Earth Pressure with Water and Surcharge

Water behind a wall pushes at full strength in every direction, which soil never does.

Before this Lesson

A retaining wall holds back 12 ft of sand. All summer the backfill stays dry and pushes on each foot of wall with about 2.9 kips. Then a week of rain soaks it, and since the drain at the wall's foot silted up years ago, the water rises to the top of the sand.

The water buoys the grains, and the sand's own push drops to about 1.5 kips. Yet the wall now feels 6.0 kips, more than twice its summer load. Of that, 4.5 kips is the water, and that's where this Lesson starts.

Soil gets a discount, water doesn't

In Lateral Earth Pressure, dry sand pushed sideways with only a fraction of its vertical effective stress, σh′=Kσv′\sigma'_h = K\sigma'_v, because friction lets the grains hold up part of their own weight. Water has no friction to lean on. It pushes sideways exactly as hard as it presses down, so its coefficient is 1. Behind a wall, the grains and the water push separately, and the wall feels the sum:

σh=KAσv′+u\sigma_h = K_A\sigma'_v + u

So KAK_A goes on σv′\sigma'_v alone, never on the total stress or on uu. Below the water table, σv′\sigma'_v grows at only γ′=γsat−γW\gamma' = \gamma_{sat} - \gamma_W, about half as fast as the total stress. That's the grains' discount. The water gets none.

For the opening wall, take ϕ=30∘\phi = 30^\circ, so KA=1/3K_A = 1/3, with γ=120\gamma = 120 lb/ft³ dry and γsat=125\gamma_{sat} = 125 lb/ft³ flooded. Dry, the pressure at the base is (1/3)(120)(12)=480(1/3)(120)(12) = 480 psf. Flooded, the grains press down at only γ′=125−62.4=62.6\gamma' = 125 - 62.4 = 62.6 lb/ft³, so their share drops to (1/3)(62.6)(12)=250(1/3)(62.6)(12) = 250 psf, but the water adds 62.4(12)=74962.4(12) = 749 psf at full strength. The base pressure doubles, and so does the triangle's area.

H = 12 ft 2.88 kip/ft γ = 120 lb/ft3 480 psf Dry backfill H = 12 ft 6.00 kip/ft γsat = 125 lb/ft3 Soil Water 250 psf 749 psf 999 psf Flooded to the surface Soil 1.50 kip/ft Water 4.49 kip/ft
The same 12 ft wall, with dry and flooded backfill
Pressures are drawn to one scale. Every piece starts from zero at the top, so each force acts H/3H/3 above the base.

That's the trade every water table makes. Buoyancy takes roughly γW\gamma_W off each foot of the grains' vertical stress, but they passed only about a third of it sideways, so their push drops by about KAγWK_A\gamma_W per foot, while the water adds a whole γW\gamma_W. That's why retaining walls are drained, with gravel against the back of the wall and weep holes or a perforated pipe at its foot to let the water out.

A water table partway down

More often the water table sits partway down, a depth H1H_1 below the top of the backfill, with H2H_2 of wall below it. Build σv′\sigma'_v as in Effective Stress, then multiply by KAK_A. It's σ1′=γH1\sigma'_1 = \gamma H_1 at the water table and σ2′=γH1+γ′H2\sigma'_2 = \gamma H_1 + \gamma' H_2 at the base, so the soil pressure runs from KAσ1′K_A\sigma'_1 to KAσ2′K_A\sigma'_2, widening more slowly below the water table than above it. The pore pressure grows from zero at the water table to γWH2\gamma_W H_2 at the base. Split at the water table, the soil diagram is a triangle above, and a rectangle and a triangle below. The water is a fourth piece.

γ γsat H1 H2 Soil pressure, KAσ′v KAσ′1 KAσ′2 P1 P2 P3 Water pressure, u PW γWH2
With a water table partway down, the push splits into four pieces
Each arrow marks the height where its piece acts.

Adapted from the FE Reference Handbook, Horizontal Stress Profiles and Forces

The rectangle is the piece people forget. The soil above the water table presses down with σ1′\sigma'_1 on every foot of soil below it, so its share of the push, KAσ1′K_A\sigma'_1, rides along to the base. Each piece's force is its area, acting at its centroid:

The four pieces, per unit length of wall
PieceForceActs above the base
P1P_1, soil above the water table12KAγH12\tfrac{1}{2}K_A\gamma H_1^2H2+H1/3H_2 + H_1/3
P2P_2, soil below: rectangleKAσ1′H2K_A\sigma'_1 H_2H2/2H_2/2
P3P_3, soil below: triangle12KAγ′H22\tfrac{1}{2}K_A\gamma' H_2^2H2/3H_2/3
PWP_W, water12γWH22\tfrac{1}{2}\gamma_W H_2^2H2/3H_2/3

The Handbook's Horizontal Stress Profiles and Forces draws this case, labeling the lower layer's γ2\gamma_2 the saturated unit weight. Its PA1P_{A1} is P1P_1, and its PA2P_{A2} is P2+P3P_2 + P_3 lumped together. It marks no lines of action, so split PA2P_{A2} back into its rectangle and triangle before taking moments. The water's triangle is the one from Hydrostatic Force on Plane Surfaces, acting a third of the way up its depth.

Worked Example A 15 ft wall with the water table 5 ft down
1 of 3

A retaining wall holds back 15 ft of level sand with ϕ=30∘\phi = 30^\circ. The water table is 5 ft below the top of the backfill. The sand weighs 110 lb/ft³ above the water table and 125 lb/ft³ below it, saturated. Find the active soil force and the water force on each foot of wall, and their total.

A water table rarely stays put, and a wall has to be designed for the highest one its drains allow. Here's one on the move.

Checkpoint

The drains clog behind a 10 ft wall holding back sand, and the water table rises from below the base to mid-height. Which statements are true?

A.
The active soil force falls.
B.
The total lateral force falls, because the sand below the water table is buoyed.
C.
The lateral pressure at the base of the wall rises.
D.
The total lateral force rises by exactly the water force.
E.
The total lateral force rises, but by less than the water force.

A load on top of the backfill

A parking lot, a road, or a stockpile on the backfill is a surcharge. Spread uniformly as qq per unit area, it adds qq to σv′\sigma'_v at every depth, as a widespread fill does in Changing Effective Stress, so the wall feels KAqK_A q at every depth: a rectangle the full height of the wall.

Pq=KAqHacting H/2 above the baseP_q = K_A qH \qquad \text{acting } H/2 \text{ above the base}

That's mid-height, not H/3H/3, since the surcharge pushes as hard at the top of the wall as at the bottom. The Handbook's Vertical Stress Profiles with Surcharge adds the surcharge, which it calls SS, to σ′\sigma' at every depth and leaves uu alone, but it prints no sideways version, so KAqK_A q is yours to carry. With uu unchanged, a water table leaves this piece as it is.

q KAq H Pq PA H/3 H/2 KAγH
A surcharge adds a rectangle to the soil's triangle
Checkpoint

A 5 m retaining wall holds back level sand with ϕ=33∘\phi = 33^\circ, and a parking lot puts a 12 kPa surcharge on the backfill. What overturning moment about the base does the surcharge alone add, per meter of wall?

kN·m/m

One force for the whole diagram

Each piece is a distributed load on the wall, and Distributed Loads replaces a distributed load with its area acting at its centroid. So each piece's force PiP_i acts at its own height yiy_i above the base. Add the forces for the total, and add each force times its height for the overturning moment about the base:

P=∑PiM=∑Piyiyˉ=MPP = \sum P_i \qquad M = \sum P_i y_i \qquad \bar{y} = \frac{M}{P}

The moment comes straight from the sum, so you need yˉ\bar{y} only when a question asks where the resultant acts. And the resultant sits wherever its pieces put it. A surcharge pulls it up toward mid-height, and water, piled low, drags it down.

Worked Example Where the 15 ft wall's push acts
1 of 3

For the 15 ft wall with the water table 5 ft down, P1=458.3P_1 = 458.3, P2=1,833.3P_2 = 1{,}833.3, P3=1,043.3P_3 = 1{,}043.3, and PW=3,120P_W = 3{,}120 lb/ft, a total of 6,455 lb/ft. Find their overturning moment about the base and the height at which their resultant acts.

Will the wall tip?

A cantilever retaining wall is an upside-down T of concrete: a stem on a base slab that sticks out in front as the toe and back under the backfill as the heel. The soil standing on the heel rides on the base and holds it down, so it counts as part of the wall. The active force is then figured on a vertical line up from the back of the heel, over the full height HH to the bottom of the base.

Stem Base Soil on heel W1 W2 W3 x1 x2 x3 Toe Heel Tipping PA y H
The forces on a cantilever wall, with moments about the toe
The soil on the heel, inside the dashed line, counts as part of the wall. Every arm xx is measured from the toe.

A wall that tips rotates forward about the front edge of its toe, so take every moment there. PAP_A, at height yy above the base, turns the wall forward with MO=PAyM_O = P_A y. Each weight, at a horizontal distance xx from the toe, turns it back. The Handbook's Retaining Walls gives the factor of safety as their ratio:

FSoverturning=∑MRMO∑MR=∑WixiFS_{overturning} = \frac{\sum M_R}{M_O} \qquad \sum M_R = \sum W_i x_i

The Handbook sets no minimum. Designs commonly ask for 2.0 against overturning and 1.5 against sliding, and an exam question states its own. The same entry goes on to the pressure under the toe, the eccentric-footing check from Footing Size and the Water Table, which this Lesson leaves there.

Worked Example Overturning of a 14 ft wall
1 of 2

A cantilever wall holds back level, dry sand with γ=120\gamma = 120 lb/ft³ and ϕ=30∘\phi = 30^\circ. It stands 14 ft from the backfill surface to the bottom of its 8 ft base. Per foot of wall, the weights and their distances from the toe are:

  • stem: W1=2,700W_1 = 2{,}700 lb at x1=2.75x_1 = 2.75 ft
  • base: W2=2,400W_2 = 2{,}400 lb at x2=4.00x_2 = 4.00 ft
  • soil on the heel: W3=6,480W_3 = 6{,}480 lb at x3=5.75x_3 = 5.75 ft

Find the factor of safety against overturning.

Will the wall slide?

The same thrust also tries to shove the wall forward along its base, like a crate pushed across a floor. The Handbook's Retaining Walls gives

FSsliding=(∑V)tan⁡δ+BCa+PPPAcos⁡αFS_{sliding} = \frac{(\sum V)\tan\delta + BC_a + P_P}{P_A\cos\alpha}

(∑V)tan⁡δ(\sum V)\tan\delta is base friction: the total vertical load, from the same weights as for overturning, times tan⁡δ\tan\delta as a friction coefficient. Concrete grips soil less well than soil grips soil, so δ=k1ϕ2\delta = k_1\phi_2, and an adhesion Ca=k2C2C_a = k_2 C_2 acts over the base width BB, where the 2s mark the soil under the base. The question gives k1k_1 and k2k_2, which the Handbook says range from 1/2 to 2/3. A sand has C2=0C_2 = 0, and a given friction coefficient μ\mu replaces tan⁡δ\tan\delta. The Handbook doesn't define α\alpha; it's the active force's tilt from horizontal, zero for a level backfill.

Count the passive resistance PPP_P only when the question says to. The soil in front of a toe is shallow, can be dug out or washed away, and full passive takes about ten times the movement active does, so the default leaves it out. For the 14 ft wall, with ∑V=11,580\sum V = 11{,}580 lb/ft resting on the same sand, ϕ2=30∘\phi_2 = 30^\circ, and k1=2/3k_1 = 2/3, so δ=20∘\delta = 20^\circ:

FSsliding=11,580tan⁡20∘3,920=4,2153,920=1.08FS_{sliding} = \frac{11{,}580\tan 20^\circ}{3{,}920} = \frac{4{,}215}{3{,}920} = 1.08

Now suppose the bottom of the base sat 3.5 ft below the ground in front of the toe, and the question said to count that soil. Its passive resistance is 12(3)(120)(3.5)2=2,205\tfrac{1}{2}(3)(120)(3.5)^2 = 2{,}205 lb/ft with KP=3K_P = 3, and FSFS rises to (4,215+2,205)/3,920=1.64(4{,}215 + 2{,}205)/3{,}920 = 1.64. Whether passive counts can decide whether a wall passes.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

A retaining wall's base is 9 ft wide and rests on a clayey sand with ϕ=24∘\phi = 24^\circ and c=400c = 400 psf. The vertical loads on the base total 14,000 lb/ft, and the horizontal active force is 5,200 lb/ft. With k1=k2=2/3k_1 = k_2 = 2/3, and neglecting passive resistance, what is the factor of safety against sliding?

Recap

  • Grains and water push separately, σh=KAσv′+u\sigma_h = K_A\sigma'_v + u, with σv′\sigma'_v growing at γ′\gamma' below the water table. KAK_A never goes on γsat\gamma_{sat} or on uu.
  • Water pushes with a coefficient of 1 and soil with about a third, so a rising water table adds far more thrust than buoyancy removes. That's why walls are drained.
  • A water table splits the soil's push into a triangle above it and a rectangle and a triangle below it, plus a water triangle. A surcharge adds a rectangle, KAqHK_A qH at H/2H/2. Each piece acts at its centroid, and the moment about the base is ∑Piyi\sum P_i y_i.
  • Against overturning, FS=∑MR/MOFS = \sum M_R / M_O, with moments about the toe and the soil on the heel among the weights.
  • Against sliding, friction (∑V)tan⁡δ(\sum V)\tan\delta or μ∑V\mu\sum V, plus adhesion BCaBC_a, resists PAP_A. Count PPP_P only when the question says to.