moment about every point, on the body or off it. Try it with 100 lb forces 3 ft apart, from outside the pair and from between them.

1 ft 2 ft 5 ft 8 ft 100 lb 100 lb d = 3 ft P1 P2
One couple, measured from two different points
About P1P_1: 100(8)−100(5)=300 lb⋅ft100(8) - 100(5) = 300\ \text{lb}\cdot\text{ft}. About P2P_2: 100(1)+100(2)=300 lb⋅ft100(1) + 100(2) = 300\ \text{lb}\cdot\text{ft}. Both are counterclockwise.

So a couple is usually drawn as a curved arrow with a value, and it doesn't need a location. And with no net force, no single force can replace it.

Moving a force costs a couple

A load out on a sign's arm pushes on the post's base from far away, and to see what the base feels, you'd like that force at the base. You can't just move it. At the tip, it has a moment about the base, and at the base, it has none, so you'd have changed the problem.

Here's how to move it honestly. At the new point, add the force and its opposite. They cancel, so you've added nothing. But now the original force and the opposite one form a couple, and what's left over is the same force, at the new point.

A force at A F d O A Add F up and F down at O F F F O A F at A and F up at O form a couple F M = Fd O A
Moving a force from A to O

So a force at one point equals the same force at another point, plus a couple equal to the original force's moment about the new point. That pair is a force-couple system. Sliding along the line is the free case, where that moment is zero. The Handbook doesn't describe this move, and you'll use it often: the moment at a fixed support, in Free-Body Diagrams and Supports, is this couple pushing back.

Worked Example A sign post's load, moved to its base
1 of 3

A 500 lb load acts at AA, the tip of a sign post's arm. Replace it with an equivalent force and couple at the base, OO.

O A 500 lb 10 ft 4 ft 3 4
A load at the tip of a sign post's arm

What makes two systems equivalent

Every trade so far passes one test. Two force systems are equivalent when they have the same resultant force and the same moment about any one point. One point is enough, because when you shift the moment point, the change in moment depends only on the shift and the resultant force. If the resultants match, both moments change alike, so matching at one point means matching at all of them.

The Handbook's Systems of Forces entry never says "equivalent," but its two sums, F=ΣFn\mathbf{F} = \Sigma\mathbf{F}_n and M=Σ(rn×Fn)\mathbf{M} = \Sigma(\mathbf{r}_n \times \mathbf{F}_n), are exactly the two things to compare.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

Two equal and opposite 80 N forces act along parallel lines 0.5 m apart on a plate. Which statements are true?

A.
Their moment about a point 3 m off the plate is more than 40 N·m.
B.
Their resultant force is zero.
C.
Their moment is 40 N·m about every point.
D.
Moving one of them to a different parallel line, with nothing added, leaves an equivalent system.
E.
Sliding one of them along its own line, with nothing added, leaves an equivalent system.

One force to replace them all

Now move every force in a system to one point, OO. You end up with one force, R=ΣFR = \Sigma F, and one couple, ΣM\Sigma M, the net moment about OO you already know how to find. Any couples in the system join that sum as they are, with no arm, since their moment is the same about OO as about anywhere.

If RR isn't zero, you can go one better and lose the couple. Step RR sideways off OO until its own moment about OO equals ΣM\Sigma M. It has the same force and the same moment, so it's equivalent. The distance is:

d=ΣMRd = \frac{\Sigma M}{R}

The Handbook doesn't print this, so know it cold. And dd is only a size. Place RR on the side where its moment has the same sense as ΣM\Sigma M. A downward RR to the right of OO turns clockwise, and to the left it turns counterclockwise. That can land RR past the end of the bar, which is fine: a line of action doesn't have to touch the body.

R ΣM O R d = ΣM / R O
Trading a force and couple for one force

When the forces aren't parallel, RR has both components, and the question is usually where its line crosses an axis. Put RR at the crossing, and use Mz=xRy−yRxM_z = xR_y - yR_x. On the x-axis y=0y = 0, and on the y-axis x=0x = 0, so:

x=ΣMRyy=−ΣMRxx = \frac{\Sigma M}{R_y} \qquad y = -\frac{\Sigma M}{R_x}

Keep the signs, and these give the side for you, parallel forces included.

To balance a system with one added force, make that force RR's exact opposite: the same size, the opposite direction, and on the same line. Then the total force and the total moment are both zero.

Worked Example One resultant for a loaded beam
1 of 4

Replace the forces and the couple on this beam with a single resultant, and find where it acts.

2 ft 6 ft 9 ft 200 lb 500 lb 100 lb 400 lb·ft O
Three forces and a couple on a beam

Recap

  • A moment is M=FdM = Fd, with dd the perpendicular distance from the point to the force's line, counterclockwise positive. Sliding along the line changes nothing, and a line through the point gives zero.
  • By components, Mz=xFy−yFxM_z = xF_y - yF_x, resolved at any convenient point on the line. Several moments add as signed numbers.
  • A couple has zero resultant and the same moment, FdFd, about every point.
  • Moving a force off its line takes a couple equal to its moment about the new point. Systems are equivalent when their resultants match and their moments match about any one point.
  • A single resultant acts at d=ΣM/Rd = \Sigma M/R, on the side where it turns the same way as ΣM\Sigma M.